>> rudy giuliani hired bernard -- richard: rudy giuliani hired bernard kerrick. he is a criminal. the best line ever from joe biden is, every rudy giuliani sentence has a subject, a verb and 9/11. [laughter] robert: i disagree. richard: rudy giuliani, if you look at what he is saying currently, he is not. -- he is nuts. and we've already mentioned that crime all over the country has declined in places with her without rudy giuliani. i respectively disagree. -- respectfully disagree. robert: and i disagree, too. >> let's not forget that two of the worst police misconduct cases occurred under giuliani's watch, abner rima, the man being anally raped by a broken broomstick, and the other, the nypd has had a lot of great officers and a lot of problems but it was hardly a begin --a beacon of rudy giuliani administration. moderator: thank you for your answers and for your question, and i'm sure next year we will have rudy giuliani are stop -- here. >> i think i have a difference of you from mr. kaufman on whether or not the united states can actually be said to have a police state. i'm w

her biggest challenge to sharper her differences with new york mayor rudy giuliani. both support gun control and abortion rights. he hasn't announced yet, but appeared on five sunday talk shows and said on "meet the press" -- >> i'm going to run for the senate and i'm going to serve there. >> you just said you're running for senate. >> i did? >> is that a correction? >> well i don't think that's accurate. we'll see. >> i did? i said that? from day one, she rattled him enough that he didn't even know he was running. he did ultimately announce that he was properly running and everybody thought he was going to win. he ended up dropping out of that senate race citing health reasons. he had been diagnosed with prostate cancer a few weeks earlier. but even before his announcement he was dropping out, he was already trailing hillary clinton by double digits in the polls. as a candidate, he was just flailing. famously, he hated to leave new york city for the statewide race while campaigning. even though upstate new york was supposed to be republican territory, that is where

rudy giuliani, as the best line ever from joe biden is, every rudy giuliani sentence has a subject, a verb, and 9/11. >> i disagree. >> rudy giuliani, if you look at what he is saying currently he it nuts. and we already mentioned that crime all over this country has declined. in places with or without rudy giuliani. so i respectfully disagree. >> i disagree, too. >> let's just not forget that -- [inaudible] >> where is the mic. can you keep them on all the time? >> i just want to say let's not forget two of the worst police misconduct cases occurred under giuliani's watch. diallo, 41 shots on one hand being ain'tally rained bay broken broomstick and the other the nypd has had a lot of problems and at lot of great officers but hardly a beacon of understanding in the giuliani era. >> thank you for your interesting question. i'm sure we'll have rudy giuliani on stage next year. students, please come forward on the mics. >> hi. thanks to everybody on the panel. i think i had a bit of a difference of view from mr. kaufman as far as whether the united states can actually be said to have a

before giuliani at the worst time. and i lived in new york for my four degrees of columbia after giuliani. i will tell you that before giuliani when there was insufficient law enforcement life was thomas hobbs nasty solitary brutish often short. overall, on balance and they should be held accountable and there should be panels like this and the police should always have to answer the question, are you responding disproportionally, despite that all, a thing have gotten vastly better and b treating this as a systemic problem i think is going to make matters worse. i'm going to have to leave here in a moment to play the same role on the iranian panel but to cement my claim to the witness protection program, i will respond to you that in the ferguson case, the law enforcement officer acted in legitimate, self-defense and the jury was absolutely right to exonerate him. meaning that the mark of this, is to make reasonable distinctions. >> can i ask one, i'm sorry. >> [inaudible]. >> i have one quick question because, the gen

rudy giuliani the best line ever from joe biden every rudy giuliani sentence has a subject, verb, and 911. [laughter] rudy giuliani is if you look at what he is saying currently command is nuts. we already mentioned that crime all over this country has declined in places with or without. i respectfully disagree. >> i disagree, too. >> let's not forget. [inaudible conversations] >> where are the microphones? keep them on. >> let's not forget two of the worst police misconduct cases occurred under giuliani's watch. forty-one shots on one hand being anally raped by a broken broomstick and the other. the nypd has had a lot of problems over the years and a lot of great officers, but it was hardly a beacon of understanding. [applause] >> thank you for your interesting question. i i am sure will have read giuliani here next year. over here. students, come forward of the mike's. >> hi. thanks to everyone on the panel. panel. i think i had a bit of a difference of you for mr. kaufman as far as whether or not the united states can actually be said to have a police state. i'm wondering perhaps i

