there were lots of things not right about george, that were not good about george iii. he was tremendously self-righteous. he never thought he did anything wrong, which considering that he was king at the time of the greatest strategic catastrophe to overcome britain between the loss of the lands in the 15th century and the fall of france in 1940 was quite extraordinary. but he never recognized that he did anything wrong. he also i have to say had a sense of humor that is best described as hanoverian. what's the opposite of comedy? germany. he was not a -- he was not a particularly funny man. he tried to be funny on occasion and it was a disaster. but nonetheless, this book fortunately does have lots of jokes in it, owing to the fact that, of course, the 18th century was an absolute high point of reparty and wit and parliamentary debating their points and so on. i know you heard my joke, but it's my favorite joke which is when the earl of sandwich who told john wilkes, the radical journalist, that he was either going to die of the pox or on the gallows and john wilkes s

i don't know, even george.l negotiate, i will talk with the children, i will talk with andryusha, i will talk with andryusha, if he wants to return home again. well, let the younger children, let her have two, i will help. and, as it were, what can i do to them andryusha matvey yegor i loved you, i love you and will love you. yes, vladimir putin celebrated cosmonautics day at the vostochny cosmodrome. all the details of the working trip of the national leader are in the material of nikita korobenkov. isolate russia from the west the answers of putin and lukashenko will turn out, and roman sobol listened to the special operations sanctions in the prospects of the economy and the union state. mariupol almost completely came under the control of the donetsk people's republic. today a large group of foreign journalists arrived in the city for the first time. read more omar magomedov

however, george washington george the third got even with jefferson. i'm a biographer of john adams and when john visited the king the king said as you said it was very complimentary to him, but at the same time at the end of these talk he said i'm very glad that it was you who were chosen to be the first minister to britain and when thomas jefferson who was then? american minister to france visited george the third turned us back on jefferson. i don't believe that's true i go into this in some detail. i think that jefferson's memory 40 years later in his autobiography is incorrect. he makes three or four statements factual statements in that paragraph, which can be proved not to be true. and i think that he was remembering with advantages as shakespeare put it but let me go back to another and and it's in the book and you can take issue with you with it if you disagree, but i i think that once you read it, i really do think that you will appreciate that. he wasn't being rude to jefferson even though jefferson needless to say jolly well deserved it aft

it is george was saying right here. and so what would be all one for all one, all for $1.00 and $1.00 for all can turn into a, a situation where an article by just completely falls apart. it's like sand in your hands because you're not going to get all 30 members of the alliance that go along with it. and this is a situation that brussels is probably very worried about are absolutely right. and when nato was expand, you 19 mile. all russia want russell wasn't that you are taking caucus with their huge all police, but then we were pulling them was already already to move groups. so there is some order. there were all kinds of statements made, you know, whether they're still gone, for most of the day to lead the spectrum of things over the last 10 years that you know the work. i've been a huge and rational sending volunteers and bullet was suggesting that if you do the thing, you know, and it was, there were some, or if volunteers as you, even though it's a very dangerous game with all the nato countries in law, not have

all right, george george. you know, i think when we look back in history here, when, if sweden were to join nato, i think there will be a future store and say, alba and neutrality we had a good deal. ok. i mean, what happened here? last 20 seconds. go to george. yes. no question. what if sweet enough and don't want to join us, nate roches, borders direct borders with nato will double that cannot induce great deal of anxiety in russia, particularly in the context of everything that's been going on. the western propaganda and everything that makes life very, very dangerous for the friends, because this isn't the right time to be joining a turning. it's a turning article, buying into some kind of stupid drinking game, you know, on a college campus. ok, that's my opinion here. as all the time we have want to think, my guess in budapest and here in moscow when i think our viewers from watching us here at r t c and see you next, i'm remember. ah, ah, for is your media a reflection of reality? in the world transforme

george? yes, i, you know, you raise an excellent question because it's now clear that the nato powers are called religions. i mean, they're, they're only talking about delivering arms to ukraine. we don't know how much is actually getting in out overnight. the was a record of a transport plane hadn't been shut down there or there. so i know that that may be true if true. then you wonder why haven't i been more a transport planes a shot down. but once you article belligerent then i, you know, it is all bets are off. i don't really see why it would be unacceptable that the russians do think it's unacceptable. why it would be an acceptable to say, attack of military base in poland. that is the, that is engaged in packing and dispatching arms to ukraine that will be used to kill russians and say, well, yes, do you see an active direction again, still not on the fact that with you, you are a co religion and everything that you do all the constant propaganda campaign and open sabotage of any piece

