this is news live from berlin austria looks set for a swing to the right we gratian is on voters' minds today as they head to the polls in national elections thirty one year old sebastian could could become europe's youngest leader we'll go live to a correspondent for the latest also coming up. a german migration officials leaking personal information back to turkey some asylum seekers say their names and addresses have ended up all over texas media. and a further fall from grace for harvey weinstein following sexual assault allegations the movie mogul is expelled from the academy of motion picture the same body that once gave him an oscar for shakespeare in love. i'm a diff to money welcome to the program all strands of voting in a national election that could swing the country to the right and pave the way for europe's youngest leader in all polling stations opened a few hours ago and thirty one year old foreign minister sebastian cook's is tipped to become chancellor his people's party has taken a hard line against refugees in the run up to the vote could is widely expected to go int

because it worked in the rest of the program except for saying we need to stop the gratian we need to cite islam is a wise course that's the main point of the program himself and so far at least as we believe the polls it's working now the far right freedom party is widely expected to enter government in a coalition with the boston quits conservatives how will this all get in the european union. you know when they have to you was already part of the government with your title from the year two thousand there was a huge worry in europe and a lot of problems because back then they were far more anti european then they are now at least in austria the party is part of the use abolition of the still there will be some changes because you have to the government that makes this government closer to the countries in the east for example hungry poland slovakia the so-called group less close to countries like germany or france that have big plans for reforming europe so this might make available harder for the european union to reform itself at least if you look at the plans that the french pre

to contribute to the only to gratian learning the language of the country where they live accepting their way of living living in this country is accepting equal rights for men and women for example that's a clear request but what do you think is going to happen to those tens of thousands of people who got even are they going to end up settling in ghettos like in paris and other major cities no one should one should try to avoid. ghettos and also not a solution. so integration integration into the labor market integration into society is a must when we want to have these full communities peaceful societies in the future can the bans on work us like the one in australia actually work to integrate people into european societies or instead enraged them by forcing to give up on there is precious a sick it's a sick it's a signal it's a signal it's a signal that it's not directed helping of course but is a signal. to the migrants. if you want to leave here if you want to stay for ever in europe if you want to stay for ever in germany in austria france or in the sweden you have to accept the way

the gratian party get strength from austria concerns are raised over the rise of the right in europe is a big election there this weekend. saturday morning here in moscow good morning from me i'm kevin zero in here without t h q i'm starting with the historic nuclear agreement with iran is in jeopardy this weekend after president trump announced that he won't certify to rand's compliance with the deal his decision comes despite the global nuclear watchdog as well as the u.s. and european officials though saying that iran is keeping its side of the bargain. we will not continue down a path whose predictable conclusion is more violence more terror and the very real threat of iran's nuclear breakout importantly iran is not living up to the spirit of the deal the movement now means that u.s. congress has sixty days to decide whether or not to reimpose sanctions against iran as well as to come up with new legislation to try and amend the nuclear deal but if those negotiations fail trump says the deal will be terminated which risks undermining the fragile balance the nuclear deal is secure

using migration for political ends would be something that political leaders may choose to have my gratian is you know playing with migration is like playing with fire you have to always be able to control the fire you have to make sure that there is a legal orderly process through which people come into a country you have to have the opportunity to choose most of the people that come to a country and you have to make sure as you said in your introduction that the way which people come is not chaotic because chaos or with makes the local populations extremely nervous and that's when you have all the frictions that were experiencing on and off i am a believer in long pendulum swings you know migration of so many different issues gets to a point where there is too much or the change is too fast and then people react and then policies fall of that tries to sort of control it much more tightly and then the stream goes the other way sometimes it gets out of control and you have the kinds of things that mr trump is talking about but at the end of the day there is going to be more migration broth

gratian parties. hello and welcome to your business update spain's political crisis continue to dominate the headlines this week as calls for caution and independence grew louder on friday a drama filled day as the castle and parliament voted to declare independence and madrid responded by dissolving ears and calling regional elections all this turmoil has triggered economic uncertainty too with investors feeling jittery about the region's future sub adele catalonia second largest city isn't just the stronghold of the region's independence movement it's also a business hub home to a host of thriving industries spain's fourth largest bank was founded here banko supper del is among a number of corporations that have moved their headquarters away from the region as a result of the crisis that many midsize companies are making a point of staying in catalonia take their supermarket chain its management recently announced it would open nearly thirty new stores in the region creating a thousand jobs. a month

