. >> commissioner keane commissioner chiu commissioner kopp and commissioner hayon is not present but we anticipate she'll arrive shortly item agenda item 2 public comment on matters appearing or not appearing on the agenda anyone wish to speak on - >> that item? >> commissioners ray hart for san francisco open government. in december this ethics commission held a hearing in the referral by the sunshine ordnance task force in ray heart commissioner hayon has exhibited could have recused herself in the matter rather than a fair hearing as the good golf o government guides we this facts and law commissioners hayon's statements state their prejudice in part quote the issue of disclosure by the library quote/unquote the belief this is something amiss with the friends and quote individuals that use this measure of requesting is a form of harassment end quote none of the issue issues had my bearing on the case before the commission that is a clear-cut case and 9 to nothing by the task force and supervisor mondejar was the sublth of an i dr dragged it out for a year and two months one member

. >> commissioner keane commissioner chiu commissioner kopp and commissioner hayon is not present but we anticipate she'll arrive shortly item agenda item 2 public comment on matters appearing or not appearing on the agenda anyone wish to speak on - >> that item? >> commissioners ray hart for san francisco open government. in december this ethics commission held a hearing in the referral by the sunshine ordnance task force in ray heart commissioner hayon has exhibited could have recused herself in the matter rather than a fair hearing as the good golf o government guides we this facts and law commissioners hayon's statements state their prejudice in part quote the issue of disclosure by the library quote/unquote the belief this is something amiss with the friends and quote individuals that use this measure of requesting is a form of harassment end quote none of the issue issues had my bearing on the case before the commission that is a clear-cut case and 9 to nothing by the task force and supervisor mondejar was the sublth of an i dr dragged it out for a year and two months one member

. >> commissioner keane commissioner chiu commissioner kopp and commissioner hayon is not present buthortly item agenda item 2 public comment on matters appearing or not appearing on the agenda anyone wish to speak on - >> that item? >> commissioner

chiu here, renne here, kopp present, hayon resigned last week from the commission, so we have a vacant seat that the mayor will be filling. surely we help. first we will take public comment on matters appearing were not appearing on the agenda. >> thank you chairman. members of the commission. [inaudible] friends of ethics [inaudible/off mic] i think she had almost a full six years because she had part of an earlier term and she was a stalwart member of the commission. >> for the record i'm told charlie-i think i second that. i think any commissioner that served at this time is responsible for helping to bring the commission light years ahead and it's good to see commission growing up and i think commissioner hayon certainly participated in that process and encouraged others to follow such as commissioner kopp. also, help us secure the appointment of a new stellar staff, so i want to thank her for her service. >> commissioner dooley opened out in. so we were talking about the ongoing fraud being perpetrated on the citizens of san francisco by the office of the mayor. from the findings

chiu here, renne here, kopp present, hayon resigned last week from the commission, so we have a vacant seat that the mayor will be filling. surely we help. first we will take public comment on matters appearing were not appearing on the agenda. >> thank you chairman. members of the commission. [inaudible] friends of ethics [inaudible/off mic] i think she had almost a full six years because she had part of an earlier term and she was a stalwart member of the commission. >> for the record i'm told charlie-i think i second that. i think any commissioner that served at this time is responsible for helping to bring the commission light years ahead and it's good to see commission growing up and i think commissioner hayon certainly participated in that process and encouraged others to follow such as commissioner kopp. also, help us secure the appointment of a new stellar staff, so i want to thank her for her service. >> commissioner dooley opened out in. so we were talking about the ongoing fraud being perpetrated on the citizens of san francisco by the office of the mayor. from the findings

chiu here, renne here, kopp present, hayon resigned last week from the commission, so we have a vacant

. >> commissioner keane commissioner chiu commissioner kopp and commissioner hayon is not present but we anticipate she'll arrive shortly item agenda item 2 public comment on matters appearing or not appearing on the agenda anyone wish to speak on - >> that item? >> commissioners ray hart for san francisco open government. in december this ethics commission held a

chiu here, renne here, kopp present, hayon resigned last week from the commission, so we have a vacant seat that the mayor will be filling. surely we help. first we will take public comment on matters appearing were not appearing on the agenda. >> thank you chairman. members of the commission. [inaudible] friends of ethics [inaudible/off mic] i think she had almost a full six years because she had part of an earlier term and she was a stalwart member of the commission. >> for the record i'm told charlie-i think i second that. i think any commissioner that served at this time is responsible for helping to bring the commission light years ahead and it's good to see commission growing up and i think commissioner hayon certainly participated in that process and encouraged others to follow such as commissioner kopp. also, help us secure the appointment of a new stellar staff, so i want to thank her for her service. >> commissioner dooley opened out in. so we were talking about the ongoing fraud being perpetrated on the citizens of san francisco by the office of the mayor. from the findings

chiu here, renne here, kopp present, hayon resigned last week from the commission, so we have a vacant seat that the mayor will be filling. surely we help. first we will take public comment on matters appearing were not appearing on the agenda. >> thank you chairman. members of the commission. [inaudible] friends of ethics [inaudible/off mic] i think she had almost a full six years because she had pa