who has a huge duty to provide freedom of information. and then there's the entire set of values that we also have to impart. the liberal constitutional democracy that represents and which it propagates is crumbling in poland hungary russia turkey. how does d.w. react to these developments. we try to refer especially to the issues in those places where we have a broadcast presence. in russia and in poland. we are trying to inform our users listeners or viewers and give them the outside perspective so. we can tell anyone what they should think that's not. and we always have to ensure that we manage to remain available to worldwide target audience. but we can guarantee freedom of information and also point out the democratic rights to luxury or negotiable in the e.u. for example. then there's a growing number of people who don't consider democratic rights to be that important who want security does that mean the voice of democracy is talking at cross purposes for more and more people. no i don't think so. i believe the important thing for us

when it comes to fulfilling freedom of information act requests, more than 90% of the freedom of informatione information -- that was requested. >> seth: it is -- i do want to call it out. you said at least some of the information. there were more highly censored then had been previous information. and sometimes the response was -- and again, 90% of the time they got a response. sometimes the response was, "we can't find that." >> well, the 10% was, "we don't have anything for you." but, look, there was a good-faith effort made to provide this information. the other thing the obama administration pioneered was using technology to -- to self-disclose information and information that had never been disclosed before. the best example of this is the -- is the -- the entry logs in the white house. people who walk in the white house, if you have a meeting with the president or some other member of the white house staff, for the 43 presidents before barack obama, that was information that had not been public. in fact, the bush administration actually went to the supreme court to try to prevent the

freedom of information act requests req disclosure of government documents that exempts the white house fr requests but the ethics groupe that the visitor logs are under t of the them subject to open records re why is this all impo anyway? president trump d mar-a-lago 25 days between inauguration day and mid may often with high level officials has the rino is meeting with the president wherever he holds meetings, especially giv intersection between the and president trump's vast business interests.s argue of the records provide potentia interest. so now it's back to court as the ethics groups challenge the justice department's deci >> next on "matter of fact" -- meet some good news and then o "national geograhic." three genius ideas. to make the world ♪ this is the new comfort food. and it starts with foster farms simply raised chicken. grown right here in california, with no antibiotics ever. a better way to grow, a better way to eat. foster farms. soledad: some genius ideas caught our eye this . they come from "national geograhic's" chasing genius competition. they to followers across

has a freedom of information request to release files relating to hillary clinton's e-mails the f.b.i. claims there's a quote lack of public interest for such a disclosure to be made. process underdog tries to shed some light. new york attorney ty clevenger has been waiting for more than a year for the f.b.i. to fulfill his freedom of information request and reveal the files on hillary clinton's e-mails only to get this response you've not sufficiently demonstrated that the public's interest in disclosure outweighs personal privacy interests of the subject. well whatever the f.b.i. thinks the public certainly made its interest in the e-mails a loud and clear these are the three questions that are coming out of that timeline that continue to drive the story i'm sorry when you use a private e-mail on a private server your privacy rights are out the window when you're the secretary of state of the united states of america you don't have privacy anymore she chose to do this because on her and i personally would like to know in a way reminds me of the nixon tapes shouldn't go away on the s

the findings are from a freedom of information request covering around half of the tower blocks in thec inquiry into the fire at grenfell tower, which didn't have a sprinkler system fitted, begins tomorrow. breakfast‘s graham satchell is in west london for is this morning. i support retrofitting. if you can save one life, it is worth doing. this cannot be optional not nice to have, it is a must have. it must be in place in the future to protect people. in 15 minutes you can see the whole of the special report about that on breakfast. the foreign secretary, borisjohnson, has arrived in the caribbean to visit the worst hurricane—hit british overseas territories. mrjohnson will see the relief effort first hand, visiting affected communities and meeting local officials. it's understood he will travel to the british virgin islands and anguilla. the trip follows criticism from people in the caribbean and senior mps that the uk's response was too slow. meanwhile, the first british holidaymakers stranded in the us and the caribbean will start arriving back in the uk this morning. since last we

to fulfill his freedom of information requests and reveal the files on hillary clinton's e-mails only to get this response not sufficiently demonstrated that the public's interest in disclosure outweighs personal privacy interests of the subject . well whatever the of the i think the public certainly made its interest in the e-mails loud and clear these are the three questions that are coming out of that timeline that continue to drive the story i'm sorry when you use a private e-mail on a private server your privacy rights are out the window when you're the secretary of state of the united states of america you don't have privacy anymore she chose to do that because on her and i personally would like to know in a way it reminds me of the nixon tapes shouldn't go away on the substance and voters do care about their enough all that fuss was being made while clinton was still running for the presidency but perhaps now the emails won't be as damaging especially given that clinton insists there was nothing classified in the first let me say that i am confident that i never sent nor receiv

