geoffrey thomas geoffrey what more can you tell us about the circumstances of this crash is there any indication what might have caused it. look there are a couple of scripts from asian from passengers from passenger interviews one person talked about a large bang just off the tiger off another person however spoke of a loud shot up and the plane vibrating now that could have been caused by an ice buildup on the wing the plane possibly may not have been dion asked and when the plane took off the air over the wing. broke up and we get into an aerodynamic stronghold and the classic symptom of a classic sign of that if you like is a shattering of the aircraft and then a kind it crash back down he got to a 40 feet into the air the large bang however could have been associated with an engine failure so there's 2 possibilities but of course it's very early on very difficult to say with any precise. accuracy at this stage what can you tell us about the safety record of the plane involved here and the airline that operated. look it's difficult 100 years or 100000 seat aircraft. was produced over 20 years ago by the famous father company of holland who have a long rich history of building very robust airplanes and the fact that in this particular case the fuel tanks didn't rupture citing i would cite countless numbers of laws is testimony to the strength of the the stalker wing where the fuel tanks out. and the elyse becket been operating services passenger service since 2011 they've got i fuck a 100. and not from a couple of incidents they've had no fatalities or told so they've got a they've got a good record they're a low cost airline with apparently no particular problem at all in their operation geoffrey thank you very much for bringing us up to date was aviation expert geoffrey thomas india is seeing fresh protests over a new immigration law that critics see as anti muslim it grants amnesty to undocumented migrants from 3 neighboring countries but only if they are not muslim india's prime minister narendra modi says the law aims to help religious minorities from neighboring muslim majority countries but many of india's own citizens raged at least 25 have died in protests across the country. a sea of defiance it is the biggest challenge to new render a movie since he came to power in 24th for the thousands here it is a battle for india's constitution to look at what we are saying is if you're not something else who is there for the against and. also obviously hindu if this is in the rest of the country 40 percent of you know. if there are. 4 weeks protests have raged against a law that grant citizenship to refugees from neighboring countries but not muslims some see it as islamophobia