the prosecutor's office without giving him a chance to respond in public right at the same time mr gonaives created a lot of share value for nissan and he called the accusations against him a conspiracy yes well this is what journalists and reporters are trying to figure out to what degree is this a case of what. the board says which is that this is a man who. got out of control after so many years of having everything done for him or is it a case of the nissan board being concerned about merger with renault which carlos ghosn is pushing and therefore in the century concocting a legal case to take him out of the picture and to take him down so one of those two pictures is closer to the reality and it's our job to try to figure out which is the truth now at the same time there is the question whether this affair is likely to hurt me son's image as the board has been say. no doubt no matter how it plays out images is going to be tainted one way or another either you have a case of this man who was the savior of nissan going bad in and beginning to embezzle from the company as they're now begi