tonight a freedom of information request to release files relating to hillary clinton's e-mails does claim that there's a lack of public interest for such a disclosure to be made because fran santiago has the story new york attorney tyco have injury has been waiting for more than a year for the f.b.i. to fulfill his freedom of information requests and reveal the files on hillary clinton's e-mails only to get this response you've not sufficiently demonstrated that the public's interest in disclosure outweighs personal privacy interests of the subject. well whatever the f.b.i. thinks the public certainly made its interest in the e-mails loud and clear these are the three questions that are coming out of that timeline that continue to drive the story i'm sorry when you use a private e-mail on a private server your privacy rights are out the window when you're the secretary of state of the united states of america you don't have privacy anymore she chose to do that because on her and i personally would like to know in a way reminds me of the nixon tapes shouldn't go away on the substance

that was purely political prosecution what's your plan well we are hopeful again that this freedom of information act case which is pending in the northern district of alabama will reveal enough new evidence to allow us to go forward either with discovery or with a civil rico case against all these this cast of characters and the deep money people over in mississippi the choctaw indians which provided them. money to karl rove's bag man jack avram of to you know to do me and so there is a possible civil rico case pending but you know we have to wait and see what the evidence produces so the people who perpetuated this prosecution against you and all those connections of this prosecution are they still in power today i mean you've got people like jeff sessions and eric cole jeff sachs is now the a.g. eric holder you know he's moved on back to his corporate defense firm where all he does his job is to protect wall street crooks that's what eric holder does this guy who was in charge of the department of justice that was supposed to be looking out for consumers goes back to covington and burling goes

it removed its climate change page and then got hammered with a series of freedom of information act requests as to what is going on with that and so they quickly scrambled and published an archived version but buried it back in the website. the department of interior has removed discussions of the effects of global warming from several of its pages. the department of agriculture has e-mails showing how staff in their natural resources conservation service were coached by managers to avoid the term climate change and instead use other language. that's where we are. all of those facts, the motive behind it, the fingerprints of the fossil fuel industry, the confessions by participants in those schemes, and where are we? if this -- in this room, silence. nobody will talk about it because the power of the fossil fuel industry is so strong the threats are so blood curdling that nobody dares. we cannot have a grownup factual discussion about climate change in this building either. and, of course, over in the trump administration they have completely thrown in the towel of the fossil fuel in

of justice is is hiding that that information we have. of the department of justice twice once in two thousand and six and once a couple of years ago we have a case freedom of information act case now pending in the northern district to hopefully shed some light on what is been going on but if they had if they had given me this exculpatory information back when they had it we could have a we could have found a motion for a new trial based on that information but they have hit it they've sealed it they've concealed it and they are still hiding it from me and from the public here well look there's got to be some recourse against this prosecutor out you know i've just i've known you for years full disclosure i've followed your career for a long time gone there's no way that you can let this prosecutor get away there's no way you can just say ok i tried we're going to move on i hope we're not going to do that in this case in light of all the evidence that was purely political prosecution what's your plan well we are hopeful again that this freedom of information act case which is pending in the northern district of alabama will reveal enough new evidence to

a freedom of information request was issued to the department for education. utside local authority control, the figure rose to 34% for pupils aged 11 to 13. schools are breaking the law. they do have to teach our ego to all of their students. schools we have spoken to tell us that re teachers can be hard to recruit and for many pupils and parents, the subject is not considered a priority. many insist that the legal obligation to teach re can be fulfilled in different ways. they might be using conferences, citizenship lessons, assemblies. as head of a church of england school, thatis head of a church of england school, that is what we did. we were not breaking the law. the department for a says that religious education remains compulsory for all state funded schools. american television's most prestigious awards will be handed out tonight. schmoozing before the big night, with the television industry enjoying large audiences on a range of platforms, the emmy awards will be more competitive than ever. the crown, the net flicks series about the early life of eliz