we continue with mayor giuliani in studio with us.this last night, perhaps those buildings could have been saved. >> sure if they had stopped the first one who looted a building and arrested them. the second one and the third and the fourth one. if they didn't buy into this cooling off period theory that is the theory that they had. >> here's the thing that i find troubling. decades of bad policies does not excuse throwing bricks at police officers or breaking windows or stealing things. and second who is responsible for the bad policies but the very politicians you were interviewing. they have been in charge of that city, liberal democrats with very left wing policies of dependency don't do anything about the schools, let the teachers union push you around don't support charter schools, don't move people off welfare, don't try aggressive programs of moving people off of welfare into work. i moved 700,000 people off welfare and put them to work. >> they are making excuses. >> there are decades of bad policies. these are the bad polici

one of loretta lynch's advocates is giuliani. he will lobby saying i worked with this woman, she's qualified. let's get it done. >> harry reid's move to force a vote. could it be counterproductive. >> i don't think it will work. he has to get five republicans to buck the leadership. >> how about the group that was founded by al sharpton threatening hunger strike could that be counterproductive? >> the fact of the matter is mitch mcconnell nose he's safe. -- knows he's safe. republicans will ride this out. i don't think outside pressure - if giuliani can't get them to move i don't think a burn of protesters will. >> now there's the iran bill. they could push off the human trafficking bill. it could go on much. >> i thought this was problem attic. we don't have a new or functional attorney. -- attorney-general. we had a foreign leader. it doesn't make sense. >> what do you think will happen. >> i think shell get confirmed. it won't happen until some time over the summer. the white house has capitulated. i don't think it will be hel

i was at the gym again, and carol costello from cnn decided to go after rudy giuliani. rudy giuliani didn't shoot this man. she had shown tape of him previously defending cops. therefore implying that he had something to do with this. if a muslim bombs a marathon, do you go after people who then defend the muslim faith? no you don't. so going after giuliani because he defends an organization that he's part of seems awful. >> defending the broken window theory. >> it had nothing to do with this. the point is focus on the incident. you have footage of the incident. you no longer have to see this through the prism of race. we have it in front of you, a man shoots another man in the back and kills him. >> it speaks for itself. >> yes. >> okay. >>> coming up president obama takes another shot at christians. this time at the white house easter prayer breakfast. the remarks have sparked outrage. >> sparked. >> my favorite phrase. next on "the five." know your financial plan won't keep you up at night. know you have insights from professional investment strategists to help set

. >>> coming up america's mayor, rudy giuliani reacts and what he would do in panama city beach when we come back. that's all straight ahead. >>> also tonight, we have more we're going to get to. and that is hillary clinton ends up staged in campaign stop in abi bringing in fake voters talk to her at a coffee shop. >>> one on one with a congressman who says it feels like open season for killing black men in america. that and much more as we continue. audible safety beeping audible safety beeping audible safety beeping the nissan rogue with safety shield technologies. the only thing left to fear is you imagination. nissan. innovation that excites. >>> welcome back to hannity, now we have been warning you about the out of control partying that goes on during spring break and what it can lead to, now that panama city beach florida has come under scrutiny for handling of several instances like the alleged gang rape and several shootings. well what should the city now do to prevent this type of thing from ever happening again in the future? here to answer that question, the man who cleane

