james, represents gina miller, solicitor for gina miller and david greene is a solicitor.ll. what about you david, 8—3, were you maybe hoping for a unanimous decision from the justices? from hoping for a unanimous decision from thejustices? from a law hoping for a unanimous decision from the justices? from a law of point of view, it doesn't matter whether it is majority or not, that's the decision is majority. thatjudges are willing and do express their views is a great part of the process. we had an e-mail into the victoria derbyshire programme from a viewer saying, "why do i bother to vote when you have all this legal process ? " vote when you have all this legal process?" people think they voted in a referendum for a result and it has been challenged in the courts? we made it clear and the courts made it clear, this is not about shall we withdraw or stay in? it is not about the brexit or the remain argument. it is purely a point of law and this is about people's rights. i think the message we should get from this, it is about people's rights. for instance, citizens livi

the legal challenge was mounted by british investment fund manager gina miller. r correspondent caught up with miller to find out what motivated her. reporter: since launching legal proceedings against the british government, gina miller has had to hire bodyguards. the investment fund manager has received numerous death threats. we know that her at her offices in one of west london's wealthy districts. >> we are about to go through brexit, which is such a momentous decision. we need people to speak up and talk about the scenarios and what will be good or bad and come to the best decision. all of those people are frightened. reporter: no politician has been up here -- has been willing to appear with her in public. some of the hatred people have sent her way -- some have called for her to be deported, a british citizen, and those are among the least spiteful posts on twitter. >> if i was a white man bringing this case, i possibly wouldn't have experienced the same thing. the vitriol has not really been about the case. my life has changed. we don't really go out anym

of course the lead claimant in this case is business woman, gina miller. i believe she is arriving as we speak. many wonder whether or not she will deliver a statement on her expectations for this decision today. we could see whether or not she has a comment, of course. she was the lead claimant in this case appealing the government's decision, which they continue to fight. the assumption by markets and legal experts is that the high court decision will be upheld, that the uk government will have to take a bill to parliament and they want to move quickly to do that. let's just see if we can get any comments here from gina miller as she goes into court. she is not going to stop for reporters here. we know the top lawyers in the case of the government have already been told of the decision. theresa may, however, will reportedly be inform the at 9:15 very soon, just 15 minutes before the broader public. and then the 11 judges who have been deliberating on this appeal since december will deliver their judgment. what to expect from there? well keep your eyes on

one of the campaigners who brought the case was gina miller, who has been subjected toa number of ginar of violent threats online and that prompted bbc news to put a tweet out asking if she was the most hated woman in the uk? it linked to a discussion on that but led to angry responses on twitter. bbc news gave us a statement in response, which read: wednesday's news at ten took some viewers by surprise with its lead story, a special report from ed thomas and the marked increase in knife crime in the uk. in five yea rs' knife crime in the uk. in five years' time, i could be injail, could be dead, could be the biggest drug dealer in liverpool, you never know, do you, until it happens? tonight, it is liverpool, but this story could be told in many cities. it is one of knives, fear and wasted lives. it started from selling a bit of weed, to selling a bit of class a ‘s. of weed, to selling a bit of class a 's. when did you start selling knives? —— carrying knives? finally, it's been noted this week that bbc political correspondent ca role that bbc political correspondent carole walker is a

one of the campaigners who brought the case was gina miller, who has been subjected toa number of ginaas been subjected to a number of violent threats online. that prompted bbc news to post a tweet asking: it linked to a woman's hour discussion about her treatment, that led to a number of angry responses on twitter. martin phelps answered the question posed like this: dave mcnally thought: humza yousaf thought: well, bbc news gave us a statement in response. it read: wednesday's news at ten took some viewers by surprise with its lead story, a special report from ed thomas on the marked increase in knife crime in the uk. i could be in jail, could be dead, could be the biggest drug dealer in the country, we don't know, see what happens. tonight it's liverpool but this story could be told in many cities. it's one of knives, fear and wasted lives. it starts by selling a bit of weed. winded you start carrying knives? 12. and this woman was flabbergasted by the report: finally it's been noticed this week that bbc political correspondent carol walker is an early riser. on wednesday she was on

