with the exception of tulsi gabbert who voted present. we did not know what she was going to do. >>> can you break down exactly where we go from here? it has been a long day on the hill. what happens next?>> reporter: some point in the near future house speaker nancy pelosi is expected to reveal who she would like to see as impeachment managers. at one point yesterday we thought that might happen tonight following the vote. it now looks like that could be pushed off and they could vote on that separate resolution sometime soon. we don't exactly know when the. as i was telling you before there are rumors or different mentions swirling of bay area members potentially being impeachment managers. including congressman eric swalwell. we will also have to see whether the articles of impeachment are actually withheld before being transmitted to the republican- controlled senate. there is a small group of members and potentially a growing group of members including bay area congresswoman jackie spear who think perhaps the article should be withhe

gabbert because she's got guts ok and i probably wouldn't agree with her on most of her social issues ok but she stuck to her guns being a veteran of these illegal wars and she's she says what is true and she has and she's pushed back you have the clinton machine dumped on her and she very effectively pushed back she pushed out of the race about what harris and to a large extent i mean there is a person of gravity toss and she's dumped on by the media go ahead alex. yeah remember kemal harris was the chosen one it was going to be the next obama told c gabbert took her out with one shot and the fact that she pushed back against the clinton machine was amazing i mean that one everybody over to toss it gabbert and if i can just go back to the previous topic peter using children and using whatever means necessary yet children are good yeah we have to believe children until you get to the epstein case in which case the media and all the neo liberals in the globalist don't want to talk about it but i think we have just in case perfectly so i mean this is going on you have to believe that ch

wars say it wasn't worth it in 2016 trying to gain traction for doubting foreign adventures today gabbert is doing the same why are the elite out of touch. cross talking and ending wars i'm joined by i guess daniel hsia in new york he is a professor of latin american and caribbean studies at city university of new york and but that is that we have peter because nick he is a professor of history and director of the nuclear studies institute at american university as well as co-author with all of her stone of the untold history of the united states and in washington we cross to camp he is the host and head writer of the comedy new show redacted tonight on our t.v. america all right so i mean cross talk rules in fact that means you can jump in anytime you want i always appreciate let's go to bethesda peter i think that all of us would agree and our audience that it's unlikely that we would ever compared to donald trump ok they're very very different but they do have one commonality and it's an attitude towards for. and adventures now donald trump has not been able to do much about his rhetor

. >> gabbert claims she was going to skip the debate even if she qualified so she was in new hampshire democrats may have questions on why her vote for impeachment was present. >> i couldn't vote against impeachment because i believe he is guilty of wrongdoing. i could not in good conscious vote for impeachment, because removal of a sitting president must not be the culmination of a partisan process. >> as gabbert voted last night, president trump tried to make pete a bunch line. >> buttigeig. you have to be older to know what that means. >> he minimized elizabeth warren's crowd slices. >> i'd get going to central park. he eat get a bigger crowd. but if she has the crowd, oh, this crowd -- the crowds are so big. >> and claimed early state voters are losing interest in joe biden. >> he has a big rally and they get 93 people show up. >> but biden will have a big national audience tonight, center stage at a debate, hours after rallying for a flat bed truck very carefully. >> that's okay. i'm not going to jump. >> candidates who criticized biden the most over the last few debates won't be

been able to do much about his rhetoric of the campaign while he's been in office but tell us he gabbert keeps going both of them are slammed every time they go outside the the borders or the perimeters of the bipartisan commitment to these wars why is that why do they get slammed down so hard so fast even with people within their own party go ahead peter. well as you indicate there is a bipartisan consensus when it comes to american foreign policy and it's dominated by a neo con neoconservative or a view it's based on this idea of american exceptionalism that the united states has the right duty the obligation to intervene or out or 0 if the united states is god's gift to humanity that unlike everybody else where alex was to commend evelyn you are just breath freedom and democracy but the net result of this is that we live in a war of them which the richest people have more wealth than the poorest the point 8000000000 people that us policy has been consistently interventionist one that the cold more never really and that policy change at the end or and there's been a war a war between t

democratic presidential candidate, representative tulsa gabbert of hawaii voted present on both articles. the speaker: on this vote, the yeas are 230, the nays are 197. present is one. article 1 is adopted. the speaker: on this vote the yeas are 229. are 198. present is one. article 2 is adopted. the speaker pro tempore: without objection, the motion to on ider article 1 is laid the table. without objection, the motion to econsider article 2 is laid on the table. pursuant to section 7-b of house resolution