they said -- we sued under a law called the freedom of information act allowing the public to get documentsnformation act doesn't apply to the president, but it does apply to other parts of government, like the secret service which is part of the department of homeland security. they have said that all of the other records are -- are not governed by the freedom of information act. they didn't say that previously. you know, when they asked for more than a month to produce these records and then asked for an extra week extension. it's outrageous that they were ordered to produce these. they said they were going to. took a whole bunch of time and come in with basically one page with a handful of names mostly public. strikes us as completely outrageous. >> and white house visitor logs are often subject to release. right? >> right. this not our first time in this, on this issue. we have sued the bush administration and then the obama administration and ultimately worked out a settlement with the obama administration where they agreed to produce visitor logs. did it for seven years. they produced

it issued a freedom of information request to the department for education. s school census data showed that 26% of secondary schools in england made no provision for re, and in academies, which operate outside of local authority control, the figure rose to 34% amongst the 11 to 13 age group — 44% for older pupils. when it comes down to it, schools are breaking the law. they do have to teach re to all of their students. schools we've spoken to have told us that re teachers can be hard to recruit, and that, for many pupils and parents, the subject is not considered a priority. many insist that the legal obligation to teach re can be fulfilled in different ways. they might be using conferences, they might be using some of citizenship lessons, they might be using assemblies. as head of a church of england school, that's what we did. we were most definitely not breaking the law. the department for education said that it firmly believes in the importance of religious education, and that it remains compulsory for all state funded schools. tim muffett, bbc news. now

watchdog groups who filed a freedom of information act were given two documents this week. tter from the doj stating that the government believes that presidential schedule information is not subject to freedom of information act. now, to the second document. a list of only 22 names turned over by the department of homeland security. well, since taking office president trump has spent 25 days of his presidency at the place known as the winter white house. joining me now is richard painter, chief white house ethics lawyer under george w. bush. appreciate your time here. so we're talking the 22 people as far as this document that was released while visiting mar-a-lago. why wouldn't you release more? is the president hiding something here? >> well, i don't know. we asked him to release it. i'm the vice chair of citizens for responsible ethics in washington. we are the plaintiffs in that lawsuit. and we believe that the judge ordered that this information be released. the american taxpayers are paying for the president to go back and forth from mar-a-lago. we are paying for $500

it issued a freedom of information request to the department for education.

denies a freedom of information act request to release files to hillary clinton's e-mails claiming that a lack of public interest in the disclosure we speak to the lawyer behind the requests. were not when you want to first got the letter from the f.b.i. . the absurdity of trying to suggest that there was a matter of public interest. there is three pm here in moscow and you're washing our t. international with me in the karen good to have you with us this hour now we start with breaking news the u.s. led coalition against islamic state has confirmed another sick. the one civilian deaths have likely been caused by its air and artillery strikes in iraq and syria the total number of civilians it has acknowledged killing in the campaign has now risen to six hundred eighty five in the statement to the coalition it's investigating another four hundred and fifty reports of civilian casualties caused by its strikes. as the u.s. led coalition attempts to retake remaining parts of syria's rocker from eisel the u.n. warns that not enough is being done to specify in lives what we're witnessing esse

you put in the freedom of information request to get this, what did you discover? if it is one person living with another they are entitled to the 25%. it is much more rare that somebody is living by themselves at home and in that rare case they would get 100% discount. that is the equivalent to about £a00 a year typically offer a council tax bill and a year typically offer a council tax billand in many a year typically offer a council tax bill and in many cases it can be backdated which means we started campaigning on this year ago and we already have a lot of stories who have followed it through and got thousands of pounds back. we got people who were telling us, i have tried to do this and your information is wrong, the council says i cannot claim and we wanted to investigate that. we did 260 freedom of information requests and a mystery shopping exercise at 100 different councils. we found an absolute postcode lottery of the take—up of this smi discount. in some areas, 77 times more people get it than other areas and that is simply not justified by it than other

looks like the journalists have done freedom of information work, looking at the numberof informationat the number of successful cyber attacks on different british universities. they say it has doubled in the past couple of years. i think it isjust indicative of the world we are now living in, where so much more crime isjust becoming living in, where so much more crime is just becoming an living in, where so much more crime isjust becoming an online issue. the really smart criminals, they are not going around robbing banks any more. they are doing this kind of work. you think of the wealth of information that universities hold, or all sorts of different issues, technology, medical research, anything else, there is a real financial incentive to do that kind of attack. another university story, this is the head of oxford university attacking what they call pay lies of ministers? it is quite a long—running story. the various heads of universities being attacked for bringing home massive pay packages at a time when students are buckling under the debt they accumulate going to university.