. >>> coming up, america's mayor, rudy giuliani reacts and what he would do in panama city beach when we come back. that's all straight ahead. >>> also coming up tonight, we have a lot more we're going to get to, and hillary clinton ends up staging a campaign stop in iowa by bringing in fake voters to talk to her at a coffee shop. >>> one on one with a congressman who says, it feels like open season for killing black men in america. that and much more as we continue. 8fq@q:)q1m-[f=/p2!a>l>> welcome back to "hannity." now, we have been warning you about the out-of-control partying that goes on during spring break and what it can lead to, now that panama city bea

i would argue -- >> giuliani -- >> compliment anybody tieing this back to giuliani? >> no no, no. >> that's the most leftist compliment on earth. >> no what i'm actually saying, that is part of the theory, that they've taken it too far, the broken windows theory. >> but that's not on this list. >> i will say this, i do think that there was good stuff on the list. do not imitate speech patterns. i don't see how that could help anything. but do cops do that? >> i don't know. i have not witnessed that. >> then it never happened. >> of course not. >> okay. coming up kirsten powers a. a democrat is upset at president obama. details, next. 40% of streetlights in detroit at one point did not work. at the time that the bankruptcy filing was done the public lighting authority had a hard time of finding a bank. citi did not run away from the table like some other bankers did. they had the strength to help us go to the credit markets and raise the money. it's a brighter day in detroit. kids are feeling safer while they walk to school. 40% of the lights were out but they're not

rudy giuliani, the cast of snl. ♪ john: the tribeca film festival is the talk of the town.nt our red carpet reporter to mingle with the celebs. >> did you come up with the slogan for hillary's campaign? >> yeah. why not? why not get on board? why not get on board the hillary train? >> i think she would win it she use that. >> what are your thoughts on her logo? >> looks good. >> she has certainly paid her dues. she has the right to be president if anybody does. >> i don't understand it. >> in a way, it is kind of like, i'm with stupid. seriously? i got this. flex she deserves the job -- >> she deserves the job if she wants it. >> is it pointing to the left or the right? >> who cares what the logo is? is that what is going to make our president? the president is about making the country better. >> the guys have any suggestions about who should be her running mate? >> oprah winfrey. >> we will get free stuff all the time. >> pauly shore, that would be fun. >> any ideas for what her slogan should be? >> still killing it. john: that is pretty funny. the 2016 board game, we made

and we've had other moments of tragedy in our country like 9/11 and just as rudy giuliani was, quote, america's mayor on that day, ron norig in oklahoma was america's day. it was an amazing performance as i got together his police and his firefighters and was immediately on the scene and one of the great public servants that i've ever seen. and i would be remiss not to mention my friend behind me, mr. lucas, as he alluded to in his remarks that was his district office, one building over. that was a place where he was in and out of a lot in the federal building and my task as secretary of state signed by -- assigned by the governor was to work in weab to try to coordinate with the federal government a long-term rebuilding effort. nobody did more to rebuild oklahoma city than frank lucas. . this was not a natural disaster, this was literally an attack on a federal facility in oklahoma city with a unique federal responsibility. those are all things that frank lucas got done not just for the people of his district but the people of our state. frankly, in that he set some precedents that s

we continue with mayor giuliani in studio with us.hey done this last night, perhaps those buildings could have been saved. >> sure if they had stopped the first one who looted a building and arrested them. the second one and the third and the fourth one. if they didn't buy into this cooling off period theory that is the theory that they had. >> here's the thing that i find troubling. decades of bad policies does not excuse throwing bricks at police officers or breaking windows or stealing things. and second who is responsible for the bad policies but the very politicians you were interviewing. they have been in charge of that city, liberal democrats with very left wing policies of dependency don't do anything about the schools, let the teachers union push you around don't support charter schools, don't move people off welfare, don't try aggressive programs of moving people off of welfare into work. i moved 700,000 people off welfare and put them to work. >> they are making excuses. >> there are decades of bad policies. these are the b

so do you think mayor giuliani will talk about the south carolina case l.z.? >> of course not.ou know when have you seen him actually come out and say, i've made a mistake with anything in terms of both his policies as mayor and since he's run for president and since he's now become a conservative commentator. he's not come out and said i was wrong or you know maybe i wasn't as clear or perhaps i misspoke. he doesn't apologize. he keeps barrelling forward ahead. the thing that i find most offensive about what's happening now in south carolina is this notion that this was this one particular cop who made one bad decision. when in the police report you know he says that several police officers tried to administer cpr to save the man's life and then the video comes out and we don't see anything like that. we just see them kind of mulling around standing over his body as he's dying. so to tell us that this was one police officer who made one bad mistake meanwhile other responding police officers don't try to save this man's life tells us there's a lot more going on than what's been

