>> i would like to echo commissioner hayon about the leadership of you. you and commissioner an drews and the selection from the executive director and all the work you did on prop c meeting with the public and serving as our representative, it was a lot of extra work and appreciate it. >> thank you. i call the question. all in favor? >> aye. >> opposed? one obtain and 4 approve. the second item on- >> actually you can't obstain. >> i have a conflict of interest but i'll vote if that makes you happier. >> i'm happier >> item 3 is the election of the vice chair. do i hear a nomination? commissioner keane? >> yes, i also like to renominate commissioner andrews as vice chair to the commission. >> i hear a second? >> second. >> any discussion? any public comment? >> patrick mu net shah. on the way into this chamber i spoke with commissioner andrews and he said between his work on the ethics commission as a commissioner his work on the non profit he is too busy for, so if that is the case, and if he were being honest about matters, i think he should thank comm

>> i would like to echo commissioner hayon about the leadership of you. you and commissioner an drews and the selection from the executive director and all the work you did on prop c meeting with the public and serving as our representative, it was a lot of extra work and appreciate it. >> thank you. i call the question. all in favor? >> aye. >> opposed? one obtain and 4 approve. the second item on- >> actually you can't obstain. >> i have a conflict of interest but i'll vote if that makes you happier. >> i'm happier >> item 3 is the election of the vice chair. do i hear a nomination? commissioner keane? >> yes, i also like to renominate commissioner andrews as vice chair to the commission. >> i hear a second? >> second. >> any discussion? any public comment? >> patrick mu net shah. on the way into this chamber i spoke with commissioner andrews and he said between his work on the ethics commission as a commissioner his work on the non profit he is too busy for, so if that is the case, and if he were being honest about matters, i think he should thank comm

>> i would like to echo commissioner hayon about the leadership of you. you and commissioner an drews and the selection from the executive director and all the work you did on prop c meeting with the public and serving as our representative, it was a lot of extr work and appreciate it. >> thank you. i call the question. all in favor? >> aye. >> opposed? one obtain and 4 approve. the second item on- >> actually you can't obstain. >> i have a conflict of interest but i'll vote if that makes you happier. >> i'm happier >> item 3 is the election of the vice chair. do i hear a nomination? commissioner keane? >> yes, i also like to renominate commissioner andrews as vice chair to the commission. >> i hear a second? >> second. >> any discussion? any public comment? >> patrick mu net shah. on the way into this chamber i spoke with commissioner andrews and he said between his work on the ethics commission as a commissioner his work on the non profit he is too busy for, so if that is the case, and if he were being honest about matters, i think he should thank commi

commissioner hayon, here. commissioner keane, here. we have a visitor. commissioner hur. let me say we welcome you back and particularly in the view the fact we'll cover the wistal blow rr regulations we passed at the last meeting and i see you didn't bring your plaque that you stethly took away in february. >>

. >> before we vote that commissioner renne i'm in support of commissioner hayons motion on the floor. >> i'd like to think that mr. pelham having heard the district attorney indicate she has the horticulture to make that decision without you that that will get you off the backside and take the leadership role and prove mr. hart's wrong there will be a 3 to 2 vote all right. but a 3 to 2 vote to audit the mayor campaigns for 2015 san franciscans expect you to do the ethical thing and conduct the audits because if he didn't have anything to hide he shouldn't be afraid for audited even in la you have pelham; right? if you've done nothing wrong don't be afraid of an audit it is only when the - and the keiths get caught on federal that the mayors start worrying about what will happen on an audit you can doing the right thing with a 3 to 2 vote and audit did mayors campaign or ms. pelham so consider ord the audit independently based on the city attorney information san franciscans want to welcome you with open arms ms. pelham that's because we've had too much corruption at city hall for to

. >> before we vote that commissioner renne i'm in support of commissioner hayons motion on the floor. >> i'd like to think that mr. pelham having heard the district attorney indicate she has the horticulture to make that decision without you that that will get you off the backside and take the leadership role and prove mr. hart's wrong there will be a 3 to 2 vote all right. but a 3 to 2 vote to audit the mayor campaigns for 2015 san franciscans expect you to do the ethical thing and conduct the audits because if he didn't have anything to hide he shouldn't be afraid for audited even in la you have pelham; right? if you've done nothing wrong don't be afraid of an audit it is only when the - and the keiths get caught on federal that the mayors start worrying about what will happen on an audit you can doing the right thing with a 3 to 2 vote and audit did mayors campaign or ms. pelham so consider ord the audit independently based on the city attorney information san franciscans want to welcome you with open arms ms. pelham that's because we've had too much corruption at city hall for to

. >> commissioner hayon has been excused. and i would like to take this opportunity to introduce and welcome our newest commissioner, daina chiu, who is going to -- i'm absolutely certain going to be a worthy successor to commissioner hur and we look forward to working with her. she is an attorney, was in the general counsel's office at mckisson, presently not working at the moment, i understand, other than her family dutis and i told her that means that we have someone that can spend a lot of time on ethics commission matters. [laughter ] >> but we're delighted to have her here, and welcome. >> thank you, i'm delighted to be here. >> all right. turning to item no. 2 on the agenda, which is public comment on matters appearing or not appearing on the agenda. any comments? >> commissioners, san francisco open government, as previously stated i'm filing the first of a series of complaints with the -- directly with the ethics commission as november i went to the ethics commission and talked to two of your investigators both of wh