le for himtile -- futi to do that. al harmain is designated by virtue of his connection to it. we have said in sworn declaration that he would eggs -- he would resign and al harmain would accept his resignation. the court has said that kind of severing of ties is relevant. regulations say that corporate reorganizations or resignations of persons from positions on a board is a basis of consideration. had we known in 2004 that that was an issue, he would have resigned at that point. we would have considered it. it would be relevant that this person know longer has any ownership or control of al harmain. we were particularly -- we were precluded from making that argument because we were never told that was an issue in the case until there was a decision made and there was nothing we can do. >> what remedy are you proposing? >> every man to the agency so that we can have a fair -- a remand to the agency so that we can have a fair hearing. the court held that when an agency failed to disclose -- in that case, it was a single report -- that renders its decision arbitrary and capricio