parable and i think tosi gabbert is this as a so candidate for president who is really running on this you know antiwar platform that's the things that we'd like to hear from her that's what i wanted to hear from her and i think that would have made a little bit more sense of that kind of excuse for saying president which i'm president right now too i wish i could have said that at the beginning that i would have to be saying all this but at the end of the story is look the bottom line is if she just didn't explain herself i think there was no there and i think is actually going to go it's could be a big negative for her and i don't think this is going to resonate for has been around by the way telsey as a major league as a ron. and not saying it's a strike not saying it's not but remember when arlen specter during the clinton he said not prove always wants to be the she's that asterisk in history but let me tell you something she has got a big future don't run. eliminate her present and also beauty gig. he added i don't particularly but watch these but she is she what was so good abou

well presence the congresswoman out of hawaii and current democratic presidential candidate tells me gabbert made a 1st wednesday night in the nation's history of impeachment vote by choosing to vote not yay or nay but present. cue the thunderous rebuke from capitol hill so the presidential impeachment moving forward and tells the gathered standing president let's start watching the hawks. that i got. when watching the hawks i am 2 tyro of an attorney joining me today as my unimpeachable teachable panel of r t america all-stars lion-el of lynell media r t correspondent sara month and the host of the big picture holland cook and from toronto we want to only to america correspondent alex you all for coming on today. all right so look i know that we all have an opinion or an observation the biggest story in the united states today the impeachment of one bottle from. you know that stain on this presidential jacket what are your initial thoughts let's start with sir well i spent a lot of time yesterday covering the impeachment throughout the day so just to just to kind of reiterate it just seems

. >> congresswoman tulsi gabbert is causing a stir after voting present. but a neutral vote. neil is calling on her to step down. gabbert announced she's not running for reelection. >> one of the candidates stand on pelosi withholding those articles of impeachment? >> that's a big question how long she'll hold onto articles. senators, book klobuchar all expected to be on the campaign trail. michael bloomberg he's pushing for a trial as soon as possible. listen. >> i think they should have a trial. whatever the evidence is, that's what the constitution calls for. i think we deserve nothing less. >> senator cory booker tweeted about a future trial where he would be a juror. this trial demands a thorough review of the evidence. we must be rented with witnesses and documents. if it's in january or february, that's right in the middle of important campaigning and iowa new hampshire. state of the union is february 4th a day after the iowa caucuses. it's going to be busy with the trial, with the state of the union, lot going on and these people on the campaign trial not taking much

susan, i wonder what do you think the rational is behind gabbert's position on this. does it play well for her politically or undermine everything else the democrats are trying to do? >> i think she's just looking for attention, frankly, this was a way of her getting it and she's hoping that keeps her raising money to continue. she hasn't made the last debate, i don't think she's making the next one, i think this is just a desperate attempt for attention. >> julia, i want you to weigh in on that. if this is a desperate play for attention is it working? >> i think it feeds to tulsi gabbard's pace. i think tulsi gabbard has an interesting base, anti-establishment, a bit alternative to that democratic establishment and they don't necessarily like to see her fit into that mold of the joe bidens or the elizabeth warrens. they want to see a new kind of candidate. i guess that helps her there. but it's interesting to look at tulsi gabbert -- her other fans, she actually has quite a bit of fans and supporters on the right side of the aisle, the republican side of the aisle. y

articles, but we did see some democrats trade there one president vote on both articles that was tulsa gabbert who happens also to be running for presiden she did say in a statement that she wanted to beat the center this vote and she wanted to introduce a resotion to censure the president instead of impeach him she's trying appeato kind of the thmiddle of the country to the center of her base that she knows supports we did see 2 democrats we expected to vote no on both articleand then we saw a 3rd democrat kind of shake up the second article vote he's a mocrat from maine and he voted yes for the first article of these of power and no for the second article obtruction of congress d so we still saw little movement there but for the most part very predictable night and the house closing after hours of debate on a pretty somber note. >>jesse what's next we're about to eer the christmas and new year's holidays nd that the senate is expected to pick up the matter but i guess thas not a 100% certainty, what is your expectation in terms of what happens next. >>shuri a ly the only certainty that e kno

. >> and tulsi gabbert of hawaii, a democratic presidential candidate voted present and she just released a statement. let me read the statement. "i am standing in the center and have decided to vote present. i could not in good conscience vote against impeachment because i believe president trump is guilty of wrongdoing. i also in good conscience could not vote for impeachment because removal of a sitting president should not be the culmination of a partisan process fueled by trials and animosities that have so gravely divided our country. >> is she saying it should be ub a -- unanimous? >> she simply voted present. >> we have heard more moderate people from the republican party and others talk about how they did not have 100% support for the roprocess. congressman golden from maine voted for article i and against article ii. tull sif gsi gabbert is a uniqu individual and she takes a lot of heat. >> anderson cooper, more reaction coming in. >> it's interesting because we were talking before about the poe ttential ramifications at t ballot box. democrats have been repeatedly making the ar

it wasn't worth it in 2016 trying to gain traction for doubting foreign adventures today told see gabbert is doing the same.