a bbc freedom of information request also found that the number of abandoned calls also increased sharplyuncil says resources have been stretched by recent terror attacks and people using the 999 service for non—emergency calls. more than 100 firefighters have been battling the blaze at a warehouse in north london overnight. 20 engines we re north london overnight. 20 engines were sent to the location at white hart lane in tottenham. wattage from the scene shows a large building a light. 0ne the scene shows a large building a light. one person was taken to hospital however their injuries are not thought to be serious. john is with us today with all the day's sport. we will get to see what kind of shape the english women's football tea m kind of shape the english women's football team is in. mark sampson has been cleared of any discrimination charges. we will see how it has affected the team. the striker says it is the best team spirit they have experienced for a long time but we will see how it plays out on the pitch later. desperate to get back on the pitch. manager mark sampson have bee

the agency to general administration and also xplicit regulation saying the public can file freedom of information act request to get this information. journalists who have done requests and shined light on this, in my opinion, of taxpayer dollars. host: paul seamus ryan with ommon cause talking about government travel by cabinet secretaries and others. numbers, 202-748-8000 for democrats. republicans. for and for all others, independents, 202-748-8002. "washington post" piece on scott taken they write he's four noncommercial and military flights since mid-february, osting taxpayers more than $58,000 to fly to various parts of the country. e.p.a. provided documents outlined how his office of can given legal athourization for each trip. of legal counsel does this, what do they look at? regs i mentioned arlier, they need to justify military aircraft or charter aircraft usage, either on the effectiveness or security or communication needs not mply the fact there is an available commercial flight available at that time. heightened ere security concern fist tom price, for example, or scott pruitt to ta

kat: this comes on the heels of the person who's in charge of records at the fbi denying a freedom of informationike yourself or anybody can go and request government documents. they denied a freedom of information act request saying, there is no public interest in the hillary clinton email situation. now you hear this? what is your best guess as to what's going on? >> my best guest is the best guess i think every american has at this point. i have hillary clinton fatigue. i am glad she is no longer running for president. she is no longer the first lady. let her go away. do you honestly think she was ever going to spend the day in prison? we will cover this up until the end of time. >> jason: but do you think that we as americans have the right to be so critical -- >> 100%. 100%. but what i'm saying is she so ingratiated. the clinton machine is in the hon the -- isn't a hyundai. it's a tank. she is not going. on both sides of the aisle, they will cover this up. but kat, doesn't the rule of law prevail? isn't lady justice of supposed be blindfolded? is and she should are there special rules for cl

the justice department maintains the president's schedule is exempt from the freedom of information act. jeffrey sandusky, a son of penn state football assistant coach jerry sandusky, who was convicted of sexually abusing underage boys, is heading to prison for his own sex crimes. the 41-year-old is expected to serve six to eight years in state prison following yesterday's guilty plea for soliciting nude photos from a 16-year-old girl and asking a 15-year-old girl for oral sex. jeffrey sandusky, a former state prison guard, is one of jerry sandusky's six adopted children. he had been set to go to trial next week. the elder sandusky was convicted in a 2012 trial of molesting ten boys. veteran hollywood character actor harry dean stanton, who appeared in more than 200 movies and tv shows, died yesterday of natural causes. >> an ordinary person spends his life avoiding toans situations. repo man spends his life getting into tense situations. >> sreenivasan: the kentucky- born stanton created memorable supporting roles in such films as "repo man" and "alien," and had a rare star turn in "pa

he found a lawyer who submitted a freedom of information act request that would do no more. -- but would do no more. he was accused of sexual harassment, but he was still denied notice of the specific allegation and he remained suspended. this young man was denied due process, this pundit and without options are hope, after five years of sobriety, he relapsed and attempted to take his own life. he felt he had let down everyone who had mattered to him, including his grandmother who was looking forward to seeing the first member of her family done a cap and down. -- don a cap and gown. whatever accusers say you are is what people believe you are. that is the current reality. a student says he or she was sexually assaulted by another student on campus. if he or she is not purged to keep quiet or discouraged from reporting it to local law enforcement, the case goes to a cool -- a school administrator who will act as judge and jury. the accused may or may not be told of the allegations before decision is rendered. if there is a hearing, both the survivor and the accused may or may not be allo