soil and former new york city mayor rudy giuliani joins us. mayor, pleasure to have you on the record tonight. what do you make of the news that another american has been linked to a terror group? >> well, it's not a surprise at a all. kimberly. this is part of the plan that goes back to the late 1990s, bin laden wrote about the fact that you can self-actualize these jihadists if you know what you are doing. and it's actually an easier way to bring about an attack. so, part of my frustration about this is how we act so surprised at these one offs like the boston marathon bombing. the bombing in london in 2005 were local people. they were people who were basically citizens of the u.k. this has been part of their plan. their war on us from the very beginning. and it's something that we have to be very aware of. this is a good result for the government because we caught this guy. >> right. >> but the reality is there are a lot more of them out there that we're not catching. this is why we need to have a great deal of local police knowledge about

we will talk more about that story with new york mayor rudy giuliani who helped find counter terrorist like two fbi guys on the inside. he did get back from syria. >> that is the bad news. he shouldn't have gotten back from syria. good news is we caught him. remember president bush used to say the difficulty here is we have to be right 100% of the time. they have to be right less than 1% of the time. i think that is the issue we are facing. that gets more difficult when it is internal terrorism. the fact that he left the united states came back under funny circumstances would indicate that we should have picked him up. the ones that worry me are the ones that don't bother going overseas and are planning it here. there you need a lot of policing a lot of local policing and training of police. basically the fbi and homeland security have to think of our 800,000 uniform police officers as their eyes and ears. we have to come up with that concept. there are only 14,000 fbi agents but 800,000 police. it's those police that can spot the terrorists. i can give you examples before september 11

rudy giuliani was able to clean up the streets using bill's crime bill.s anyone going to ask her on heels of baltimore would she reject her husband's own legislation. >> i doubt it. this is why i'm glad i am a republican. liberal policies that have caused this generational poverty in this town. and until people wake up, and like i did and realize and understand that the free market, school choice, and conservative principles are the only way to change and grow this city. any city. any city impoverished. it is only way. >> sandra, very quickly what about that? liberal policies in baltimore. the president doesn't seem to want to talk about that. it was really rudy giuliani's policies cleaned up new york to make it as safe as it is today? >> the root of the situation is the economic situation in this country but yet the president, when he spoke yesterday he blamed congress for not acting on his economic policies for the, unemployment situation that we still face in this country. so there was in my opinion, lack of condemnation of the violent acts in baltimor

in 2001 under then-mayor rudy giuliani. had been, this would become oddly important, commissioner of corrections. in 2004 george bush wanted him to join his cabinet. his failure to pay a nanny taxes made him withdraw. by february of 2010, bernie kerik stood convicted eight counts of criminal conspiracy, tax evasion and lying under oath and headed to prison. joining me, bernard kerik author of the new book "from jailer to jailed." thank you for coming on. >> thanks, chris. >> i want to ask you what you know, what we don't know. what the fall from grace felt like, what prison was like. most fear rape in prison, fear being beat up, fear the hell of it. start with that. what was the worst part of something you never thought you'd experience? prison life? >> honestly, chris, the worst part for me was not prison life. the worst part for me was the removal of my kids, was being taken away from your family. and i think the depravation of freedom, for anyone, especially someone in my position or someone in your position, the deprava

but early this week, of the man who cleaned up america's biggest city rudy giuliani, shared some tips on how the mayor can get control of her town. here's what he said. >> i'd have to know the number of cops. maybe it's 300, maybe it's 400. you put them on the beach. first one that does something wrong you arrest them. i'm not sure if florida has an open bottle law. if it does, i'd enforce it in a second. no bottles on the beach no drinking on the beach. >> your message to them is you should clean this up in two days and cut the nonsense. >> keep 300 400 cops there for the duration of the spring break. next year when they come back they should be met by 300 cops. they'll go somewhere else. >> the sheriff who we've had on this program, several times he's been voicing his concern for years. now, why won't the mayor listen to what the police need, and clean up this mess, especially in light of seven kids being shot and now this girl being allegedly gang raped. joining me now, former lapd detective mark fuhrman and bo deedle. two things about the mayor, the gutless mayor who should be fir