would have an indictment gratian agenda and certainly mr publisher would also like if he quits a two to isolate the czech republic slightly more and this now from from the outside world but i would say that mr publishes at the same time more similar to. syria over risk only because when he went into politics he bought said two major dailies in the czech republic plus the radio station so he's got the. media machinery behind the suit to promote his interests well what we do know also about andre bobbish is that he's quite critical of the e.u. if he is elected prime minister what will this mean for relations with brussels. well it we don't know at this point because we still publish this businessman is that he's a pretty modest who really assess certain things now during the electoral campaign . to impress his electorate which consists mainly of older less educated people and those people are not happy with the european union but at the same time he's going to its own interests. are your structure only public to germany and france aren't in alliance u.s. companies in all of those count

speaking to our correspondent in the capital vienna in just a moment but first here is how you may gratian has shaped the election. thirty one year old sebastian courts only became leader of the people's party and made since then besides economic reform he's made immigration the cornerstone of his election campaign. we've got the guns and i'm going to strike a very clear path which is going to reduce illegal migration to zero who sets off illegally must be stopped at the border taken care of and sent back it can't be that the traffickers decide who gets through and not we as a republic or the european union. his views echo those of the anti immigrant far right freedom party. indiscriminate mass immigration from outside europe naturally islamist terror into the heart of europe seals. and what we have now is that through the many associations structures and mosques there is such a tenacious and dangerous structure that i say ban the radical islamic organizations mosques and kindergartens and expel their members i'm sure. his words have found favor with austrians who fear their country is los

socialist already for seven years in a row he stopped his career seven years ago and the secretary pretty gratian he obviously convinced people he is the new guy on the block all right he's young he's charismatic it sounds like he's convinced voters but how likely is it that the far right freedom party is going to be joining close in government. in the end o.p.'s the at least depends on the outcome at the end of this sunday but most probably attempt and his freedom proxy would get into the cause that second then then they would farm in accordance with the people's party then or approach to refugee school radicalism likewise the little bit different in that approach to europe but both parties feel if europe is necessary but keep in mind the temper is allied with muddying the pen on the bill with us from the president then to cooperate to senate if the and as i read right wing extremists. we will be cautious here because we know the polls have been wrong in the past but if the polls are anything to go by it does look like australia is set to swing to the right what's driving that is it just the ref

due to the news coming to you live from berlin austria looks set for a swing to the right and the gratian is on voters' minds today as they head to the polls in national elections thirty one year old sebastian courts could become europe's youngest leader we'll go live to our correspondent for the latest also coming up devastation in mogadishu medics are fighting to save hundreds of people as the death toll from the massive bombing soars in the somali capital. and our german migration officials leaking close no information back to turkey some asylum seekers say their names and addresses have ended up all over turkish media. and sarah harman welcome to the show it's good to have you with us. austrians are voting in national elections today that could swing the country to the right and pave the way for europe's youngest later polling stations opened a few hours ago and thirty one year old foreign minister sebastian cortes is tipped to become austria's next chancellor and his people's party has taken a hard line against refugees in the run up to this vote course is widely expected to go into

ready for seven years in a row he's got to to his career seven years ago as and the secretary clinton gratian he's obviously convince people that he is the new guy on the block all right he's young he's charismatic it sounds like you convince voters but how likely is it that the far right freedom party is going to be joining chorus in government soon. in the end opiates these days depends on the outcome at the end up this sunday but most probably an attempt to treat him popular get into as a cause that second and then according to the people party then or approach to record gene pool radicalism likewise you need a bit different in the approach to europe but both parties feel less europe is necessary but keep in mind depends on how it is allied with money depends on the. view the from the president then to cooperate to set and if the and as a treaty right wing extremist. we will be cautious here because we know the polls have been wrong in the past but if the polls are anything to go by it does look like austria is set to swing to the right what's driving that is it just the refugee issue or i

citizens to employ an additional ten thousand and gratian officers to deport criminals and unaccompanied children he also outlined measures to penalize so-called sanctuary cities because they refuse to share information to help the government enforce immigration law. a senior u.s. republican senator says president trump's twitter activity is hurting the country's foreign policy bob corker chairs the foreign relations committee has told the new york times that trumps threats to other countries could set the us on the path to world war three. farmers in the kurdish region of northern iraq say iran has stem the flow of water to border towns and follows last month's kurdish independence referendum iraq iran and turkey opposed the vote all of them have a large kurdish minority the scottish national party appears to have delayed plans to push for a second and dependence referendum on the back of britain's exit from the european union scotland rejected independence from the u.k. in two thousand and fourteen but the majority of scots voted to remain in the e.u. during two thousand and sixteen br

