um, it's been more of a problem for atheists, um, like fred hoyle and the steady state people who hated the idea of the big bang. because if you have an eternal universe, you don't need an initial event. no, no. that - that's right. but god can create a universe with an infinite past just as he - that's not a problem for god. so - so, you would look at god in a universe that had no beginning, that had an infinite past as maybe the cause, or we can say the ontological - the - the fundamental being creator of it, but not the creator in a time process. presicely. he's, ontologically, he is prior to the universe, not necessarily temporally. god isn't really needed, uh, to light the blue touch paper, he's needed for there to be anything at all; that's the theological question, um, the question that was posed by leibniz, you know, way back, why is there something rather than nothing? that's the fundamental theological question to which god provides the answer, rather than the beginning in time. here's the common theology - which rodney challenges: everything that begins to exist has a cause.