thank you for the detailed questions, director heminger. i want to say a few comments just to reminds us all we are looking for solutions here. i know it may feel you are under attack. we are trying to surface ideas you may not have had and appreciate your service and you work heard to solve the issues every day. i wanted to add-on 2 pieces and go to director hinze on the phone. getting you say we don't have enough resources. too big of a job and not enough resource we will heard a lot of conversation about alternatives to traditional mreegs, is there a piece what is involved in traffic safety that could be supported by nonpolice officers we could supplement with am busy dovers or other solutions like that. a license play that license play minot tell mow who is in the car. does not tell me had they did before or when they are on their way to do. i would never wuk up to a car on a traffic stop without a vest and my utility belt. i had a very successful and lucky career but others have not. for a moving violation. i don't think i would sends

director heminger. >> here. >> director hinze. >> present >> director yekutiel is walking in. present. director boarden is not expected director hinze is attending remost. she must appear on cam are to vote on any item. item 3 the ring and use of cell phones and electronic devices are presented the chair may order removal from the room of anyone responsible for reasoning of a no one or sounds prugs electronic device. item 4, approval of minutes for march 7 regular meeting y. directors are there changes to the minutes? >> we will upon open public meant for those in the room. on the minutes from match 7th. open the phone secretary silva j. remote public not to exceed 10 minutes. any members wish to comment press star 3. i see no one in the queue joyful will take a motion. >> moved. we will take that as a second. call the roll. motion to approve the minutes director cajina. >> aye >> director heminger >> aye. >> director hinze. >> aye >> yekutiel. >> aye >> eakon. >> aye >> item 5, communication. colleague

director heminger you have benched the soun down sides. some having to do with equity there is an equity question where san francisco has i 10th of the population but muni carries over 50% of all the transit riders in the bay area. when you have i dispute over resources or priorities. do we wait population or ridership? some of the issues that need to be resolved are -- it is great when we are in agreement. when we xom peat for resources or priorities how do we make the decision in a way that it is right. this it is obviously a lengthy subject of conversation. i will decide on this point. i dothe work this has been done here is valuable. the challenge is ahead of you not behind. and -- again the notion of applying that same thinking to our planning operation you know we got a bit of a pause in san francisco because we completed major capitol projects. got another one with train control headed down the track now. and i think this gives us an opportunity in addition to the short term stuff had should the 30 stockton stop and the jackson begi

director heminger. thick bit thought you would get through a meeting without me taushg being this one is irresistible. i had a couple of comments but first a question. that it is i had a hard time swallowing a few of the results of the estimated reduction in green house gas e missions. you had a couple at the gipping that were mall amounts for tdm and i agree with this i'm not sure that should be small they may be should be zero. but then there was one this was better than either one of those which is public out reach. i don't see how talking to people can get you any green house gas reductions. yea we model today on community based transportation plans the idea is community based transportation plans are low cost. so you can implement them sooner and therefore shift more people out of cars to the low carbon modes. the other thing sucan get community buy in when there is buy in to community transportation plans then they are like low to mode shift. >> that is a nice drive. this is a bit of a stretch to

. >> we are expecting director heminger today. ure have a kwoer and up for the record i note that director hinds is remote. she must apore on camera in order to speak on any items. all those here will be taken by roll call. item 3. the sound producing electronics are prohibited. the chair may order removal from the room anyone responsible for ring or use of a cell phone or other sound electronic device. item 4. approval of minute for february 7 special meeting and february 21 regular meeting. >> thank you. . are there comments on the minutes for our special day long workshop or last meeting on february 21. >> in dam chair. if i could for the workshop minutes for february 7 add the organizations for the [inaudible] under item 6. [inaudible]. i would be supportive. other comments on the minutes? i will energy that i received now comments from 2 members of public that they would like to see a bit more reflective in the minutes of substantlies of the panel. when we heard from the community members. that was a meaningful discussion to