he found a lawyer who submitted a freedom of information act pro bono but would do no more. he had discovered he had been accused of sexual harassment but was denied notice of the specific allegations and he remained suspended. this young man was denied due process. despond and and without options or hope -- despond and and -- dent and without options or hope -- whatever your accusers say you are, he told me, is what people leave you are. that is the current reality. here is what it looks like. a student says he or she was sexually assaulted by the student on campus. if he or she is not urged to keep quiet or discouraged from reporting it to local law enforcement, the case goes to the school administrator, who will act as the judge and jury. the accused may or may not be told of the allegations before a decision is rendered if there is a hearing, both the survivor and the accused may or may not be allowed legal representation. whatever evidence is presented may or may not shown to all parties. , if allowednesses to be called, may or may not be cross examined. and washington d

in a freedom of information request we found that the majority, 68%, of council tower blocks have a singlend just 2% have a full sprinkler system. we know they save lives, we know they can save properties and we know they make a real dirves. so 2% is a shockingly low number. can save properties and we know they make a real difference. so 2% is a shockingly low number. dany cotton led the fire service at grenfell tower. the recommendation should be that it is mandatory to fit sprinklers in all new builds, especially in places like high rises and schools. and what about retro—fitting? i support retro—fitting. for me, where you can save one life, then it's both doing, this can't be optional, it can't be nice to have, it is something that must happen and it is something that must be in place for the future to protect people. recommendations to fit sprinklers have been made at inquests and inquiries before. the government says it has encouraged local authorities to fit them, but as our figures show, those recommendations have largely been ignored. all the more surprising perhaps because indepen

glaring details from the limited logs the trump administration released as a result of the freedom of information request? >> i mean, so since the beginning of the trump administration, they've been keeping these logs and these visitor records close to their chest. essentially as just a way to set the tone for trump's presidency as something different than we've seen in the past. the glaring details are not clear just yet. i think they'll become more clear as more details come out, but it's just another way that the trump administration is trying to set the tone for their presidency as being something totally different than we've seen in the past, and i think that it's only adding to this optics issue that has plagued trump's presidency since the beginning. >> thank you so much for being here this morning. >> thank you. >> thank you for having me. >>> to london now, where police are announcing a significant arrest linked to yesterday's terror incident in a subway car. nbc's keir simmons is live with the very latest. what are you learning about this? >> reporter: well, dara, this arrest was made u

a freedom of information request also showed that two—thirds of the blocks had only one staircase.ssioner, dany cotton, said sprinklers would save lives and fitting them should be compulsory. graham satchell reports. borisjohnson is travelling to the caribbean countries hit by irma. he will visit the worst hit islands. there has been criticism that the uk's response has been too slow. hundreds of homes in nottinghamshire and lincolnshire have been left without power as storm aileen brings strong winds to parts of the uk. aileen, the first named storm this season, has hit wales, southern parts of northern england and the north midlands, with winds of up to 75mph. highways england warned of an increased risk to drivers of lorries, caravans and motorbikes who could be blown over by the storm. mums who go into labour early should be given antibiotics to prevent passing on any potentially deadly infections to their babies. that's according to new guidelines from the royal college of obstetricians and gynaecologists. group b strep is the most common cause of life—threatening infection in

suspecting many schools ignore re altogether, it issued a freedom of information request to the departmentn england made no provision for re. in academies, which operate outside of local authority control, the figure rose to 34% amongst the 11—13 age group. 44% for older pupils. when it comes down to it, schools are breaking the law. they have to teach re to all of their students. if someone is not religious and their family is not religious, why should they be studying re at school? we're not teaching children to be religious. we are teaching children about religious beliefs that are in this country. you don't only teach geography to people because they are going to be world explorers. schools we've spoken to have told us that re teachers can be hard to recruit and that for many pupils and parents, the subject is not considered a priority. and many insist the legal obligation to teach re can be fulfilled in different ways. 0ne union that represents head teachers says claims of lawbreaking are overblown. it might result from the report, trying to find a very traditional delivery model of r

he found a lawyer who submitted a freedom of information act request pro bono. only through foia was he able to discover he was accused of sexual harassment but still denied notice of the specific allegations and remained suspended. this young man was denied due process. despondent and without options or hope, he relapsed and attempted to take his own life. family e let down his . d mostly his grandmother whatever your asuesers say your he told me, is what people believe you are. that is the current reality. here's what it looks like. a student says he or she was sexually assaulted by another student on campus, if he or she isn't urged to keep quiet or report it to law enforcement, the case goes to a school administrator who will act as the judge and jury. the accused may or may not be told about a decision. if there is a hearing, the survivor and the accused may or may not be allowed legal representation. whatever evidence is presented may or may not be shown to all parties. whatever witnesses, if allowed to be called, may or may not be cross-examined. and washi

