the administrative procedures act has been, as judge hannan thwarted, he didn't ultimately decide that for the sake of this preliminary injunction he reserved that as well as the constitutional issues for the future but the states certainly believe that in all three cases the president has failed. >> let me afford that opportunity for professor blackman and professor foley to respond to that as well. >> so i think that professor legamski opined dapa didn't do far enough. a november 25th blog post, the professor wrote how come dapa didn't apply to the parents of the dreamers? the parents of the daca beneficiaries. this raises an very important point. many professors signed that letter and think the president didn't go far enough. so the doj's perceptions but was more important than that. but i will stress for the reason why they didn't go far enough because there has to be a relationship to a group that congress has preferred. daca was people without any legal status. dapa is the parents of u.s. citizens. one important point is parents of u.s. citizens wait 21 years for a petition for a

the four army national guard members were based out of hannan, louisiana. the seven marines were special operations in north carolina. this is the kind of chopper that we're talking about, a uh-60 blackhawk helicopter. file video of the same kind of chopper here. last night's crash happened over the gulf of mexico. officials say most of the 11 crew members have now been recovered. as you likely know, it will be a very long time to determine the official cause of this crash. but as of right now, officials say there was heavy fog and a low ceiling at the time of the crash. however, we also checked with nbc's weather channel, which reports that at the time of the crash, it was cloudy with light wind and fog developing, but that visibility was fine. no rain, no thunderstorms. about six hours after the crash, the u.s. coast guard discovered the debris field, inchluding th tail rotor. most of the crew members have been recovered. there was a second blackhawk helicopter that was on the same training mission. it managed to return to base safely, so whether or not i

the administrative procedures act has been, as judge hannan thwarted, he didn't ultimately decide thatr the sake of this preliminary injunction he reserved that as well as the constitutional issues for the future but the states certainly believe that in all three cases the president has failed. >> let me afford that opportunity for professor blackman and professor foley to respond to that as well. >> so i think that professor legamski opined dapa didn't do far enough. a november 25th blog post, the professor wrote how come dapa didn't apply to the parents of the dreamers? the parents of the daca beneficiaries. this raises an very important point. many professors signed that letter and think the president didn't go far enough. so the doj's perceptions but was more important than that. but i will stress for the reason why they didn't go far enough because there has to be a relationship to a group that congress has preferred. daca was people without any legal status. dapa is the parents of u.s. citizens. one important point is parents of u.s. citizens wait 21 years for a petition for a vi