gina miller there, who brought the case.or gina miller personally, this has been quite a difficult case. she has been quite a difficult case. she has been vilified, she has had death threats and has had to employ bodyguards. she has. she has exercised the right of every citizen has to a court and say, look, you scrutinise the actions of the proposed actions of the executive, of ministers, to ensure they are lawful under our constitution? that is through a mechanism called judicial review. it is very democratic because anyone can do it. it is often difficult to raise the money to do it but i'm doing it, it has been a particularly stressful time for her. she has been the subject of some pretty vicious and nasty threats. she has shown that a single citizen can invite the independent judiciary to single citizen can invite the independentjudiciary to hold the government to account and to stop the government debt in its tracks before the government proposes is deemed to be unlawful under the constitution. she has actually provided

the arrest is in connection with a complaint made on the 6th of november by gina miller. trigger article 50 of the lisbon treaty without an act of parliament. she won her case at the court yesterday. it relates to threats made online and a second unrelated comment believed to have been made by the same suspect in august 20 16. the arrested man is currently in custody ata arrested man is currently in custody at a central london police station. as pa rt of at a central london police station. as part of the same investigation, we are told that the police issued eight cease and desist notices to various individuals around the uk. they do what they say on the tin. those notices that they if you don't stop the behaviour you're involved with, that could lead to police action. speaking to me in december following the supreme court hearing, gina miller outline the general nature of the threats she has faced. they are quite vile. the sexual violence is very vile and i wouldn't like to say, but anything you can probably imagine is what i've been threatened with. then there have been

gina miller, founding partner at scm direct.ll get more reaction to today's decision, sir william cash, lawmaker with the house of commons. he joins us. this is bloomberg. ♪ vonnie: you are watching bloomberg. i am vonnie quinn. mark: i am mark barton. this is your global business report. setback for theresa may, the uk's highest court rules she must get elements permission before triggering the two-year countdown to leave the eu. vonnie: saudi aramco is preparing for their ipo. mark: measuring china's economy. layern we get a current -- clear picture? theresa may now has a set of roadblocks before she can get the brexit process started. the highest court in the u.k. has ruled she must get parliamentary motion before triggering the two-year countdown to lead the european union. they came out of the u.k. supreme court. fromen the u.k. withdraws eu treaties, a source of new law will be cut off. certain rights enjoyed by u.k. citizens will be changed. therefore the government cannot outgger article 50 with parliament authorizing th

you have to remember, as well as gina miller's high court case, there was a gina miller's high courtasa high gina miller's high court case, there was a high court case in northern ireland, which was heard at the supreme court hearing. the government won that one. they'd already won once on the devolution issues. perhaps it's not really a surprise when the supreme court said under the devolution settlement, yes there's an important role for devolved administration, specifically foreign affairs is a reserved matter. so the decisions to leave orjoin other treaties, whether it's the european union or otherwise, that's for central government. even though the point of law, that it's parliament not ministers, that's the supreme court seemed to have ruled in that way because we're talking about primary legislation that is being changed because it affects everybody and pretty much everyone in their everyday working lives, that's going to be happening in northern ireland, scotland, northern ireland and wales as well. their lives will be changed in the same way. it seems odd. not really. it's p

but gina miller's barrister dismissed that out of hand.t is inherently unlikely in that context that parliament, when it enacted the 1972 act, can possibly have intended that something so fundamental could be set aside by a minister. if the government wins, its problems disappear and ministers can trigger article 50. but what are the consequences if the judges across the square here rule against it, and a bill has to be put through parliament? the consequences are that the government will start to lose control. it has to go to parliament and ask parliament to empower it to act. that means mps can put conditions on the government's power. so they might want to propose amendments to the government's bill. they might want to have future debates. they might put conditions on future discussions or more detail, and that starts to wrest control away from government towards parliament. be you ever so mighty, the law is above you. so said the latejudge lord denning. this case is about where power lies in the constitution as between ministers and pa

but gina miller's barrister dismissed that out of hand.

