qualification evaluation of the current servants of themis in accordance with their positions is ongoing. the higher qualifying commission verifies professional competence and integrity. today we will tell you how this difficult exam is conducted and what the judgesre trying to hide. but first to the news. member of the higher qualification commission. of judges of ukraine, volodymyr luhanskyi, who turned out to be a fake doctor of philosophy, unjustifiably received 15% extra pay every month for a non-existent academic degree. experts of the anti -corruption center established that luhansky received at least uah 160,000 for a fake degree from april 2015 to september 2020, when he worked at the severodonetsk city court. during the interviews with members of the competition commission and vrp, volodymyr luhanskyi stated that he had defended his thesis. in interregional academy of personnel management in 2011, however, at that time, this educational institution was not among the subjects of issuing diplomas of doctor of philosophy. moreover, only in september 2014 , the verkhovna rada adopted changes that equated the title of candidate of sciences to the scientific degree of doctor of philosophy. how it happened, luhansky could not explain, nor coul

in the end, the higher qualification commission of judges recommended the dismissal of olena panchenkow the submission must be considered by the supreme council of justice. that's all i have for today there was judicial control and i am tetyana shostrova. if you know the facts. corruption in the judicial system, or you want to talk about an unscrupulous judge, write to me on facebook or to the e-mail address you see on your screens, we will meet in exactly a week, good luck, good evening, we are from ukraine. drone attack on konoto, a lot of destruction and an attack on kharkiv this afternoon , where did the townspeople arrive or get hurt, do not miss this information, the enemy launched a counteroffensive on the kurshchyna, but zelensky says everything according to our plan about the scale of the battles and what chances to hold the territory, let's talk: is it possible to hit the territory of russia with stormshadow missiles? london had to give an unequivocal answer, whether they waited for an affirmative yes and why the us is asking for a detailed map of the targets that they plan t

candidates for the positions of judges first undergo testing, perform a practical task and pass a special check. next, the higher qualification commissionjudges examines the candidates' files. conducts interviews together with international experts, after which the supreme council of justice sends a submission with the winners of the competition to the president, he officially appoints a candidate for the position. you have an iq test, you have arrived, you have not arrived, and if you are already at this stage, if you simply do not understand what is happening, if you cannot pass, sorry, 2+2 at a sufficient level, then about the rest you don't need to be allowed to write a court decision, don't you need to be asked what your property is, if you are already well... not enough, sorry, if you have the abilities at this stage, then you can save time and effort at other stages of the selection . although this selection of judges is qualitatively different from what happened in 2019 year, at the stage of formation of the anti-corruption court, the so-called judicial mafia still does not lose hope of gaining influence and key control. represe

judge was the author of her work at all. the dissertation file's metadata indicates that it was authored by a man named dima. the higher qualification commissionvaluated all the explanations of the judge of the pechersk district court of kyiv, kateryna seredy, and found them unconvincing. so the judge. pending release. today i have everything. you watched judicial control, i am tetyana shostrova. tell us about the facts of corruption in the judicial system that you know. write to the email you see on the screen, or me on facebook see you in exactly one week. in ukraine, at 6:00 p.m., a news release on the espresso tv channel in iryna's studio is for your attention.

of donetsk region olena panchenko. in 2011, when she worked as a judge for only a year, she was... jumped on bribes of $600 for softening the defendant's sentence. the higher qualification commissionn removed the judge from his position. however, she did not fire. the kuibyshiv district court of donetsk convicted panchenko. up to five years of imprisonment with exemption from serving the sentence with probation for 3 years and confiscation of property. panchenko appealed the verdict, but the appeal was not considered due to the seizure of the court building by the russian army. accordingly, the verdict is not entered into force. i was inconvenient for the local authorities, in my opinion. and i applied for an administrative position in this court. immediately is this your inner conviction? yes. i believe that this became the basis for artificially creating such a criminal case. it is also known that in her scientific article , olena panchenko, contrary to the rules, used information from a russian-language source, translating it through google translate. of course, it 's a coincidence, in no case would i use anything russian and would not want to to use, well, but this is a litera

of the parties in a civil case for making a decision in her interests. during the search , $15,600 was seized from the judge, packaged in different envelopes. higher the qualification commission to evaluate the current servants of themis for their suitability for the positions they hold. qualification confirmations are not as fast as we would like. public council of virtue. and experts carry out a titanic job of researching the integrity of judges and identifying dubious fortunes. members of the kvaliv commission need a lot of time to analyze all the information. in turn , the judges themselves try to delay the possible dismissal as much as possible, ignore interviews, suddenly fall ill and invent very original ways to disrupt the process. in the 10 months since the beginning of the qualification evaluation, the commission held a meeting on 170. two judges out of almost 2,000 were dismissed, while 43, who were found to be dishonest by the public integrity council and analysts of the deure foundation, were retained by the supreme court of justice . last week , the judge of the rivne district administrative court, andrii salo, underwent a qualification assessment. i am constant