george ribbon simultaneously with the action, st. george's ribbon, all over the country. people plant trees in memory of those who died in during the great patriotic war gardens of memory appear. it is necessary to make such a memory everywhere under the windows of house 50 on frunzenskaya embankment in moscow, residents of the house and volunteers. planting christmas trees actress olesya zheleznyak decided to dedicate her tree to the memory of a relative of a war veteran for an international action. the garden of memory joins, armenia in the victory park in yerevan sounds the legendary katyusha song 200 volunteers plant trees. uh, among the participants of the action, the extraordinary plenipotentiary ambassadors of belarus are only ministan, kazakhstan and russia here in in armenia, the memory of the war is not distorted by being guarded. e. it is very important for me that at all levels, from the leadership of the country to the end. and every citizen is an ordinary citizen. uh, the memory of the war is preserved informally preserved in the souls of people preserved in

george? yes, i, you know, you raise an excellent question because it's now clear that the nato powers are co religions. i mean, they're, they're only talking about delivering arms to grant. we don't know how much is actually getting in out overnight. the was a report of a transport lane hadn't been shut down there on this up. i know that that may be true if true, then you wonder why haven't i been more a transport planes a shot down. but once you article belligerent then i, you know, it's in the old bed, it's all, i don't really see why it would be unacceptable that the russians do think it's unacceptable. why it would be an acceptable to say, attack military base in poland. that is the, that he's engaged in packing dispatching arms to ukraine. that will be used to kill russians and say, well, yeah, do you see an active direction again? so when i was on the regression figures you, you are a co religion and everything that you do, all the constant propaganda campaign and open sabotage of any p

george, let's go to the front — fate. we shall see. george, let's go to the front page — fate.see. george, let's go to the front page of— fate. we shall see. george, let's go to the front page of the _ fate. we shall see. george, let's go to the front page of the times, - fate. we shall see. george, let's go i to the front page of the times, same story, different photo. the headline is french election in balance after narrow macron when. == is french election in balance after narrow macron when.— is french election in balance after narrow macron when. -- win. emmanuel macron's lead — narrow macron when. -- win. emmanuel macron's lead in — narrow macron when. -- win. emmanuel macron's lead in the _ narrow macron when. -- win. emmanuel macron's lead in the first _ narrow macron when. -- win. emmanuel macron's lead in the first round - narrow macron when. -- win. emmanuel macron's lead in the first round is - macron's lead in the first round is actually— macron's lead in the first round is actually larger than it was in 2017, but for— actually larger than it was in 2017, but for t

it's entirely possible the world would not have heard of george washington. he was a virginia planter and he would have lived his life as a virginia planter and that would have been that norwood people goaded thomas jefferson to write the -- people would have heard of benjamin franklin because he was this world-famous scientist and as i say he was in and busiest of the british empire but he turned against the british empire and the striking thing about franklin is it's fairly common to think of rebellion or revolution as a young person's game, a younger generation revolting against the old generation. they think the folks didn't get it right in and benjamin franklin's case he was 70 years old when he became a rebel and an franklin's case it allows me to tell an interesting side in a personal site of the same story of william franklin who is the another figure that i focus on the william franklin remains a loyalists. benjamin franklin became a rebel and william franklin became the loyalists in the sun was the more conservative one. the sun was the one who stuc

let me welcome george gilder to independent conversations. hi, george. [inaudible] >> it's a pleasure to see youou again. i met george gilder first, i met your first i think it was sort of deep in the winter of maybe january of 1982 in western new york, and you had recently published "wealth in poverty" like the year before i think. was it "wealth in poverty" published in 1981? >> 1980. >> 19800, which is -- [inaudible] and i think president reagan's love the book if i remember hearing he read it at some time. did you hear that story? >> while, he wrote me letters about it before publication. he read articles, excerpts from it. it wasxc excerpted all over the place before it came out and it made me president reagan's most quoted living author. >> mac wow. it was a fabulous book. your creativity in saying what others didn't see about the system of free exchange so-called capitalism when you analogized it -- what was exchange thing among the t natie american tribes? >> there's the japanese one. there's a whole bunch of different ways, but -- >> the tribes