outside the court, the ruling was welcomed by gina miller, the woman who'd challenged the government.oday's decision has created legal certainty based on our democratic process and provides the legal foundations for the government to trigger article 50. david davis tells mps that there is no going back on brexit and legislation seeking their approval will be introduced quickly. we will within days introduce legislation to give the government legal power to trigger article 50 and begin the formal process of withdrawal. we'll be examining the significance of the supreme court ruling and asking what impact it will have on brexit. also this lunchtime: build in the usa — president trump tells car manufacturers, put your new factories on american soil. the massacre on a tunisian beach — an inquest into the deaths of 30 british tourists hears from a woman who played dead to survive. on the up — speeding fines for motorists driving well over the limit are increased by 50%. in sport on bbc news, bernie ecclestone says he was forced out as chief executive of formula one after a0 years following

the government was appealing a case brought by businesswoman gina miller.judgment at the high court stoppbing ministers bypassing parliament and triggering article 50 using what are known as prerogative powers. they are derived from times when all—powerful kings and queens could do pretty much what they wanted. the press secretary by the press corps so after checking my twitter feed, i shot just corps so after checking my twitter feed, i shotjust an e—mail knowing he could rest easy that his title is secure. let me begin by saying the president has been monitoring the weather in the south—east and spoke with the governor of georgia and offered condolences and support. today president trump is focused on his pledge on trade policies that put america first. he began his day with breakfast with key business leaders in the us onjob creation and growing our manufacturing base. business leaders who intended included michael dell, jeff hendrick, mark fields, alex gorski, marilyn hewson, class client field, and you risk, mario longueuil, elon musk, kevin plank, mar

but businesswoman gina miller fought and fought and fought again.uing the government simply does not have the power to do it alone. there's no precedent, so can our departure start? so—called article 50, without parliament saying yes? today, by a majority of eight to three, the supreme court rules that the government cannot trigger article 50 without an act of parliament authorising it to do so. the referendum is of great political significance. but the act of parliament which established it did not say what should happen as a result. so, any change in the law, to give effect to the referendum, must be made in the only way permitted by the uk constitution, namely, by an act of parliament. to proceed otherwise, would be a breach of settled constitutional principles stretching back many centuries. and there are consequences from that clear instruction. ministers have no choice, mps must have a say. of course the government is disappointed with the outcome but we have the good fortune to live in a country where everyone, every individual, every organis

over my shoulder, you might be able to see gina miller at the supreme court. she is one of the respondents in this case, bringing the original case. she is an asset manager in the u.k., along with a hairdresser, being the case against the governor that went to the high court in november. it is the high court ruling that the government is appealing today. there is wide expectation. we spoke to edit agricole on this matter. they say the expectation for the market at the moment is that the government does lose. if the government does lose, where we end up is, the government has to draft some kind of brief legislation that goes to parliament, in some form, perhaps being explained by the justices of the supreme court. members of the parliament, members of the house of lords, get to make amendments to the bill. the significance of this is basically, how much does this slow down, even if it does not entirely disrupt, the grexit process? francine: if we think of it methodically, there are more core options. the first one, the government wins. the second one, the gover

original high courtjudicial review —— gina miller.an. the bbc understands that indeed was gina miller relating to threats made online. the arrested man is currently in custody at a london police station. we are told that as part of the same investigation, the metropolitan police have released eight notices, cease and desist notices... if you continue with the conduct behaviour you are currently engaged in, then that could result in police action. i should just say that this is entirely separate to another arrest that was made in early december. that arrest was made during the course of the supreme court hearing. metropolitan police officers from the same unit, this is the vulcan unit, the anti—cyber crime unit, on that occasion arrested a 55—year—old man in swindon. he has been released on bail. so, to arrests made so far in that investigation. thank you. some breaking news about the editor in chief of vogue, who has just announced she will be stepping down. she will leave her role this summer. she will leave her role this summer. she