new york becoming a safe place, it has been greatly credited to you and mayor giuliani, and following the broken windows theory, and, you know, small crimes that disorder leads to greater crimes. stop and frisk, which was instituted more specifically after you left and you mentioned earlier went to certain extremes. the court order said it had to be limited under certain circumstances. was stop and frisk, which i know you believe is an essential part inappropriately? >> i think so. i said that repeatedly. there was too much of it, it was unnecessary. that's borne out by the fact that we have - we do sit very significantly during my 15 months as police officer. my predecessor ray kelly reduced it dramatically during his time with no negative impact on reduction of crime in the city. >> how should it be used? >> you have to have reasonable suspicion that a crime has, is or about to be committed. if a crime has not been, is not or is not about to be committed, you can't have the officer fabricate it. the community felt that too many officers were inappropriately stopping them. the federa

and senator mccain's campaign looked like it was falling apart, there were many glomming on to giulianiperienced this in the early days with george bush. i don't know. but people interpret that and say -- >> yeah, that's part of what the game is about. and, again, we see a little bit above the surface, there is a lot going on below the surface. the things that go on above the surface, every campaign is trying to promote mojo. ted cruz announces he is running and then has a good announcement. and then the attention begins to dwindle aaway. they try to pump him back up, oh surprise. we have $31 million that we have raised for our superpac. marco rubio has a nice announcement. but clearly, these two men are jostling against each other, sort of occupy the same space, freshman senators young guys. and so what does marco rubio do? his allies go out and say well we have $40 million in our superpac. >> it's an interesting thought that it's not just one guy getting a lot of money. >> we don't know that yet. >> and jeb bush has a problem. >> but he is very good at getting that money early on from

chris christie needs to do what rudy giuliani couldn't do. rudy giuliani was a really popular mayor right after 9/11 who did real well in the northeast and kept postponing his chances because he couldn't do well elsewhere. by the time florida came along, he imploded. so chris christie may have a warm reception in new hampshire. he's got to see how voters in south carolina and iowa and elsewhere feel about him. but look he's got to do what everybody else will do. take a look at the polls, take a look at how many people are giving him financial support dip his toe in the water and figure out what he wants to do. we'll see. but if he jumps in, welcome. there are a lot of folks in the pool already. >> there are indeed. i want to bring in a reporter for bloomberg politics dave wiegle. i think a lot of folks were surprised to hear jeb bush say it's time for republicans to let loretta lynch go and by go i mean confirm the woman. the country's black, african-american female attorney general. how much do you think his talking abouts on these issues ta

giuliani goes on fox news to talk about the riots and gives

giuliani goes on fox news to talk about the riots and gives a just nuanced take on the day's events.looep. and cable news spins the day asking whether thug is the new n word. isn't n word one you should familiarized yourself with news. time to keep it 100. this is the nightly show. (cheers and a captioning sponsored by

giuliani goes on fox news to talk about the riots and gives a just nuanced take on the day's events. he says some dumb ass bull blaep blooep. and cable news spins the day asking whether thug is the new n word. isn't n word one you should familiarized yourself with news. time to keep it 100. this is the nightly show. (cheers and a captioning sponsored by comedy central >> larry: choo! thank you very much. >> larry, larry larry! larry larry larry! >> larry: thank you very much. welcome to the nightly show. somebody brought it up before so now-- but i thank you. i'm larry wilmore. and we are in day two of our continuing coverage of the unrest in baltimore. and it feels lick there's been a little rest in the unrest in the last 24 hours. but you know i got something on cnn last night that really stood out. here say report that aired about ten minutes after the 10 p.m. curfew. see if you notice something missing from this picture. and hint it's not missing yet. >> would you have do you think that is the right thing? >> there is no easy answer to that. what it appears to be that baltimore i

rudy giuliani says it's time to confirm her. these are not people that my colleagues on the other side of the aisle normally say are lawless. now, this is the story of loretta lynch and why i think she has been able to wait out this long, long process. loretta lynch has a lot of patience. when she was a little girl, she took a test and she did incredibly well on that test. she did so well that they didn't believe she took that test. then they asked her to take that test over again and she scored even higher. when she was the valedictorian of her class and the principal came up to her and said this is a little awkward, you're african, we might want another white student to share the honor, that's what happened to her, she said all right. that is a woman who has been through something and can wait this out. well, she waits no longer after today. now, the other thing i heard from our friend on the other side of the aisle, from senator cruz, was that somehow she is lawless because she supported something that every president since d