we will speak to george magness, oxford china research associate this hour. francine: let's not forget china as well. for the moment, futures are seeing a bit of a lift. risk appetite back after the pboc stepping in. tom: this supportive rhetoric from the pboc and the response from china's policy makers has been rather muted in the last weeks and months as they way out the length downs -- the lockdowns in shanghai. will they actually pull out the big bazooka following the meeting that takes place later this week in beijing that will be closely watched. the msci asia pacific is in the drain, but the mainland shares -- in the green, but that mainland shares with some doubts amongst investors as to how far officials in china are really prepared to go. in the european space, solid gains of around 1.4% on the spanish ibex, 1.1% on the ftse 100, and the cac 40 up .9%, reversing heavier losses we saw yesterday. wall street ending in the dream. let's see how stocks are lining up for the futures stateside. it really is about china and earnings today. the central bank

george gilder,.hat's for him to run. >> expect the domination of the theory of the information theory ofeconomics . which prohibits really anticipating the future. the future is based on human creativity. and as princeton hirschman declared, creativity always comes with a surprise to it. and that's no deterministic theory of economics. no deterministic theory of mind. can create a new future. and what differentiates our age from the stone age is not refinement of stones. it's the advance of knowledge. knowledge as well. it's learning and it's all constrained by the passage of time which is what remains scarce when all else grows abundant. so the future unless it's going to be just more of the same in other words, a degeneration it's got to surprise us. and i believe that in 30 years going to live in a world that is would be almost incomprehensible in some ways technologically from the world we live in today. it will go beyond silicon. i think we all produce and are intelligent machines will depend on

george ribbon.re, apparently, there will be some cries of opposition, somewhere there will be. uh, unfortunately, even the police, probably, are dispersing this baltic, but nevertheless we are counting on the courage of our compatriots, who will want to say theirs to support russia now in moscow goes. to hand over like this a symbol of endless gratitude for the victory in the most terrible war in the history of mankind maria thank you to our colleague olga ramikova from the headquarters of russia today in moscow where the st. george ribbon action officially started. russia completed the construction of the first cross-border railway bridge across the amur river, which will connect our country with china, do you work simultaneously from both sides ? well, in fact, the new export route, the turnover of cargo transportation can exceed 24 million tons per year, ksenia's report for the first time in history, a train rides over the amur towards china, a railway bridge now connects two states on one side,

in the case of george washington george washington didn't have to win the war. they had to avoid losing the war because soonerad or later the british say it just isn't worth it anymore and in this regard position of the two sides in the american revolution were not symmetrical because the americans were fighting for their mere existence and if this didn't work this thing in the united states would be destroyed and that would be the end of it. it was no means the end of the british empire and there was british home territory. it was easier forth the britisho say enough is enough the war is over then it would have been for the americans because they would have had to give up this thing and there was the small fact that they were identified as traders by the british government and there were penalties to pay for them. >> and you also talk about how the rivalry between britain and france impacted how not only the american revolutionary warti was fought at the french and indian waren before it and how critical french support was to be ultimate victory of the colonist

george soros donated more than two million dollars to george gascony campaign, but he wasn'tver the lone ceo of netflix. reed hastings and his wifemp patty quillanai donated two poi> $1 million. oh , yeah, this iss all funded by soros and company and reed hastings. >> alld the billionaires in the bay area, the only significant elected official in los angeles who opposes george gascon is the county sheriff. alex, the, the t the problem is t here in l.a. in cityhe and couny government, they occupy every single seat. there iss no other point of view other than that , wolf.ea ideology have to operate in the> real world, not their fake fantasy from 2019 to 2020 one we spend 94% increase in homicides, which is mind boggling increase. i can't get the board of supervisors to even admit that homicides are going up 95% . i think the understatement of the year would be to say that there's no love lost between george gascon and l.a. county sheriff alex fauci in a wayov over theire por opposites. my lack of relationship with the d.a. is unprecedent i've had c one phone call with him since he's taken

