and she didn't know why until gwen florio found out something that surprised both of them.ice had told the football coach about the incident, but he'd kept it to himself. >> by mistake, and i'm sure an honest mistake, he just did not report it to me. >> reporter: jim o'day was the school's athletic director at the time. he says the coach disciplined the players on his own without involving the administration. >> he brought the -- the men in. regardless of what happened, they were disciplined for being in a situation that they shouldn't have been in. >> reporter: but that locker room justice didn't seem adequate to the dean of students when he found out about the incident a year later. he initiated disciplinary proceedings against kelsey's four alleged rapists. two of the students were no longer enrolled at the college. one student was expelled. and a fourth student was banned from setting foot on campus after he finished out the school year. >> i was a little upset that this kid got to graduate and go live his life. >> reporter: kelsey was also upset by what she'd overheard