giuliani goes on fox news to talk about the riots and gives a just nuanced take on the day's events.ll blaep blooep. and cable news spins the day asking whether thug is the new n word. isn't n word one you should familiarized yourself with news. time to keep it 100. this is the nightly show. (cheers and a captioning sponsored by comedy central >> larry: choo! thank you very much. >> larry, larry larry! larry larry larry! >> larry: thank you very much. welcome to the nightly show. somebody brought it up before so now-- but i thank you. i'm larry wilmore. and we are in day two of our continuing coverage of the unrest in baltimore. and it feels lick there's been a little rest in the unrest in the last 24 hours. but you know i got something on cnn last night that really stood out. here say report that aired about ten minutes after the 10 p.m. curfew. see if you notice something missing from this picture. and hint it's not missing yet. >> would you have do you think that is the right thing? >> there is no easy answer to that. what it appears to be that baltimore is trying to do-- is do so

i understand and i was surprised that you haven't talked to rudy giuliani your old boss and great friend for so many years. >> it's been a long time. lou: how does that make you feel? >> look i've talked about this. this is a small portion of the book. but the reality is that we create a distance early on to keep him out of the mix of my withdrawal -- and the federal investigation. but what bothered me was that he's the godfather of my kids. and i would have hoped he was there for them while i was gone. >> great to have you here. again, congratulations. time for a look at last night's poll results. we asked whether you think with his foreign policy record, mr. obama should be eager to make a deal with the world's leading sponsor of terror. 91% of you said no. that's it for us tonight. we thank you for being with us. see you here tomorrow. good night from new strangeinheritance.com. >> a sanctuary for exotic animals. >> how is his health? >> he's doing good. >> call of the wild. >> rescued by quite an odd duck himself. >> we use 26,000 pounds of chicken or beef every six weeks? jamie: wha

so did she have a responsibility to follow the rudy giuliani rule? the first rock that is thrown you're done and arrested you send a message to everybody else. that will not be tolerated. . >> i want to make a distinction here. there is a big distinction from peaceful protestors today. people protesting were not throwing rocks and between the two, where you get to this you know headlines saying protestors are rioting. rioters are rioting. thugs are looting. >> unfortunately, when you sign up to go on these protest mars you don't always get only boy scouts >> well that is true. listen, richard is correct. some peaceful protestors do fade in the background. but they're interchangeable. >> no they're not, mark. they're not. >> for anyone watching. richard? richard? listen to me. >> people are not interchangeable with rioters and looters. that is absurd. whether it is is -- whether -- whether. >> richard richard, let me finish. you're watching people this is not the first time that they've conducted themselves in this manner. and you kind of wonder why t

so did she have a responsibility to follow the rudy giuliani rule? the first rock that is thrown you're done and arrested you send a message to everybody else. that will not be tolerated. . >> i want to make a distinction here. there is a big distinction from peaceful protestors today. people protesting were not throwing rocks and between the two, where you get to this you know headlines saying protestors are rioting. rioters are rioting. thugs are looting. >> unfortunately, when you sign up to go on these protest mars you don't always get only boy scouts >> well that is true. listen, richard is correct. some peaceful protestors do fade in the background. but they're interchangeable. >> no they're not, mark. they're not. >> for anyone watching. richard? richard? listen to me. >> people are not interchangeable with rioters and looters. that is absurd. whether it is is -- whether -- whether. >> richard richard, let me finish. you're watching people this is not the first time that they've conducted themselves in this manner. and you kind of wonder why t

rudy giuliani says he's not surprised about the rise in home grown terror and he says that we need to be more proactive in stopping it. >> we have got to have surveillance on these groups in the united states that may be encouraging people. i don't think this happened accidentally that he went to syria. something happened in the united states to encourage him going there. this requires intensive cooperation between the fbi and local police. training the local police to see the precursors of terrorism. >> isis making advances. making advances on the iraqi city of ramadi even as air strikes reign down before above. yemen ceasing an oil terminal. leland vittert is live with more with these growing threats. >> these air strikes aren't doing enough. a number of civilians running for their lives from ramadi gives you a good idea a lot of folks worry this city might fall t. goes right to the core of the administration's strategy of fighting isis and the more time that goes by the worse it looks. isis supposed to be on the run with iraqi troops pounding them and coalition providing air sport.