it meets emotion and economic gratian all right here an economic question i would say stay in the country because economically it is clearly not beneficial to the cotillion economy but i think it's more an emotional story and something about authorities then a pure economic argument here are and i just let just briefly at the big picture there i mean we see this north south divide of course across europe do you think what we see in catalonia is just the tip of the iceberg. in the political discussion yes in the economic discussion no obviously it is all about solidarity right now we have solidarity within countries who also have a solidarity across the e.u. and we do see in many regions and many countries that the solidarity is at stake that people are putting question marks behind the solidarity but let's not forget or whether we look at an injury of the german context or also the european context solidarity is part of the european project so if we would really give it up. because economically it will be extremely hard for these small islands for the small regions to really survive in th

gratian party gain strength there the spotlight is on the rise of the right.

ever rush hour after a common interest to look at closer call gratian and to see why i seem to be so important to mobilize the driving force into business community but also we in culture entertainment and sports we need to you know to bring it to two societies much closer. to europe has to either change or cease to exist the people who work in this building the e.u. headquarters should change the rules were set up the european union would have to work on fewer issues both with better results he should be paying more attention to protecting external borders fighting against terrorists curbing illegal immigration . as well as harmonizing economic policies on the judicial system otherwise the europe we have today is doing it were transformed into a strange loose community of twenty seven countries with nothing in common. oh don't think of it or leave it will you never let me out you know. the thing you think you. are a little. bit of a. headline news independent pressure catalans launch a petition as they fear the region's officials to declare independence from spain after last sunday'

the company says it will start work on the sixteen billion dollars gratian. so we know and we don't like this as you can see this little here at the moment. so the proposed mine will span sound thirty kilometers and include massive open cot and underground mines at its peak capacity it will produce sixty million tons of coal a year. from the galilee basin the call will be transported almost four hundred kilometers by rail to the company's pool at point the great barrier reef. to india. adani is banking on a seven hundred million dollars loan from the astroid in government to help fund the construction of the railway no major strain in bank is prepared to back the company believing global climate change policies undermine the financial viability of new coal projects and it seems finances are the only challenge adanis facing. just a kilometers from the planned mine site of the bullet springs. the water comes from the great basin and feeds into the comical river that runs through the mine site. a scene of tranquility today but a fierce battle is raging to protec

have a common interest to look at closer call gratian and to see why i seem to be so important to mobilize driving force in debian in this community but also we in culture entertainment and sports we need to you know to bring it to two societies much closer to. los angeles the city of luxury and fame but also an alarming number of people living in the streets. the simple fact in l.a. is there's just not enough shelter even if people on the streets right now decided to come in there's nowhere to come in and it's been a struggle. to get this man found his own response of the problem and constructed dozens of tiny homes for people in need of shelter when you have nothing in order to go. you know having something like this may as well be a castle but do the authorities accept such to lucian a tiny house on a city parking space is not a solution. someone monitoring the site otherwise it will be a free for all and is there a better alternative to end the homelessness crisis. and . i am. going to end. it. but. look into it knowing as. this is international in a recap of some of the week's big sto

reasons need lots of space they regularly cross borders and populated areas during their long way gratian and but after this essential instinct is reindeer and by fences roads and settlements that block their way and that's why a couple of years ago five african states as stablished one of the world's largest conservation areas our team traveled to north east in the media to join the rangers there their aim is to restore the elephants original bagration roots but the only way to make that work is to also help the locals better fit from this conservation effort. here along the crandall river north east in the middle year there's never any shortage of water that's one reason why so many elephants gather here during the dry season. but they're having to share the land with more and more people. farmers like raymond. who are dependent on the harvest from their fields he's constantly having to protect his cornfield from the hungry elephants. we think there were seven elephants. as soon as we heard them we ran out drive them away. but often the elephants aren't afraid of us so they just stay pu

