was john hersey who made his way to hiroshima and wrote the first story for american audiences in the new yorker of what really happened. so i would like to ask you all to share your thoughts on that would youd, kai, like to start us off? i am you to. -- muted. that is an interesting question, the role of the early journalists in covering this, the thing i am struck by always is that if you look at the record of the early critics of the bomb, they were actually all republicans and right-wingers. review, in thel 1950's, was a critic. herbert hoover was a critic of the decision, saying it was unnecessary. and it was ironically left wingers and left-wing publications like the nation magazine, that defended the decision. and then, low and behold, by the 1960's and 1970's, everything slept. and it -- everything slept. -- flipped. and it was the right wing defending the decision and the left-wing had become critics of it. this is ironic. as journalists we should be aware of the politics of this hot button issue. you included a chapter in your book, the decision, about the role of journalist