macro economic policy institute of the huns a burglar foundation which is close to the german federation of trade unions and i asked him why germany's european neighbors as well as the i.m.f. are so keen on berlin increasing public spending. it's because we have those huge exports of places that means we export so much more than being paul and we need government to spend more money to create more domestic income and then part of that income will flow into imports and increase. crees income abroad and this is something that really europe needs badly because a lot of countries are student crisis mode so this is one of the reasons of course in recent years we've heard that consumer spending in germany for one has increased significantly actually and to the new coalition government already agreed to increasing spending on education are indeed digitalisation on families agriculture mobility and of course defense so what's missing so they say they will increase a lot but if you really look at the numbers it's not really so much what we've seen recently with a new budget coming out from the new finance ministe