looking at george w. bush's immediate response to 9/11 which was really quite quite inspiring story. what do you think of his post-president? well, his second one i do is his work with aids in africa. he saved a lot of lives working with all sorts of people, you know, bono and you know all the it's real life saved that george w bush very getting the money there to fight you know that campaign against aids and africa. he didn't have to do that. it wasn't constituent politics it that i think came out of his christianity. his time in dallas, you know, he's involved the library. there's well-built southern methodist university runs it well i went and spoke there not long ago to a group. it's very well integrated with the university and that's a hot school now kids want to go to southern methodist university in george w. bush's love george and laura are adored in dallas. i can't you can't put words of how much love there is towards them as a couple they do a lot of local focus on local groups. he does his woun

the status quo worked really well for george washington. and so it should be a little bit of a puzzle as to why george washington became a revolutionary. now,er but because we grow up, f course he is the leader of the revolution, it's obvious he's going to become -- it was an obvious at all and that's part of the story at a try to tell here i look at george washington ending and anything franklin. benjamin franklin was another really unlikely revolutionary because franklin, if the status quo work for george washington, it would work even better for benjamin franklin. he had become world-famous within the british empire. george washington was never come well come wasn't a very excitable character. so we didn't get excited about the british empire. benjamin franklin was an enthusiast of the british empire. he thought that british empire was greatest thing going, and well he might have because it was within the britishsh empire and under the auspices in which the opportunities the british empire provided that benjamin franklin became, well, th

george. yeah, that's right. that's right. but of course, was that cheap, but a definite pattern in all of western foreign policy is that off the everything goes now. it's like, well, we didn't really expect this to happen then maybe it was a mistake to press for a major membership where you brain maybe it was a mistake to dismiss rushes concerns in such a peremptory badger where the same thing of the vietnam had the same things off the iraq, same things are not having maybe we shouldn't have issue that we made them to so yeah, there was happens. but the extraordinary thing is that economics and finance is something that you would expect. western leaders on the bad. i mean, they live for this was the capital one thing they know it's, you know, we can all makes and yet give a, let me, whoa, we didn't realize that russia is a lot less dependent on international trade than we are. and so therefore, when we impose sanctions, we are going to be hurt more than russia as we think the interest his st

me issue, george. it's a very, very interesting because the, initially, i think fox news wanted to play in the way that i've always laid the cold war. horrible. e will russia horrible evils? soviet union, breast yeah. of course, job style and versus the freedom loving peoples of the world. and they realize that their audience, that would, is just simply wasn't buying it. i mean, the birthplace american have very serious economic problems of their own growing inflation out of the control border crime. and so i'm, but above all, i think there's a, there's a feeling among americans that this was a war instigated by the biking group. i mean that the, you know, there's some feeling that may not follow things as closely as we do, whether the feeling that the biden biden's family, the obama, by ministration, all of these characters, they have their hands up to their elbows in the ukraine. and therefore, think americans and the rest of the world to pay for their own hubris and their corruption, the corruption

george w. bush and barbara bush were very better baker not doing more to say 41 and that was already in their relationship but you know where a friendship and, begins where it ends and on the day w was dies he accuses him, the person who came to his house not once, not twice but three times that day with jim baker. the guy standing there at his bedside running is the was jim baker. that's a friendship that goes beyond aypolitics in a way we haven'tseen in modern times . >> is interesting, as he said he probably wouldn't have wanted to politics as such except for was. he wasn't a political animal intexas . he once ran for attorney general and lost and a very uninspired campaign. but then he's brought to washington and then when reagan becomes president and gets into trouble, he's brought into the white house and he's sort of, you described his job as the ship detector. he becomes very you know, hands on, pragmatic. he works with democrats and republicans he's really tough . is that a good descri

he said to george h.w. lush my wife is dying of cancer and i want to spend the next few months spending time trying to make her life is good as possible. this is something strong and powerful. wend asked baker and they descre each other as brothers. that doesn't mean they love each other over time. who of us to never leisure problems with their siblings? they had to bring rivalry into politics. like the time baker told bush he wasn't going to win. maybe he should have picked it enjohn sununu as as stafford dan quayle as vice and he shouldn't say things like read my lips. the tension between them was the biggest in 1992 comes along and bush wants bigger to come back and run his re-election campaign. bush word hitter at taker for not doing more to saven 41. but you knowri where friendship the said the bush the person you was held not once, not twice. three that paper. he was standing at his bedside in the 41st president of the united states died rubbing his feet. it was jim jim baker but it's a friendship tha

