according to george jardaq , he said that human justice is the voice of human justice.means that you look at every moment of human life, but god is a center of meanings. historical and divine meanings and meanings that human life has fought throughout history this form of meaning should not prevail, we are sorry for the marginalization. the second point is that in the form of the translator of the carnival format , aren't we supposed to look for the crowd in vain and look for a congregation ? the fact is that, for example, the celebration of ghadir or the documentary of the arbaeen ceremony and what performance is repeated, sir, it is appropriate to become a carnival, because basically, what does it mean to be a carnival themselves? such that a space is provided they can, for example, have their own informal behavior, and here in these areas, where by the way, we and the difference see that the radio broadcasts the same song that is given like in the yard , around me, i can almost see none of the signs of a carnival i don't know, yes, this is actually congregations, the