austrian voters turned sharp right on a set to elect the world's youngest leader while and him a gratian party to make significant gains to. u.s. increases next year african aid budget to over five billion dollars as somalia reels from its worst ever terrorist attack. and developments in the catalonia long drawn out story now catalonia as president refuses to clarify whether his regions declaring independence from spain instead asking for talks with the prime minister who's threatening to impose direct rule from madrid. why very good morning for me kevin i just turned eleven in the morning here in moscow this monday first the austrian voters have made a clear shift to the right and they're on course to put the world's youngest leader in office people party leaders sebastian curt's is poised to become chancellor after his center right group secured thirty one percent of the vote while the right wing anti immigrant freedom party is in line to come second with over twenty seven percent its leader christian strachan seemed as jubilant as the winner at times as the first results were announce

the referendum and we know that a lot of controversy as well so with attentional independence that gratian looming early next week will be keeping up to date with events in catalonia. for. the next on the menu today saturday marks sixteen years since the u.s. invasion of afghanistan in two thousand and one then president george w. bush accused the afghan government of sheltering the al qaeda leaders would masterminded the nine eleven attacks that saw the beginning of the so-called war on terror now america's longest running conflict had to be on a verse from today hundreds of people protesting in the afghan capital kabul against the continued presence of u.s. troops in that country demonstrators carried on to us an antenatal sign saying afghanistan's been occupied by america this comes as the united nations has released new figures showing an increase in casualties from the previous. day he says any for me i was praying in my house and when i saw american helicopters i told my wife and children to save themselves after that i just heard a loud noise and then my house was destroyed six peop

is positive or there is no answer at all we will demand mr president to revoke the independence to gratian so obviously developments on rattling quite rapidly here in catalonia for these people the question is i don't think john wants region to leave the country but we have to keep in mind that so many people have been supporting independence and that's why it's quite unlikely they're going to lose interest should independence clearly despite this political crisis that they're gripped him because so many people voted on the couple's first referendum and this is going to issue that's been so important for this region for decades. of pro unity protesters can be seen embracing local catalan police the scenes have surprised some as many regional officers came out against unity with spain during the referendum some catalan police trying to prevent the civil guard from using excessive force against photos. well the same time some apostle over this holiday groups express their opposition to independence more aggressively they burned independence movement flags and marched through the city this la

answer is positive or there is no answer at all will demand mr president to revoke the independence to gratian so obviously developments on raveling quite rapidly fewer chances for these people the question is no i don't think job was to tell me that actually but we have to keep in mind that so many people have been supporting me and that's why and it's quite likely they're going to lose interest in the sea of independence for the religious right this political crisis that their great demand because so many people voted on the so-called first referendum and this is going to issue that's going to start from this region for decades. pro unity protesters can be seen in bracing local police and those scenes of surprise some as many regional officers came out against unity with spain during the referendum some catalan place tried to prevent the civil guard from using excessive force against voters. to me was i the same time some of barcelona's hard right groups expressed their opposition to independence more aggressively they burned independence movement flags and marched through the city with. hum

date of the news coming to you live from berlin austria looks set for a swing to the right and the gratian is on voters' minds today as they head to the polls in national elections thirty one year old sebastian courts could become europe's youngest leader.

is positive or there is no answer at all we will demand mr president to revoke the independence to gratian so for the first demand the answer should be presented to turn the clock of monday morning for the second to which we hope there would be no need to go ten o'clock thursday morning. and to see the church and he joins me on the line so we heard the council on president talking about negotiations not a very welcome response the whole is that the door closed now in negotiations. well neal you know the way things sound it looks like the situation has gone from a chess game to upping the ante to see who blinks first and now really both sides or at least madrid certainly at this hour running out of patience and demanding clarity because as we see now the spanish prime minister now wanting the cat which they want to make it clear whether they're in or out of spain and he's earlier also said today that the room for mediation the way things stand is certainly not there given that madrid still continues to see the results of the observer first referendum illegal. it's impossible to start a dial

only adding to concerns over the rise of right wing populism in europe in france the storm jimmy gratian hardliner and the pan was leading contender in this year's presidential election that last month germany saw a right wing nationalist party enter parliament for the first time in nearly sixty years and now might also be about to see a dramatic shift to the right. get something for deficiencies the deputy district. attorney. but. there is a history of frustration with the established political party during the global recession and twenty nine. and hard on top of the stream of margaret's and twenty three. enormously increased popular discontent. following events in austria for us is pulis lier. there's a lot of intrigue over whether or not the right wing freedom party will do as well as its sisters elsewhere in europe in france and in germany form of fringe parties making it big on the political scene the us skeptic anti immigrant freedom party is seriously complicates things for the leading center right people's party the v p o v p started to harsh in its agenda to attract voters i'm h

