hassan khani. you have been with us until this moment, from all the good viewers of the program above all , i thank you for watching this program until this moment , may god protect you, ali. i couldn't continue my education at all . be happy with your family. may you be the companion of hazrat ali . may you have a blessed month of ramadan. thank you for what we have. with the help of hope, be a broken heart. be the key to closed doors. in the name of allah , the most merciful, the most merciful, i am at your service, dear and respected viewers , we are at your service with another special program, and mr. khatibi, the financial administrative director of the ministry of science , research and technology, is also present here, and we will ask him some questions. what in 1402? events what has happened to the students, to the academics , and what is going to happen in the new year of 1403 ? you are very welcome, mr. khatib . let's start the discussion of the dormitories first , whether in the new yea

hassan khani in the field of agriculture.ould like to tell you that his statement regarding the specialization of the business is completely correct , but the question is that when we want to design the structure of the ministry of housing. with what logic do we design the structure? the issue of specialization, the issue of the size of a ministry, the issue of abstraction or separation and integration in the fact that it is big or small. the ministry of home affairs, well, the specialized discussions of public administration , which are actually discussed in the public administration of public administration, but the issue is that the basis what, for example, if the specialization of that work is the basis , then in the ministry of agricultural jihad, we also have different departments that are really specialized, that is, for example , the specialization that is necessary for the field of agriculture and the specialization that is necessary for the field of dairying are very different from each other, and each one is really

hassan khani. well, dear brother, look, we are not against, nobody is in favor of governmentizing the economy . the general sentences are the same. it doesn't matter that we don't know from the leadership's statements from the slogan of the year, from the fact that the gentleman says that the popularization of the economy is equal to the trade unionization of the economy, which we should not see. the point is that you say that sir let's leave it to snaf. if this is your interpretation, it means that we should leave the pricing to snaf. my suggestion is that there is no problem. let us leave the pricing to snaf. snuff, but the formula of this pricing should be clear , we can't say mr. snuff, you can make a box, a magic box , any price will come out of that magic box. demand can set the price fairly in conditions of stability. in conditions of competition, in conditions of perfect competition, it can make pricing fair . but what if there was a monopoly? in conditions of monopoly, on the supply side,

hassan khani , we talked about market regulation and marketing. let's go to you. we have about 10 minutes to go and talk about my supervision. one of the the criticisms that you raised now were that zinfan's snafs themselves can't have supervision , you are supplementing their explanations to the class under them. i suspected a conflict of interest here. there are interests, and since there are suspicions of conflicts and interests, it is not possible to be satisfied with the supervisory mechanisms of the guild . asalaf's friends also have a problem with government supervision , but a division of duties is necessary, as we are with supervision it happens at different levels. anyway, if the supervision was a level of supervision that does not require the presence of the government and the guild itself can be responsible for this level of supervision, there is no prohibition , the guild should take care of it, but there must be an arbitration mechanism. in order to protect the interests of the people, if a person goes to complain about a taxi, if he finds a place in

hassan khani mentioned and the question that so far in this, for example, how many in the year when the law of concentration was passed, all these powers were in the hands of the ministry of jihad and agriculture, and as you said , they were concentrated in one place. we had to follow a path in order to reach that basic people's governance mechanism that came up from the bottom with a people's production structure . a very large part of what we have achieved so far will be lost in order to reach that destination, which means that i agree that the current situation is not at all defensible in that sense, and in fact, the performance container that exists in the existing structure will hinder our work. it makes it difficult to defend the idea , but anyway, we can't fall short of the principle of this idea, that there should be concentration, the work should be entrusted to the organizations, but the issue is that if the ministry of commerce is formed and the important arms of the ministry of jihad, agriculture are in the discussions business should be taken away from him, i am not looking

hassan khani in the field of agriculture.ill tell you about the specialization of the commercial discussion. it is absolutely correct, but the question is, when we want to design the structure of the ministry of housing, with what logic do we design the structure? the discussion of specialization, the discussion of the size of a ministry, the discussion of the effect of abstraction or separation and integration in the actual size or smallness of the ministry of home affairs , well, the specialized discussions of public administration, which are actually discussed in public administration, public administration , but the issue is what is the basis. for example, if there is a basis for the specialization of that job, then you and the ministry we also have different departments that are really specialized, for example, the specialization required for the field of agriculture is very different from the specialization required for the dairy field, and each is really specialized, but it does not necessarily mean that , for example,

hassan khani, why do you agree with the establishment of this ministry of home affairs ? much do you agree with mr. soudagar's words before starting the discussion? let's do it. now, i emphasize again that the debate may not be very relevant, but it is important, but we will try to agree to your request and debate, but before we debate, i will read a few posts with each other . that separation and the claim of the ministry of housing is in you d. the government as a rule does not significantly reduce or increase the size of the government. if you have a dispute , let's discuss this with each other. it means that a government in a country may have 50 ministries of home affairs, then it may increase these 50 according to its expediency. 30 up to 40 , the size of the government should not be considered in terms of cost. the experience of recent years , at least since the 1990s, when the ministry of privacy, mining, and trade was separated and the ministry of home affairs was formed , does not show us anything that the ministry of home affairs has done since mr. ahmadinejad,

hassan khani . think that tomorrow, for example, the ministry of commerce will be formed and all these powers that we are talking about will be transferred to this ministry. as an expert, you are against this practice, what will happen to your fellow field? agriculture is also the field of your presence, that the industry will fall on the ground, what is happening now , i think it will only make the administrative processes inside the ministry of jihad difficult, so maybe in practice nothing will happen in the current situation, but you will move towards that desired situation. we will definitely have challenges, that is, i know very well that in the current state of our public administration structure, we can hope that in the situation where we have multiple goals, we will be able to manage several home ministries in such a coordinated way, so i want to i can say that maybe in the current situation as well we cannot say at all that if trade is separated , the situation, for example, the price of in

hassan khani, another economic expert of the program, as a supporter of the formation of the ministryffairs, which i presented to you . hello, god bless both guests of the program . i want to start with mr. soudagar and ask the reason for their opposition to the establishment of the ministry of commerce. greetings to you and all the respected viewers and the same kind of acceptance of prayer and worship in this blessed month. i would like to inform you that there is a fundamental discussion regarding the mission of the agricultural sector. in the past , the agricultural sector in all parts of the world was usually seen as being responsible for the production of raw agricultural products. then that.