giuliani calling. following the model that you don't raise the sales tax or shifted to another if you have normal growth over time if it comes in above 2% anything beyond that goes to permanent the ratchet down the income tax if you have a more serious recovery and economic growth issue higher taxes revenue, that is when you end up with this situation to ratchet down the taxes. neil: what in the diary environment? >> then you cut spending progress some point you have to reduce spending or doesn't work. >> they have all kinds of adhered to your timeline some of the dance around and the taxpayer pledge everyone looking for the republican side. >> why has he told you know ? >> he did not take the pledge when he ran for governor. he wouldn't raise taxes but did not put it into writing now he seems to be under the impression his father wanted spending cuts but that is not what happened. the spending went up even more than was planned. it is a disaster on all fronts to increase spending, slowed the economy i

so did she have a responsibility to follow the rudy giuliani rule? the first rock that is thrown you're done and arrested you send a message to everybody else. that will not be tolerated. . >> i want to make a distinction here. there is a big distinction from peaceful protestors today. people protesting were not throwing rocks and between the two, where you get to this you know headlines saying protestors are rioting. rioters are rioting. thugs are looting. >> unfortunately, when you sign up to go on these protest mars you don't always get only boy scouts >> well that is true. listen, richard is correct. some peaceful protestors do fade in the background. but they're interchangeable. >> no they're not, mark. they're not. >> for anyone watching. richard? richard? listen to me. >> people are not interchangeable with rioters and looters. that is absurd. whether it is is -- whether -- whether. >> richard richard, let me finish. you're watching people this is not the first time that they've conducted themselves in this manner. and you kind of wonder why t

. >>> giuliani and beth think plague the eating disorder rumors kelly clarkson fat shamed pie fox newsman kendall wore a pretty daring outfit in church. >> hmm. >>> we are tracking the stars' holiday weekend. jennifer lawrence and chris martin caught sneaking onto a private jet. >>> plus the real housewives of new york city palling and brawling. now on "extra," from universal stud crows

>> i came on the nypd in 1979 and then bratton and giuliani in the mid-'90s.hen what happens when you do broken windows and et cetera. thousands 0 of people are alive today because of this. >> you say it works. down in baltimore, there are reports that the mayor gave the stand down order on monday. there's the mayor right there and then apparently also said, just let them go and destroy things. it's only property. >> that's a tragic mistake. i think she had to walk it back several times since then. i see broken windows as a necessary tool in the toolbox in policing and a lot of people alive today because of it and detractors never offer an alternative strategy. is there an acceptable level of murder and carnage and mayhem they'll take? >> so many people watching, ed, monday afternoon when those, you know, they refer to them as children, those kids out of the high school and they started pelting the cops with bricks and rocks and all sorts of stuff. if you were the commissioner of police in baltimore when that happened, what would you do? would you retreat like

former new york city mayor rudy giuliani is sounding off on the problem with hillary clinton's perceived untrust worthiness. >> part of a problem, and that goes to the biggest liability which is trust worthiness. if she is going to present herself she has to present herself as an authentic person to over come the untrust worthiness that has built up over the years with regard to all of the different things. i don't have to mention them all. >> she has a vicious temper. >> what she needs is spontaneity. she goes into chipotle lay, theoretically nobody recognizes her. >> she has on the glasses. how can any one recognize her? >> the legal decisions in our country's history doesn't mean he can't serve jury duty. john roberts showing up like any ordinary citizen to do his civic duty at a courthouse. roberts answered a few questions from the judge and injure or 49 was dismissed. >> the time is 10 minutes after the top of the hour. straight ahead out of a hollywood movie cops say this was all too real. meet the heart doctor who was supposed to be saving lives. instead he was catchinghatching an