director heminger. thank you in dam chair there is a lot to say about this. and i guess i will start by stating the obvious that this is a really disspiriting report on our lack of progress on what everybody says is job one. which is safety. of the people who use our system. safety for all modes. when you look at it was slide 10 with the bar charts. and we go from 2007 with 41 fataliies to last year with 37. . i isn't in the true. there were a lot mark for identification efforts to try to knock down the numbers. some conventional, some infrastructure. some of them education actions. but i think we have to face the fact that when we are doing is not working. doing more it or presenting a series of slides this learningly catalog when we have done but i think are not sufficiently focussed on had we are not doing. that might be more effective. now i know we have been trying. we put a lot of eggs in the basket of automated speed enforcement. but that is something that we have yet to bring home the bacon on that is a challenge as you see in the slide about the othe

. >> we are expecting director heminger today. ure have a kwoer and up for the record i note that director hinds is remote. she must apore on camera in order to speak on any items. all those here will be taken by roll call. item 3. the sound producing electronics are prohibited. the chair may order removal from the room anyone responsible for ring or use of a cell phone or other sound electronic device. item 4. approval of minute for february 7 special meeting and february 21 regular meeting. >> thank you. . are there comments on the minutes for our special day long workshop or last meeting on february 21. >> in dam chair. if i could for the workshop minutes for february 7 add the organizations for the [inaudible] under item 6. [inaudible]. i would be supportive. other comments on the minutes? i will energy that i received now comments from 2 members of public that they would like to see a bit more reflective in the minutes of substantlies of the panel. when we heard from the community members. that was a meaningful discussion to

cajina >> aye >> heminger. >> aye. hinze. >> aye joovm director yekutiel. >> aye >> chair eakon. >> aye. testimony is approved we will return to item 10. 2 approving 20th street as part of the slow streets program electronically [inaudible] residential street in san francisco prioritize biking walking and transportation ensure access to everyone. do you have comments. this is smith brought up before the board felt like the area from valence why to shotwelwas unsuccessful as a slow street. an active parking lot flchlt a lot of sxars thought abused 99 tables and chairs but [inaudible]. dangerous and the point of slow streets to reduce the initial cars. i got a bunch of director feedback from folks tloornd are cyclists that were confused why this board voted make 22nd a slow street. sounds like we got out reach. about bring 20th back in halfway measure. so i wanted understand the process to bring it back. and then talk about the shot welbeginning of it. i also remember 20th and shot wel. 20th is a slow street it was 4 way

. >> director heminger. >> here. >> director hinze. >> present >> director yekutiel is walking in. present. director boarden is not expected director hinze is attending remost. she must appear on cam are to vote on any item. item 3 the ring and use of cell phones and electronic devices are presented the chair may order removal from the room of anyone responsible for reasoning of a no one or sounds prugs electronic device. item 4, approval of minutes for march 7 regular meeting y. directors are there changes to the minutes? >> we will upon open public meant for those in the room. on the minutes from match 7th. open the phone secretary silva j. remote public not to exceed 10 minutes. any members wish to comment press star 3. i see no one in the queue joyful will take a motion. >> moved. we will take that as a second. call the roll. motion to approve the minutes director cajina. >> aye >> director heminger >> aye. >> director hinze. >> aye >> yekutiel. >> aye >> eakon. >> aye >> item 5, communication. colleagues are there any communications today? i will note for the public we are goi

squads that don't handle collisions or respond to other issues they are the ones that commissioner heminger was tucking about. than i were within internal. upon >> thank you. . >> thank you. thank you, officer for being on the hot seat. >> we are part of this so i want to be forth coming and as not -- this is what is going on the best we can do i got it twice i'm happy torhere. >> my colleagues took most my questions. i share aloft of enforcement is not only answer to this i am a believer in [inaudible] and community policing through environmental design and believe design plays a factor in how we can mitigate a lot of the opportunity, like that piece of the triangle in terments of creating opportunity for folks to use the worse judgment with a situation. and so i department to ask you just you know -- i wonder if we can't invest more in law enforcement is there equipment or things we can do in invest in that. like what how effective are radar speed signs from your experience? do they help deter folks. do they stop when than i see i'm going 20 miles over the limit. is this chipping away at