last year his struggle to sell his tobacco harvest where advisers help him with his next seed of gratian has largely to shift to one of plans and make himself even less dependent on tobacco production. and that's all the time we had for this edition of eco africa brought to you by dr beller in germany k.p.n. aim kenya and channels t.v. in nigeria my name is joy during beer and we were coming to you from the nairobi national park here in nairobi kenya if you have any stories you want to tell voters to post on environmental issues and innovations in green technology don't hesitate to send of an e-mail or visit our social media site you can also comment on our videos so you next time and thanks for watching a good africa. european stars deliver rousing performance of. jazz flavored song for good let me look around. has touched the hearts of these facts. concert. freedom of expression. of ways has to be defended and news. all over the world. of freedom freedom of art. a multimedia project about artists and their right to express their views freely. w dot com part of freedom. when history boo

there are big elections this weekend in austria and gratian party getting their concerns are growing over the rise of the right in your. hello good afternoon welcome you're watching r.t. international it's just three o'clock here and. now the historic nuclear agreement with iran is in jeopardy after president trump announced he won't certify terrans compliance with the deal his decision does come despite the global nuclear watchdog as well as u.s. and european officials saying iran is keeping its side of the bargain. we will not continue down a path whose predictable conclusion is more violence more terror and the very real threat of iran's nuclear breakout importantly a red is not living up to the spirit of the deal well the move means the u.s. congress now has sixty days to decide whether to reimpose sanctions against iran as well as come up with new legislation to try and amend the nuclear deal but if those negotiations fail trump says the deal will be terminated which risks undermining the fragile balance the nuclear deal has secured although they could be other reasons to think

contention for a place in government ahead of sunday's vote posed to suggest a strong showing for the anti gratian freedom posse it is currently in second place as you can see from these polls of the latest ones and i assume from the top there is the centrist people's party. in its leader and current foreign minister sebastian kurtz says that if he does become chancellor he will end power sharing with the social democrats and then seek a coalition with any other party including perhaps the right wing with which he shares a strong anti immigration stance with the latest results in austria only adding to concern over the rise of populism at the heart of europe in france you might remember the storage immigration hardliners and nationalist marine le pen was a leading contender at one point in this year's presidential election last month last month and we had two in germany seeing a right wing party enter parliament the first time there in nearly sixty years and now austria might be about to follow suit. that gets on the board at the. critics but i've jumped aboard it's really up. to a break there is

all of these companies and and we see that door owsley and they are moving in that they direction gratianand. and put in a policy and that's the problem that you have here because. people began to prepare themselves what would happen if the government brough and and and black come on the power but we think that based on the as a journalist something about you know to be easy even if. governments come under on the power between the coalition. and block i don't think that they will go on using the same birthday knowledge and they are using the cup final important point for matthew you know in britain voted for braggs a lot of leaders were speaking about now we're going to accelerate european integration now those reluctant brits are finally out the club that if that changed now that given what's happened in austria given the rise of the far right in france and germany to. well i think at the beginning of the year the election of macron and then the defeat. bill is in another looms really gate your renewed sense of confidence and it doubled down on that narrative of we're out just get on wit

seek a coalition with any party including perhaps the right wing with which he shares a strong and gratian stance will the latest results in austria only adding to concern over the rise of populism at the heart of europe in france you might remember the storage immigration hardliner and nationalist marine le pen was a leading contender for much of this year's presidential race there and then last month germany did see a right wing party into power for the first time in nearly sixty years and now austria might be about to follow suit. that gets on the board it. is not up to the top couple it's really up. to a break there is a history of frustration with the established political parties during the global recession and twenty nine europe in austria were hit hard and top of this war this stream of migrants in twenty fifteen all that enormously increased popular discontent. with more now from austria his poor sleep. there's a lot of intrigue over whether or not the right wing freedom party will do as well as it's just as elsewhere in europe in france and in germany form a fringe parties making

