on and geoffrey tucker of the american institute for economic research ben let's start with you give us a rundown of what this committee says it found. yeah so this whole talk about evidence that they found proof they found is that really they're essentially what they have is a bunch of telecom insiders venture capitalists who came in testify before this committee and essentially what they said was we know that the chinese government has given money to while away in order to build it up one venture capitalist said that over the course of about 3 years of the chinese government put about 75 $1000000000.00 into wall way now does he know this for sure he claims that he does but let's say that it's true $75000000000.00 has been poured into weiwei he says in order to be able for that company to sell its technology at an incredibly low price point which is allowed to kind of outbid its competitors ok that can be an accusation in and of itself but here's the problem sara is that that accusation has nothing to do with the accusation that is supposedly keeping walk away from being able to do