but the investor gina miller had other ideas, she won a case at the high court that only parliament couldupreme court, big stakes constitutionally, perry mason it was not. you have a set of files called the ca. the electronic bundle. 0n the electronic bundle it's 1697. bundle three, tab five, i think that is the... the judges will give their verdict in a few weeks' time. meanwhile, brexit secretary david davis had to explain he hadn't really described his counterpart in the european parliament as "satan". i was being tempted by the chairman of the select committee to criticise you, so i said "get behind me, satan." he was the satan, not you. laughter. that clarifies it all. he's examining the pros and cons of brexit on 50 different sectors of the economy, from cakes to cars. it's certainly doing terrible things to the english language. the prime minister leads us towards a smart and smooth brexit, as i like to call it, a smexit. and conference, mark my words, we will make breakfast..brexit a success. laughter. and was there at brexit effect in richmond? zac goldsmith triggered a by—electi

her photograph is in all the pictures, it is gina miller.? you've got your way. it went your way in the end. how do you feel about that today? i'm delighted the debate has already started and the mps are already doing what they should have done, ifelt, months ago, and before the actual vote itself. so i'm delighted that they have already started their debate. in some ways it was more about the debate for you, was it? oh, absolutely. this is what the mps we re absolutely. this is what the mps were supposed to do. they're supposed to debate vote, put through an act of parliament and then the government can trigger article 50. we've heard from david davis saying he hopes that parliament and this won't be used to thwart the will of the people. what's your reaction to people who say that perhaps that's what you have been trying to do? we need to move on. it is a broken record. we can't go back and talk about what happened lastjune. we need to look forward and what's going to happen in the future. we haven't talked about that. my case was to ensur

but businesswoman gina miller fought and fought and fought again. government simply does not have the power to do it alone. there's no precedent, so can our departure start? so—called article 50, without parliament saying yes? today, by a majority of eight to three, the supreme court rules that the government cannot trigger article 50 without an act of parliament authorising it to do so. the referendum is of great political significance. but the act of parliament which established it did not say what should happen as a result. so, any change in the law, to give effect to the referendum, must be made in the only way permitted by the uk constitution, namely, by an act of parliament. to proceed otherwise, would be a breach of settled constitutional principles stretching back many centuries. and there are consequences from that clear instruction. ministers have no choice, mps must have a say. of course the government is disappointed with the outcome but we have the good fortune to live in a country where everyone, every individual, every organisation, e

but businesswoman gina miller fought and fought and fought again.hat the government simply does not have the power to do it alone. there is no precedent, so can our departure start, so—called article 50, without parliament saying yes? today, by a majority of 8-3, the saying yes? today, by a majority of 8—3, the supreme court rules that the government cannot trigger article 50 without an act of parliament authorising it to do so. the referendum is of great political significance, but the act of parliament which established it did not say what should happen as a result. so any change in the law to give effect to the referendum must be made in the new age permitted, by the uk constitution, namely by an act of parliament —— in the only permitted. to proceed otherwise would be a breach of settled constitutional principles stretching back many centuries. and there are consequences from that clear instruction. ministers have no choice. mps must have a say. of course the government is disappointed with the outcome, but we have the good fortune to live in a

a man arrested over alleged threats made against gina miller, the woman behind the brexit legal challenge. the 50—year—old man was detained on wednesday on suspicion of racially—aggravated malicious communications. he has been bailed until mid—february. northumbria university has apologised and been fined £400,000 after two people nearly died taking part in a science experiment. the students were accidentally given enough caffeine for 300 cups of coffee, 100 times the intended dose. laws to prevent discrimination against women in relation to dress code in the workplace are not being properly enforced, according to mps. their report was commissioned after a receptionist was sent home for not wearing high—heeled shoes. rescue teams in italy have found more bodies in the ruins of a ski resort hotel that was hit by an avalanche last week. in all, 24 people were killed with 5 people still missing. 0ur rome correspondent james reynolds has been speaking to two survivors. how many of us will ever know what it's like to come back to life? on saturday vincenzo forti and giorgia galassi were pulled