no on the 1st count as well we also had one democrat who chose to vote present this was told see gabbert who is a presidential candidate among the democratic field and who has been trying to eke out her position as the most conservative option among that among the candidates there but again really no big surprises here almost of the i'm going to interrupt you because we. are hearing from house speaker nancy pelosi now so that's listen to that. good evening. december 18th. a great day to the constitution of the united states a sad one for america that the president's reckless activities necessitated us our having to interviews articles of impeachment mad that our 6 chairs were for a long period of time have been legislated investigating and litigating. today that came to our culmination on the floor of the house. committee under the leadership of harry neither of new york and meet him to tell us his committee under the leadership of adam schiff of california broccoli articles of impeachment to the floor to a conclusion where they have passed i thank them for their tremendous leadership i

or news this tech giants however have been blamed for screwing up a bit of campaigning like when gabbertfor instance challenged google for taking down her ads this alarming trend has been growing with tech giants continuing to silence voices and restrict access to information this concentration of power and influence is a direct threat to our democracy by the way did you know about this side to it 29000 saw the list. facebook moderators claiming to have p.t.s.d. growing with a former employee suing the social media giant even though the company said it was offering all the required support. well no point in digging too deep if the story's repeating itself twitter has mastered the art of new era suspensions and bans to the vagueness of the rules probably isn't so much to worry about so you can get in trouble for it can be many things from supporting join a songe to pulling a prank on the fans of the cats movie but just keep in mind what kind of folks you made.

and if anyone questions it it's dead they're called right hillary clinton called gabbert a russian asset that is completely not allowed to question our military industrial complex and if you are you are pushed out by the 2 corporate parties you are you are purged from them like something they needed to vomit up because you dared question these things and as you mentioned earlier in the few instances that donald trump has tried to do something that was against war against death against our military such as withdraw troops or peace with north korea he is shut down and you know that is not to say he's some kind of dove. that obama dropped 26000 drone bombs his final year in office and with under trumpet went up to 40000 a year or so he has no dog it's a bomb every 12 minutes you know there's blood on all of our hands as americans and but in those few instances where he does seem like he has some desire to create peace or to limit war he is completely shut down and it raises the question have we seen basically a soft coup in terms of foreign policy if it's completely run by our military indu

chelsea gabbert of hawaii voted present. and one former republican, an independent from michigan, voted with the democrats. >> they shouldn't even be allowed to have an impeachment. >> reporter: president trump lashed out at a rally in michigan. >> democrat lawmakers are not believe you have the right to select your own president. >> the president is still president today. be president tomorrow. and he's gonna be president after 2020. >> we have done what we have set out to do. the house has acted on a very sad day to protect and defend the constitution of the united states. >> reporter: interestingly tonight, speaker pelosi said she will not send the articles of impeachment to the republican-controlled senate for the trial until the senate has decided to the procedures. >>> the number of people who were at the san francisco attempt event space to watch the impeachment proceedings were told some people stayed to watch the entire six-hour debate and the votes that followed. some said it was a somber day and they were glad to

. >> congresswoman gabbert weighed in on this. >> we all know that trump won't be found guilty and removedy the u.s. senate. the impeachment in my view will actually increase his support among voters. it will make him harder to defeat. further more the house impeachment has increased the likelihood that republicans will take over the house of representatives. >> when i watch her on video, all i can think about is "saturday night live." she is playing a weird spoiler role trying to warn democrats this may be a political loser. you hear from house members who voted for impeachment yes it might be. it was the right thing to do. how do you handicap this politically? i am not sure we can. >> that's an interesting question. she doesn't provide a viable alternative. she is like the ref that points it out but doesn't give you a result. and the motion to dismiss or going through the trial. as we discuss the merits of having witnesses called. senate collins said i will wait and hear the evidence and then determine whether my analis is augmented with witnesses. as long as this keeps going, they have

we were supposed to have chelsea gabbert on but unfortunately she canceled at the last minute.left out of the makeup cherished, she got a phone call, we don't know what went on, whatever happened with her we hope everything is a okay. but just after she canceled she tweeted quote for a number of reasons i have decided not to attend the timber 19th debate regardless of whether or not they are qualifying pulse. i instead choose to spend that precious time directly meeting with and hearing from the people of new hampshire and south carolina. so i guess she's not in the debate. she was super close she was one pole away from qualifying. if we get anymore updates, will bring them to you. right here. but coming up the washington post has a bomb shelter report detailing how the us government and military lied to us about the war in afghanistan. will we ever get out of that hellhole? coming up, stay with me. my body is truly powerful. i have the power to lower my blood sugar and a1c. because i can still make my own insulin. and trulicity activates my body to release it like it's suppose

eastern tulsiawaii congress ma'am gabbert in hudson, new hampshire. unday at 2:00 p.m. eastern, former vice president joe biden in peterborough, new hampshire. 2:00 p.m. eastern entrepreneur yang in new tuesday atnd