henry liften on behalf of respondent department of public health. with me this evening are inspector jennifer (inaudible) and inspector (inaudible) i do want to mention before i cover a few points from my brief that inspector (inaudible) reached out to the appellate and if the board is interested i would allow her the opportunity to give them a update on the discussion that occurred. >> sure, please go ahead. >> thank you. >> thank you commissioners good evening. jen (inaudible) environmental health. i did call mr. alle one of the owners of koheba gift inc. and did answer and stated he is not planning to attend the hearing and had somebody else that is attending but seemed frustrated that they were not on, but told me he would call them and make sure they got on. i provided my phone number if there were issues. i did not hear back and did not see them come on the zoom call and so i called back but he did not pick up that time and left him a message. if they needed any assistance. >> okay. thank you for that update. mr. lipten do you want to continue