think it is imperative on all members in this house to reflect on the debt of gratitude we owe to gina millershould all reflect on that. and on the amendment, primarily what we wa nt and on the amendment, primarily what we want is scrutiny. in our white paper yet to be published, it is interesting that you are not publishing a white paper by the time we have a debate and you want to publish one after we have had a debate and after the bill has been passed. that must surely be unprecedented. secondly the lack of respect for the devolution settlement. also the consequences of leaving the eu without certainty, and the kind of vision of the uk thatis and the kind of vision of the uk that is being created. one enormous step that the government could have made, and this was touched upon by the honourable member for made, and this was touched upon by the honourable memberfor rushcliffe and by the memberfor holborn the honourable memberfor rushcliffe and by the member for holborn and the honourable memberfor rushcliffe and by the memberfor holborn and st pancras, is the fact that european nationals c

says she can start the uk's divorce from the eu herself but campaigners, led by the businesswoman gina millernt loses, they will also lose complete control of the timetable for starting the process of leaving the european union. it will have to rush its plan through parliament in the next few weeks. today is not about whether brexit should or will happen but who gets to press go. that is why it matters and that is why there was a lot of interest here in what the judges had to say. chris mason, bbc news, westminster. later this morning we'll be speaking to the former deputy prime minister nick clegg to get his thoughts on the supreme court ruling. that's at 7:10. president trump has announced that america will formally withdraw from the trans—pacific partnership, one of the major pledges he made during the election campaign. the trade deal involving a dozen countries was agreed by barack obama. president trump has also cut funding for international groups that provide abortions, and has frozen the hiring of some federal workers. drivers caught driving well above the speed limit will face bigge

now, we know that was connected to complaints made by gina miller.uclear weapons, if his survival in power depended on it. the high—ranking defector, thae yong—ho, says the north korean leader doesn't yet have the capability, but is getting closer to an effective nuclear arsenal. he's been speaking to steve evans. i'm sure that my relatives, and my brother and sister's families by now are all sent to either remote closed areas, or prison camps, you know, so that really breaks my heart. if you could imagine your brother shouting at you, "why did you do this to me? why have you put me in this place?", what would you say to him? oh, that is really, you know, a question which i do not like even to think about, yes, but that's why i'm very much now determined to do everything possible to pull down the north korean regime, to save not only my family members but the whole north korean people from slavery. do you think you'll ever see your brother again? i'm absolutely sure, and this is my dream, to walk back to my home town. if, when kim jong—un gets the bo

gina miller expected to arrive shortly as she continues her legal case against the government at thet. more coverage coming up. mass and i will wrap things up on the bloomberg television. up next it is surveillance. coming up but we will be live outside the supreme court when that decision comes out. francine: supreme decisions. brexit gets its day in court with a ruling on triggers. this will delay theresa may's timetable for leaving the e.u. currency concerns. the u.s. treasury secretary nominee, steven mnuchin, says the dollar is very strong. does the buck stop here? and trump don'ts the tpp -- dumps the tpp. and shares in a telecom giant plunge. this is "bloomberg surveillance."