last year in in november, the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine announced an additionalruitment for 25 vacant positions. the competition is held with the involvement of a public council of international experts. previously, how was the selection of judicial vacancies in general? someone comes who has been agreed upon for a long time. they ask them how you like the weather, how you like nature. they tell me that everything is cool with me, you, er, how things are, and formality, that is, it was and they get the position. now, little by little, we have brought everything to the point where we have formalized, standardized stages of selection, and this selection is quite careful, and it is quite similar to how one chooses for oneself. judges of other countries. candidates for the positions of judges first pass a test, perform a practical task and pass a special check. next, the higher qualification commission of judges examines the candidates' files together with international experts, conducts interviews, after which the supreme council of justice sends a submission with t

the european union, judicial reform is one of the main requirements for continuing our path to the eu. the higher qualification commission assesses current judges their suitability for positions. the servants of themis continue to amaze from wealth, which cannot be explained by income to professional incompetence. today we will tell you about those whom vkks has already weeded out. but first to the news. state bureau of investigation. completed the pre-trial investigation of the case of the judge of the economic court of the dnipropetrovsk region, eduard bondarev, who is suspected of the kidnapping of his business partner. according to the version of the investigation, the judge started farming in 2017, and since he is prohibited from doing so by law, he found a fake person, on whom part of the of business in the sumy region. later, the judge decided to remove the partner from the cases, blackmailing him with a million dollar loan. however, the man did not want to leave the company without pay. then, according to the investigation, the suspect ordered the kidnapping of his partner for $17. the man was to be deprived of his freedom and forced to

higher quorum commission announced a break before making a final decision on the suitability of andrii sal for the position and is waiting for additional information from him documents and explanations. the higher qualification commission of judgesdismissed the judge of the avdiyiv city court of the donetsk region. in 2011, when she had worked as a judge for only a year, elena panchenko was bribed with $600 for reducing the defendant's sentence. the higher qualification commission then removed the judge from his position, but did not dismiss him. the kuibyshiv district court of donetsk sentenced panchenko to five years in prison with a suspended sentence with a three-year probationary period and confiscation of property. panchenko appealed the verdict, but the appeal... was not considered due to the capture of the courthouse by the russian army, so the verdict never entered into force. i was inconvenient to the local government, in my opinion, and i applied to take an administrative position in this court. of course. is this your inner conviction? yes. i believe that this became the basis for creating such an artificial criminal case. it is also known that in his scientific article. olena panchenko, contrary to the rules, used i

2011, when she had worked as a judge for only a year, she jumped in... for bribes of 6,000 dollars for softening the defendant's sentence. the higher qualification commissionn removed the judge from his position. however, she did not fire. the kuibyshiv district court of donetsk sentenced panchenko to five years in prison with a suspended sentence with a three-year probationary period and confiscation of property. panchenko appealed the verdict, but the appeal was not considered due to the seizure of the court building by the russian army. accordingly, the verdict is not typed for i was inconvenient to the local government, in my opinion, and i applied to occupy an administrative position in this court, of course, this is your inner conviction, yes, i believe that this became the basis for creating an artificial criminal case like this . it is also known that in her scientific article, olena panchenko, contrary to the rules, used information from a russian-language source, translating it. via google translate, of course, a coincidence, under no circumstances would i use anything russian and would not want to use, well, but it's a literal translation of thr

the higher qualification commission of judges continues to conduct interviews in within the frameworkevaluation of active servants. femida for compliance with the positions held, this is the judge of the pechersk district court of the city of kyiv, kateryna sereda. i have certain, let's call them healthy, ambitions in terms of my further career growth. kateryna sereda was appointed to the position of a judge in zaporizhzhia in 2012, and already in february 14, she was transferred to the pechersk district court of kyiv under a simplified procedure. at the time of the transfer , she did not consider a single case, which calls into question her professional training, and in the opinion of the public council, it is good. raises suspicions about using connections to obtain preferences. my career was consistent, logical, and i don't see any, you know, doubts in this that i immediately got to know the court team, i was not separated from justice, that is, i explained that i was and as an assistant and constantly studied and, well, that is, put in the maximum effort from myself, which is in p

in the end, the higher qualification commission of judges recommended that elena be fired panchenko. the submission must be considered by the supreme council of justice. for today, i have everything, it was judicial control and i, tetyana shostrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system, or you want to tell about an unscrupulous judge, write to me on facebook. or to the email address you see on your screens. see you in exactly one week. it's all good. we are looking for 12-year-old ivan gudimov and his 16-year-old sister karina. i know that these children lived in the city of severo-donetsk in the luhansk region, and it was there that they met full-scale war. in june 22 , the settlement was occupied by the russians, and already in september it appeared. information about the disappearance of the brother and sister, it is possible that ivan and karina, like many children from uncontrolled territories of ukraine, could be taken to russia, but it is quite likely that the boy and girl are still somewhere in the temporarily occupied territory of our country, so i i rea