is positive or there is no answer at all we will demand mr president to revoke the independence to gratian so obviously developments are rattling quite rapidly here and that's a lot of these people questioning the top was the chip kelly coaching but you have to think like that so many people thought it was that's right like they're losing interest shooting to couldn't sleep despite this political crisis that they're praying to him because so many people voted on the first referendum and this is going to be she that's what this reach that's. all pro unity protests as can be seen embracing local catalan police the scenes have surprised some as many regional officers came out against unity with spain during the referendum some catalan police trying to prevent the civil guard from using excessive force against voters. well that's allowed here how this referendum on october the first with ninety percent of voters opting to break away with the fate of the region still in the balance a look now at how victory in a referendum doesn't always mean getting what you voted for. catalans are holding the

with the house giving a bit more time i think it's good and they should cancel even in that little gratian that will not leave anywhere it's obvious that it will leave only basically to getting out of the european union and then doc and we can talk about everything within the law we can govern rules that make us all equal and where all the all the rights are respected not only the rights of the april independence people to get the money well a lot of us journalists have been looking. this this is a the official english translation of the spanish constitution and in particular to section one five five about part of the constitution has never been used before it says if a self-governing community does not fulfill the obligation is imposed on it by the constitution or acts in a way that seriously prejudicial to the general interests of spain the government way following senate approval take all measures necessary to compel the community to meet said obligations simon some of call this the nuclear option. yeah i mean this would be i think the automatic and natural reaction of the spanish centr

gratian in all it's time for such compassion and strength that was shared around the globe and it said something about. the conflict with tim sebastian beat you is getting increasingly fed up with his refusal to take the share prices of refugees long. rauf the new regulations of the lords my guests here in budapest is all time colebatch the prime minister's international's folks with a long uses government thank you playing the bad boy in brussels folks in thirty minutes d w five. mile wide family. from a jedi on somebody one of. the best on the world and international brand. a shared passion. for f.c. byron munich to truly understand all news these three words flow from me as some young. me out on sea kind of you can't touch us refined them by an. exclusive journey into the sun of biomechanics yes i mean it's a kind of culture to walk we are who we are and accept us for what we are we're a family that unbelievable. to me a son me a phenomenon starting october fifteenth on d w. flip. flop climate change is affecting us home folks. flames rising sea levels and erratic levels i join the

now i merely got he has sworn i was always happens when there is other gratian of independent there is a new legal system sought the spanish government cannot claim. that the curation of independence room breaks the spanish illegality because now they don't yet he's under the rule of law of the god allah. is or no argument against that they're a legal one. you know this this was against the constitution of spain so effectively catalonia has broken the law and it will have to face consequences yeah but. legally according. to the spanish constitution does not mean. the movement. has the support it has borne through the support of the over all my surety of the cadillac house. but it won't mean majority of the guy that wanted this and she expressed both in the election and on the seventh of september two thousand and fifteen in the referendum for in durban there's the first of october of this year so. of the catalan movement underpinned and now is a question is a matter of effective yes. we will see if. the long legal system is the effective one or the spanish one. i guess that if if. span

gratian in all its diversity compassion and strength that was shared around the dinner and it said something about. him during the conflict with tim sebastian beat you is getting increasingly fed up with hungry refusal to take a share of migrants and refugees and a whole raft of new regulations my guess here is budapest is salton kovacs the prime minister's international spokesman how long is his government thanks keep playing the bad boy in brussels. by by i mean keep it by him you know never give up they always think they can still win right up to the very last second to. be your son mia lives it. starting october fifteenth on d w and on line. be you is getting increasingly fed up with hungary its refusal to take a share of migrants and refugees and a whole raft of new regulations and laws my guest here in budapest is. the prime minister's international spokesman how long you see the government going to keep playing the bad boy.

is positive or there is no answer at all we will demand mr president to revoke the independence to gratian so for the first demand the answer should be presented to ten o'clock of monday morning for the second to which we hope there would be no need to go ten o'clock thursday morning looks like the situation has gone from a chess game to upping the ante to see who blinks first and now really both sides or at least madrid certainly at this hour running out of patience and demanding clarity because as we see now the panic prime minister now wanting the cat litter quality pushed him on to make it clear whether in or out of. his earlier also a sense that the room for mediation the way things stand is certainly not there given that madrid still continue to see the results of the observer first referendum illegal. it's impossible to start a dialogue on something prohibited by the constitution and this is something that those numerous mediators who offered to broker a solution for this crisis most of them with the best intentions should take into account i have to thank them for their involvement