eventually he found a lawyer who submitted a freedom of information act pro bono but would do no more. only through the foya would he discover that he had been accused of sexual harassment but he was still denied notice of the specific allegations and he remains suspended. this young man was denied due process. decemb despondent and absent of home, he tried to take his overwhelm life. he felt he let down everyone who mattered to him, including his grandmother, who so looked forward to seeing the first member of her family don cap and gown. whatever your accusers say you are, he told me, is what people believe you are, that is the doesn't reality. -- current reality. here's what it looks like. a student says he or she was sexual assaulted by another student on campus, if he or she isn't urged to keep quiet or discouraged from reporting it to local law enforcement, the case goes to a schooled ed administr who will act as judge and jury, this individual may or may not be told the facts of the case before the decision is rendered. and the accused may or may not be allowed legal representa

the proviso that this is never made public it's now been made public through freedom of information act requests and so you can see some of it and it's just as shocking as those sacks of the you know the member the goldman sachs stuff and when they had to testify in front of carl levin in front of the in front of the senate right so more a buffet said when the time. wearing a bathing suit so in two thousand and eight the tide went out a serious way bernie madoff clearly was caught up and he was in a vicious j.p. morgan client j.p. morgan client and ponzi scheme and he was busted and it also revealed on the balance sheets of these big banks like i could j.p. morgan massive fraudulent behavior that as you've just described there and during that time they were also engaged in numerable instances of fraudulent behavior illegal behavior and as i said what's amazing is that back in the eighty's when i was working on wall street during the s. and l. crisis the laws that were broken at the time and fifteen hundred bankers went to jail at the time the response from regulators was not too much to

in a freedom of information request to local authorities across the uk, we found thatjust 2% of residentialr blocks have a sprinkler system fitted. we know they save lives, we know they can save properties, and we know they make a real difference. so, 2% is a shockingly low number. dany cotton led the fire service at grenfell tower. the recommendation should be that it's mandatory to fit sprinklers in all new builds, especially in places like high—rises and schools. and what about retrofitting? i support retrofitting, clearly. for me, where you can save one life, than it's worth doing. this can't be optional, it can't be a nice—to—have, this is something that must happen and it's something that must be in place for the future to protect people. recommendations to fit sprinklers have been made before. this is lakanal house in london. six people were killed in a fire here in 2009. the recommendation from the coroner in the lakanal inquest was just simply ignored, and absolutely nothing happened. it is very clear that we have a system of regulation over the fire safety of tower blocks that is

freedom of information act request demanding explanation planned sweeps on 24 ice offices. steve? for hurricane victims but it didn't take long for hold thollywood to make it political. >> anyone who believes that there is no such thing as global warming must be blind or unintelligent. steve: that's stevie wonder. and they're not the only one. these headlines doubling down their climate change attacks. the nation saying climate change denialism is literally killing us. and the other from the outline climate change denial should be a crime. well, that's new. here to react climate researcher and author of an inconvenience deception which looks at al gore's book and is actually outselling al gore. dr. roy spencer joins us from nashville today. doctor, good morning to you. >> good morning, steve. steve: it shouldn't be surprise going have you two big powerful hurricanes in a row there are going to be some people who have said we have never had that before so it must be climate change. >> we knew this was going to happen i mean in terms of the hype. because, as you know, we have gone a

minister of defense to refute the there was an accident say five lean several months ago until freedom of information request was able to assure that they were lying i mean the mislead all that they the minister of defense misled this about weapons of mass destruction in iraq so the idea of the going to mislead the. control in nuclear weapons is no surprise tell me about you've been jailed for protesting for as they tell me about fazli in scotland and the nuclear submarine base and safe safe it all is up there given what is going on in the world rate no. we could be exterminated as we speak because let's face it we become a legitimate target because of the presence of nuclear weapons for to me it was you know from edinburgh and glasgow we get an argument all the same that we should maintain this to ted and because it protects jobs know this that they're doing has a running course of one thousand million pounds when billion pounds a year and it got in ts. jobs i asked the leader of glasgow city council how many jobs they could mean teen on the beasts of one billion pounds a year and he told me twenty