the government was appealing a case brought by businesswoman gina miller.m times when all—powerful kings and queens could do pretty much what they wanted. it‘s accepted that they can legitimately use the prerogative to enter into and leave international treaties, like the one that took the uk into what is now the eu. but that treaty led to an act of parliament, which brought rights into our domestic law, and it‘s the removal of those rights that lies at the heart of the case. the government argue that we are dealing with an international treaty that our government has signed with the other eu governments, so even though the eu treaty gives rights to british citizens, it is ultimately up to the government to decide whether it wants to pull britain out, and not up to parliament. and in court, the attorney general argued that if parliament had wanted to limit ministers‘ powers, it could have done so. when it comes to leaving the european union, parliament has had full capacity and multiple opportunities to restrict the executive‘s ordinary ability to begin the

a man's arrested over alleged threats against gina miller — the woman behind the brexit legal challengeconfirmed as england's captain for the six nations, two days after his suspension for striking came to an end. liverpool's philippe coutinho has signed a new contract worth £150,000 a month. serena williams has backed johanna konta to be a future champion, after knock bg out ing her out of australian open. four school children, all under the age of 13, have been taken to hospital after it's thought they mistakenly ate cocaine, thinking it was sherbet. it happened at broadstone middle school near poole in dorset. 0ur correspondent, duncan kennedy, is there. what has happened here? well, we are not entirely clear of all the details. all we can say is this was a strange and potentially serious incident. it took place three weeks ago on january 3rd. incident. it took place three weeks ago onjanuary 3rd. 0nly it has only just been reported. judging by what the police and the head teacher are saying is a pupil turned up at school with some white powder. three other pupils look at this, aged

gina miller would contend there is not any plans to [inaudible] theresa may has wrecked sterling. changed. you are -- or take so far. guest: it is clear the markets are holding that may government in check. every time it looks for some thef edge brexit coming, and preventedd from doing stupid stuff. there are huge amounts of uncertainty and i think the biggest worry of all is the data on the firm's investment and hiring intentions. warning got another about brexit. i we seeing in the data a drop off in investment that you put down to brexit or is it too early to see? guest: i do not know if we are seeing it in the hard data yet. the big thing we saw was movement in the data street after in june. that is the reason the bank of england acted. those were the days in 2008 that read that recession was coming. some of the things we have to remember is the bank actually acted and that lifted things a little bit. i think the great uncertainty is the -- a big deal. bi has itsmentioned own uncertainty index. it has been sloping down. you sat on the mpc. give me a sense of the kind of data p

one of the campaigners who brought the case was gina miller, who has been subjected to a number of violent of angry responses on twitter. martin phelps answered the question posed like this: dave mcnally thought: humza yousaf thought: well, bbc news gave us a statement in response. it read: wednesday's news at ten took some viewers by surprise with its lead story, a special report from ed thomas on the marked increase in knife crime in the uk. in five years' time i could be injail, could be dead, could be the biggest drug dealer in the country, you never know, see what happens. tonight it's liverpool but this story could be told in many cities. it's one of knives, fear and wasted lives. it starts by selling a bit of weed. selling a bit of class as. when did you start carrying knives? 12. and annie good was flabbergasted by the report: finally, it's been noticed this week that bbc political correspondent carol walker is an early riser. on wednesday she was on air in the cold just after 6am. our political correspondent carol walker is outside the houses of parliament for us. good morning to

a man has been questioned in connection with alleged threats against gina miller, the woman behind theous communications. the arrest follows a complaint last november about threats made online. he's been released on bail until the middle of next month. three people have died inafire next month. three people have died in a fire at a house in reigate in surrey. the bodies of a man, a woman and a child were found in the same bed at a farm cottage. it's thought the fire had burned all night, and the fire had burned all night, and the alarm was raised only when collea g u es the alarm was raised only when colleagues went to check on the man, who had failed to arrive at work. northumbria university has been fined £400,000 northumbria university has been fined £a00,000 after two students nearly died taking part in a science experiment. the students, who were both 20, were mistakenly given enough caffeine for 300 cups of coffee — 100 times the intended dose. they were both admitted to intensive care, and made a full recovery. the university has apologised and says it was an ‘isolated incident‘

