earlier we spoke to so talk a hashi who was a former deputy head of office of the un high commissioner for human rights and occupied palestine. he says is ralph actions and guys on saturday a yet another breach of international law. israel has shown itself time and time again. it has says, expose the sell time and time again that it doesn't care about the international laws and forward. it doesn't care about international humanitarian law. there are clear standards of proportionality. so when you're making a tight, when you engage in an attack, that might cause a civilian loss of life or damage, disability and objects, while you're attacking, it's not necessarily illegal as such, or that doesn't necessarily make it so legal, right? but the, the losses to any kind of civilian objects, your life has to be proportion. and i think it's pretty clear that, you know, these were not proportionate. and this is something that we've seen over and over again. not just since last october, but in pretty much every single attack that israel has engaged in every single offensive that is realized engaging and gaza. we've known all along and cert