george bush says to him come work on my campaign.t will help you with your greasy and he found he loved it. youus find that one thing you he a passion for and you grab onto it. the wife's passing was a way of starting a new. >> confession time, i haven't read the book either but i want to. hearing you talk about jim baker's career and trajectory and until he actually gets to power, hearing all of that in 2021 is a no-brainer. my question is is there anything that can be applicable to the career or is it just look how things used to work and now there is now. >> individual agency matters. that is part of the take away of the story and the structure of the politics matters. we can talk about it and chris can tell you better than i can in the 1980s when jim baker was at his height, half of the states had delegations that were split. there were democratic senators that voted republican or vice versa. this was a country where there were competitive elections within states and parties and he was apolitical but he also came from the south f

george and your relatives, who are supported.latives support me, because they watched this whole picture from the very beginning, george's brother also doubts that he is the blood uncle of your children, alexei bukuvin. hello hello alexei , you began to doubt your nephews only when georges doubted them. i am began to doubt from the moment when zinaida began to leave home. children do not resemble zhora not in the shape of the face, not in the shape of the eyes. the younger one has some dark eyes. although, in principle, our breed at first, they lived normally, but after, when, after, in my opinion, the second child, zinaida began to possess a person, she left the house , it was gone for a week or two months of zinail, let's sit, sit, listen to this man first. he knows nothing in our life at all, he himself is ill-bred not one of his child. he paid alimony all his life. yes, alexei brother often complained to you. yes, it's uh, constantly, and how could we support him, what did he say? what exactly did he complain about that his w

george: yeah.ow, and continuing what he was doing with the tournament, and this year we had a good time. we had a good time day and night. i think bob would have been very proud of what the stamp i put on that thing. and i got--clint eastwood played, and jimmy kimmel played, don cheadle played, de la jolla played right before we went in the training, and i played with sam, and cheech, and andy, and huey lewis. i mean, big guys. you know, guys like that i hadn't seen in a long time there. but, i mean, think about it, damian. you know, i hid lemons in my backyard when i was 12, and then at 45 i'm the only celebrity-- forget about what color i am. i'm the only celebrity who hosts a pga tour event. you know, color is inconsequential. watch out little big words. is when you're doing stuff, you know-- damian: five syllables. george: i don't put any limits on because of my color. i just did it because they did it. i didn't do it because i was latino or i wasn't latino. i just did it because i was funny an

and we must lose another george floyd. and lose our own babies. and is a story to be told from the vantage point and in the midst of the high political drama.t jimmy baldwin is committed to the idea of the new jerusalem. and then you pull over on the side of the highway. >> i knew he would bring a flood. >> so he is always committed to the idea of the new jerusalem but in order for that to happen we have to grow up and who we are as a nation. >> so i'm not asking anybody to wait and this is a description of human nature and the perennial struggle between light and dark and then in the fullness of the nation itself because of democracy and those dispositions have just enough force and focus to create the rule of law. that is one slight management i would propose. >> and somebody asks because there was a citizen and someone asks me you have the decision back in the motel and people ask what got into these kids? america. america is what got into these kids. so what was the baldwin definition of america in that sense? >> maddening. >> badness one —- m

george baker told this to his boss, george h.w. bush. they spoke very frankly to each other. president bush said to secretary baker [indiscernible]. if we leave nato frozen on this cold war line that means you have germany that is in one half of nato. we can figure out other ways to unify germany. i am president and i think it is important to maintain nato. i am paraphrasing, at exact quotation is in my book. one of the newest documents i found said baker had the courage to say sorry about the confusion. it took mcgill gorbachev while. that is no longer an offer. when push comes to shove, when there is actually a treaty negotiated, it changes moscow's willingness to let germany go. the treaty explicitly allowed nato to move eastward. it allows the opposite of what baker and gorbachev discussed in february. he not only takes the financial payment but also let's -- as well. she takes not 1 inch from the beginning in february and ignores the fact that his country signed and ratified the treaty. i made it into the title of the book for a second reason. we start to have moscow arg