the government was appealing a case brought by businesswoman gina miller.iggering article 50 using what are known as prerogative powers. they are derived from times when all—powerful kings and queens could do pretty much what they wanted. it's accepted that they can legitimately use the prerogative to enter into and leave international treaties, like the one that took the uk into what is now the eu. but that treaty led to an act of parliament, which brought rights into our domestic law, and is the removal of those rights that lies at the heart of the case. the government argued that we are dealing with an international treaty that our government has signed with the other eu governments, so even though that the eu treaty gives rights to british citizens, it is ultimately up british citizens, it is ultimately up to the government to decide whether it wants to pull britain out, and not up to parliament. and in court, the attorney general argued that if parliament had wanted to limit ministers‘ powers, it could have done so. when it comes to leaving the europea

even gina miller on the steps of the supreme court this morning said this is not about influencing brexithe result of the referendum, that was the political sphere, that was the referendum result of this is about the legal and constitutional mechanism for putting the resultant action and triggering the article 50 notification. in that sense has been an educative process for of us and no doubt it will be discussed now in the hallowed halls of universities for many years. we surprised not surprised thejudgment for many years. we surprised not surprised the judgment that we heard this morning? i was not surprised, especially the second point that the convention is only politically binding and on the first point i think you could see from the discussion of the constitutional importance of joining the discussion of the constitutional importance ofjoining the eu that they were moving towards the need to have parliament give them that say. and trigger article 50. thank you so much to both of you. for the ball is now in pa rliament‘s much to both of you. for the ball is now in parliament's court,

we spoke to family partner gina miller.poke to us after the ruling. >> why are you so frightened of having this debate an ensuring that we talk about all the different angles of the brexit? it has to about -- be an open debate about where we go as a country. >> u.k. growth beat expectations in fourth quarter coming in at 0.6%. driven by services and consumer spending, continuing the trend of lopsided growth. it is down from the previous year and the weakest since 2013. also effects of brexit on the banking sector. santander executive chairman discussed the impact on her business. >> inflation will hurt consumers obviously. we are expecting lower growth in the u.k. for 2017. not as low as we expected before. so we still expect growth. lending less. still to grow. santander u.k. has done a great job this year and we are totally committed to the u.k. as a very local british bank. >> 24 hours a day powered by more than 2600 journalists and analysts. mark: when it comes to reasons for raising rates, the economy is ticking a lot

matt miller is here and gina sanchez, so starting with you, this is the start of a trend for 2017 in out performance? >> well, i think if you look at the individual stocks, they each actually have some positive on stock specific stories, and what's overhanging this, and i think what drove the stocks down or at least part of what drove stocks down at the end of the year was the fact that donald trump is on record, record being twit ter for being against net neutral neutrality, and in december, the senate failed to reconfirm a democratic commissioner, jessica, and so we're looking at a situation where net neutral di could could be on the chopping block. we have the chair of the fcc is pro-net neutrality, and donald trump's pick on his transition team david has no view on -- actually no record for being against net neutrality. that hangs in the balance. amazon, netflix, facebook would be severely impact if this went away. >> fear 2016, and 2017 people are not scared anymore? will it kick in and it's not the start of a trend on performance? >> well, i think that you're looking at a situa

miller was a scholarship athlete for the hawks basketball team and got graduate degrees there. >>> time now for an update on the highways and by ways. gina is in for matt good we have the clash if you travel in upper providence township. on 422 westbound at 29 and still the right lane is squeezing by, we have police and penndot on the scene and look at your bigger problem, 37 minutes to travel out on the westbound side from 202 to oaks. definitely a set back for you and this delay reaching back to 202. lets look at the big picture, 9 miles per hour on 95 this is because we had an earlier disabled vehicle near girard and has since cleared. and 14 on the schuylkill westbound at city avenue where we see a backup and 13 on the schuylkill eastbound around montgomery drive. 95 nothing but delays going on in northeast philadelphia. this is at allegheny, but it will take you 30 minutes to travel between woodhaven road and the vine. and northbound not too bad about 19 minutes. rick and monica i'll send it right back over. >> thank you. >>> video that stops your heart. a dresser falling on a 12-year-old toddler but the story has a happy ending bec