commissioner hayon. i also certificate >> the respondent is is presumed to be innocent in a subsequent hearing the vice chair shall issue a regulation for the investigation and enforcement proceedings. >> agenda item 6. the commission voted in closed session not to disclose the closed session dlibsdz the commission sought the advice of the attorney regarding the litigations in addition i wanted to raise one thing during the public comment prior to us moving into the closed session one person was giving a public comment subsequent as we were moving into closed session ms. johnson indicated to me should had not completed her public comment which the staff confirmed we asked ms. johnson to return to give her public comment but she declined and ms. johnson expressed to me that she found my response to be rude and for that i apologize ms. johnson. you need a motion on the session? that >> is there a motion to not disclose the closed session dlibsz related to agenda item number 6? >> second. >> all in favor, s

three commissioners -- commissioner hur, renne and commissioner hayon are political flacks answerable own to those that appoint them. that is not a personal attack. it is my personal opinion and i base it on years of watching you. you do nothing but protect the people and in my case that was heard without my presence commissioner hayon participated defended the person that was on the opposite side of the case. talked all about the reasons why they were right and why i was wrong and then at the end recused herself to avoid the appearance of a conflict when she actively was in a conflict during the entire proceeding. i had sincere hopes for the new commissioners and although they talk a good game there is nothing that will indicate that they will just follow the lead of the other members. i challenged you before. come here before the public and gave examples how you improved city government. you never do for the simple reason you can't. you don't do a damn thing to make government in this city better, nothing. in fact you are the antithesis of what the citizens of this city intended whe

commissioner hayon >> i'll second that. yeah, i'll agree to that. >> does that is there a motion to do so? >> so moved. is there a second? >> i'll second it. >> all in favor, say i. >> i. >> (inaudible). >> i think you've had public comment on whether or not to go into closed session there's no reason for a second round of public comment. >> the city attorney has advised we've already had. it says on every motion that's the motion before we had a discussion of the agenda >> including whether to meet in closed session. did we just vote? okay >> okay. we are going to - >> why don't we do the public discussion so those folks don't have to wait until we do the other stuff. >> does the public prefer we do that? >> yeah. >> let's do the public session on item 6. gentlemen you want to give us some background and status on the matter that's pending >> this case went to the court of appeals earlier this year. there was a certain amount of time when briefs were submitted by both parties back and forth oral argument were heard on may

and county of san francisco and they have a mandate attached to it and something that commissioner hayon pointed out a good point and two architects on the commission and both have come before you for a waiver which is something that shouldn't be dismissed. with those ark seats -- architect seats and commissioner hayon made a good point many work with the city and county and to dismiss anyone because of that not taking into consideration commissioner chow's ability to wall himself off from the conflicts deprives a large portion of citizens from serving on the commission in this instance and does a disservice to the people of the city and county to do that so we're chrj charged in the mayor's office to appoint diverse appointees and this is part of that and i ask you to approve this and it's difficult for the mayor to fill the seat in a manner that would not be present a conflict for that commissioner. and i am happy to answer any questions. >> [inaudible] >> are we taking questions? yeah ms. wheaton. so are you aware of commissioner comight's waiver? >> his waiver request? yeah. i was ma

commissioner hayon. commissioner andrews is excised we're expecting commissioner

commissioner hayon.missioner andrews is excised we're expecting commissioner keane mom ring with the harmonies of liberty;

which i'm sure even commissioner hayon living in the richmond understands the difference between plaintiffs and independents. commissioner keane last month wanted to quickly move to ignore deputy city attorney whites advise to postpone it for a month. commissioner keane according to the audit wanted to jump into an open session on the spot i believe it struck me then and now to the extent commissioner keane elected to attempt to ignore deputy city attorney josh whites city attorney advise. found it like appoints to the sunshine task force. where supervisor tang is using a witness test of undying loyalty to city attorney advise. so if commissioner keane can ignore whites advise why can't the sunshine task force who overall had reached a simple interpretation of city attorney advise. as many city policy bodies often do during open session they found ways to get around the advise presented by the deputy city attorney. but what happened no commissioner keane's idea of gap government transparent and holding it in closed session particularly on a pacing says that's not pending litigation anymore.

commissioner hayon. commissioner andrews is excised we're expecting commissioner keane mom ring with the harmonies of liberty; the public comment this is not appearing on the agenda. >> good evening chair patrick i'm here as a private citizen i'd like to ask the gentleman to distribute the 5 copies for the commissioners leave one for commissioner keane and commissioner andrews that's a formal complaint of a statement of incapable violations by sunshine task force member david. was submitted to the clerk of the board of supervisors this morning and to mr. chad field mr. syncountryside. mr. pill paul has no business coming before you and holding himself out as an agent of the task force. or an ambassador for the task force during the deliberations of sunshine referrals sent to you for enforcement. i believe it's your responsibility commissioner andrews that when mr. pill paul comes up to the microphone and introduces himself david pill paul member of the sunshine task force and sales to mention he's speaki

commissioner hayon.ommissioner andrews is excised we're expecting commissioner keane mom ring with the harmonies of liberty; the public comment this is not appearing on the

commissioner hayon. commissioner andrews is excised we're expecting commissioner keane mom ring with the harmonies of liberty; the public comment this is not appearing on the agenda. >> good evening chair patrick i'm here as a private citizen i'd like to ask the gentleman to distribute the 5 copies for the commissioners leave one for commissioner keane and commissioner andrews that's a formal complaint of a statement of incapable violations by sunshine task force member david. was submitted to the clerk of the