. >> i want to begin with a quote from george orwell. writing a book is a horrible, exhausting struggle. like a long bout of some painful illness. one would never undertake such a thing if one were not driven on by some demon whom one can neither resist nor understand. so peter and susan, i want to understand, what drove, , what demon drove you to spend seven years on, peter, on jim baker? >> one of the bakers. >> all of the bakers. now there's no relationship, , s there? >> no relationship. >> so what demon drove you on?y >> while, thank you, kai thank you to everyone for coming out today. it's really wonderful to be with you, and especially someone who really knows what a biography is meant to be. i would say there are two different answers to the question because i can interpret it as what demon let us to spend seven years on the book versus what demon let us write an e-book. anyway i've a slightly different answer. a because actually we never intended of course as no one ever does to spend so long on this project and that definitely

let me welcome george gilder to independent conversations. it's a pleasure to see you.et george gilder first, i think it was deep in the winter of maybe january of 1982 in western new york, you recently published wealth and poverty like the year before. was it published in 1981? >> 1980. >> okay, 1980. i think president reagan read the book, did you hear that story? >> he wrote letters about it before publication, it was all over the place. >> it was a fabulous book. your creativity and seeing what others did, so called capitalism when you analogized it to what was the exchange and the american tribes? >> there were a bunch of ways. >> it was simply give and share which was fascinating and you pointed out a lot ofut flak and what we call capitalism which doesn't pivot simply on self-interest but rather on something at least akin to benevolence, in eye-opener to me. thank you. >> there is a lacerations, my technology books really spring from wealth and poverty which focused on creativity and economic growth. since then, i've been working on the information of economics.

george h.w.eisenhower republican which is like saying you are the last dinosaur, right? that is dead, dead, dead that part. that party was imperfect. but, i believe that one way to think about american politics and a f life from the new deal until now is that it has been a figurative conversation between fdr and reagan. in the relative role of the state in the marketplace. and every american president except for the 45th has essentially governed on that field. and sometimes switch metaphors of football, sometimes there's a george w. bush is over with ronald reagan on the 20. sometimes it's lyndon johnson over here with fdr. i have run this by bush, clinton, and president obama. they all agree president obama agrees with the concept that was the dialectic in which he governed. it was not a dialectices that hs delivered the results i think many people want which is one of the reasons it fell apart in 2016. right? so i don't see that as a shift. what i do see is four years ago but trump is the fulle

that says george wallace. he hated. or do you want a beautiful elegant granite monument that says george wallace he built. and that's the fundamental question. it seems to me of citizenship. is do you want to hate? or do you want to build? and one of the things that eddie and i debate offline a good bet is the extent to which and i'm right by the way in this debate, just so you know. the extent to which progress is a measured and b celebrated? and so talk a little bit about that. one of the things that i insist on in our conversations, is that while white america is deliberating between whether or not it's going to hate or build. we have to raise our babies. while you're trying to decide what kind of human being you're going to be. whether that you're going to be monstrous. we have to protect ourselves. we have to figure out how to raise our children in a society that fundamentally. despises them and so the task then becomes or the question rather. isn't whether or not we're going to hate or whether we're going to build

and in budapest we have george samuel. he is a podcast or at the goggle, which can be found on youtube and locals. all right, cross up rules that affect, that means you can jump in any time you want. and i always appreciate it or i, let's start out with georgia in budapest. well, george may be the kind of an evolution of the information more is that the intelligence agencies are telling us they're lying. i mean, you and i and jumping, we always say that they are lying, but now they've come out, you know, they're ahead of the, the shark here saying that, you know, we're doing this information thing here. and the, the media is so proud to be part of this just information program. it's really quite amazing because they're lying to us to protect us, george. and of course, ukrainian people go ahead. yes. as us right. it is quite an extraordinary thing that we have the intelligence services are openly boasting that they are telling lies the media a quite happy to be transmitting. these lies and you know, the boasting about this

hmm george hw bush was the last eisenhower republican. which is like saying you're the last dinosaur. right that that is dead dead that party. and that party was imperfect. but i believe that one way to think about american politics in life. from the new deal until now is that it's been a figurative conversation. between fdr and reagan on the relative projection of force against commonly agreed upon foes and rivals and the relative role of the state in the marketplace. and every american president has ascend except for the 45th has essentially governed on that field. and sometimes to switch metaphors to football sometimes, you know, there's a george w bush who's over with ronald reagan on the 20. sometimes. there's a lyndon johnson over here with fdr. i've run this by bush clinton and president obama. they all agree president obama agrees with the concept that that was the dialectic. in which he governed? it was not a dialectic that has delivered. the results i think many people want which is one of the reasons it fell apart in 2016, righ