the collegium of the higher qualification commission referred the judge's case to the full composition of the supreme court of appeals, which must make a final decision on his suitability for the position. and finally, we will introduce you to the judge of the apostoliv district. court of the dnipropetrovsk region natalia semenova, criminal proceedings were opened against the judge for official forgery of documents, it was later closed, however, there are obviously gaps not only in integrity, but also in knowledge. criminal proceedings were opened regarding me, regarding me, the prosecutor, can the prosecutor open criminal proceedings? the investigator, what is the investigator doing, i didn't understand the question, i'm sorry, the supreme council of justice. brought nataliya semenova to justice for the fact that she constantly returned to the police protocols on administrative violations on illegal grounds, if you stated in response to the question of the public integrity council that the protocol itself was correct, drawn up in accordance with the relevant legislation, then what wer

of the general meetings, leave without consideration. the shareholders believe that judge gorbasenko's actions have signs of raiding and illegal interference in economic activity and have reported this to the higher qualifications commissiontermine whether the judge will continue his career. three months ago, the supreme court of appeals again postponed the final decision on gorbasenko, which allowed him to remain in the judge's chair for the time being and even. to be appointed to a position in the appellate instance. meanwhile, the public council of integrity revealed new facts of gorbasenko's dishonesty and made a new conclusion. actually, there should have been a review and the conclusion of the consideration of his suitability for the position, but the public council of goodness has moved to postpone the meeting, because we voted on a new decision yesterday. the new conclusion of the state criminal court states that the father of judge volodymyr gorbasenko is in the midst of a full-scale war unleashed by russia against ukraine. conducts business in the temporarily occupied crimea. he lives in the territory captured by the russians and is a co-founder of two limited liability companies. sevele adjusts and unvest pays

last week, the higher qualification commission of judges determined the dates and conditions of the qualification exam within the competition for 550 vacancies. positions of appellate judges courts 1837 candidates were allowed to participate in the competition, among them 158 applicants from economic specialization. on october 22 , pavlo gorbasenko, judge and head of the economic court of the kyiv region, will pass the test. it will be recalled that he still has not confirmed his suitability for the position of judge. since last year, the supreme court of appeals has been postponing the meeting in the case of his qualification. and while the commission is deliberating, gorbasenko decided not to waste time. submitted documents for participation in the competition for the position of a judge in the northern commercial court of appeal. so and promotion can be obtained and reset some facts of personal and professional biography. judging by the fact that the date of his testing has already been set, there are no obstacles on this way for the judge, despite the unequivocal negative conclusion of the pu

in the end, the higher qualification commission of judges recommended that elena be fired panchenko. the submission should now be considered. the supreme council of justice. for today, i have everything, it was judicial control and i, tetyana shustrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system, or you want to tell about a dishonest judge, write to me on facebook or to the email address you see on your screens. see you in exactly one week. it's all good. glory to ukraine, dear tv viewers, on the air of the tv channel, the program studio zahid, we will analyze the most important events of this week, in particular, we will carefully analyze the situation with the so-called negotiations, overt and hidden, there are extremely many signals, but we understand that some of them are just smoke signals. curtain, our today's guests are extremely informed daniel fried and oleksandr morozov. now the iconic american diplomat, ex-coordinator of the united states state department on sanctions policy, ambassador daniel frith will be on the air of the tv channel. glory to ukraine, dea

the board of the higher qualification commission. sent the judge's case for consideration by the full composition of the supreme court of appeals, who must make the final decision regarding his suitability for the position. and finally, we will introduce you to natalya semenova, judge of the apostoliv district court of the dnipropetrovsk region. as for the judge, criminal proceedings were opened for official falsification of documents. it was later closed, however, it was evidently about branches not only in virtue, but also in knowledge. criminal proceedings were opened in relation to. the prosecutor can open criminal proceedings, the investigator, what does the investigator do, i didn't understand the question, sorry, superior the council of justice brought natalia semenova to justice for the fact that she constantly returned to the police reports on administrative violations on illegal grounds. if you pointed out to the public integrity council's question that the prosecutor's report was correct in itself, it was made. according to my legislation, what grounds were there to return

actually happens, in the end the higher qualification commission... judges recommended that elena panchenko be fired. the submission should now be considered the supreme council of justice. today i have everything, it was judicial control and i am tetyana shostrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system, or you want to tell about a dishonest judge, write to me on facebook or to the email address you see on your screens. let's meet. exactly in a week. it's all good. two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become like relatives to many, as well as distinguished guests of the studio. events of the day in two hours. vasyl zima's big broadcast. a project for smart and caring people. espresso in the evening. come closer victory together with tssoaa, sbu. join one of the best special forces in the country. we are expanding and hiring. we invite civilian specialists of various fields. experienced commanders will ensure your high-quality training and education. fill out the questionnaire and choose the direction where you can be most effective. we are waiting for you in the csoa-sbu team. together we will write the histor