this project. >> do i need another motion to recuse. >> on that motion to rekinds commissioner wu. >> commissioner hillis commissioner moore commissioner hillis commissioner wu and commissioner president fong e so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously. >> good afternoon liz this is an informational and result in previously approved chinatown known as the head house on stockton street as you recall the conditional use authorization as part of the sfmta expansion into chinatown in september of 2012 as a condition of that approval the sfmta in conjunction with the office of economic workforce development and the planning department engaged in a series of ways to have open space into the site that will environment the head house and serve the neighbors it will present an overview of the final design with that i'm going to turn it over to the central program director john thank you. >> good afternoon. my name is is john i'm also accompanied by jan wang we'll be providing you with a short briefing of the chinatown design. >> the future chinatown station sites located on a price of property it ce

commissioner wu. >> commissioner richards sorry commissioner hillis raise good points i'm in favor of one fabulous but to me one hundred 90 and one hundred 20 is how you're out of town so i would be supportive of idea of some sort of streamline bed-and-breakfast we've not researched it. >> commissioner hillis. >> i mean, i have questions on the breaking points of 247 is way and hasn't the brook point to be lower non-hosted you'll run is it as a rental property i have to dig through the numbers i don't know it didn't seem right to me the 247. >> we checked the numbers about the controller's office and his ranks are coming out in the same order we're talking about the break even point where it becomes sensitized to switch in long-term to short-term rentals and certainty profit level it might not be this is the amount somewhere the incentive is earlier and later a number where the amount of profit it enough for a loraina long term rental and people that there are a lot of vacant unit if people are able to lease for one hundred and 20 days that might be good enough i'd like to see that in the hosted renta

hosting platforms - commissioner antonini nor arrest commissioner hillis no commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and commissioner president fong no that recommendation will move forward where a vote of 4 to 3 with commissioner hillis and commissioner antonini and others against. >> we're making good progress we've been here over 8 hours let's take a 5 minute break. >> thursday, april 23, 2015, commissioner we left off discussing item 16 abc. >> sorry all right. commissioner we're on recommendation number 7 is it or is to add a provision directing the mayor to set up an officer for the tax collects office we think this will provide a better experience for people wanting to think opposed the should recall registry all the offices in one stop and help with enforcement efforts. >> commissioner antonini. >> sounds like a move targeted efficiency a good step. >> commissioner wu. >> i know that to me i think there should be cross departmental help but i want to attaining the department for what they've done they've set up operations and this is in february so i maybe i don't want to prolong there's a s

commissioner wu. >> i agree with commissioner richards thoughts for enforceability is only don't need this type of information. >> commissioner hillis. >> can you remind me what the host have to report so unanimously they need to send a report to the planning department kind of signed under oath the number of days. >> yes. >> again, i that one hundred and 20 days we're trying to achieve this everything is enforceable it is not just liquor the planning code it is not it takes . >> o'connor a room is not available there is a meter to stop after one hundred and 20 days or whatever there is no more room to rent it technology is available not necessarily worked on by the platform itself but the accounting mechanism built online reservations and commissioner richards. >> i think commissioner hillis point resonates around one airbnb for the first one hundred and 20 days other rental worries me we have look at of enforcement we can psychiatries. >> commissioners shall i call the question open recommendation 11 to not require platforms to report quarterly. >> commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore n

public comment is closed. >> commissioner wu move to approve item 3 and 5. >> on that motion commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and item 4 will be considered as a first item under your regular calendar. >> commissioners, that places you under your regular matter. >> commissioner antonini marry most importantly beat la beat la beat new zealand's too on another matter in receipt of a matter to the bay area council i've sent to the commissioners about the high rising costs of hours date 3 slash 17 2015 that makes good points you know building less housing than expanded is a big factor in driving up costs it not something that the dot com and california is neglectful in building houses it hurts the economy and makes housing more difficult and talented people leave the state another recommendations they're in favor of the things to building affordable housing but we have target individuals specifically rather than you know helping saufts them to find housing particul

in instituted a civil action. >> commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner moore no commissioner richards no commissioner wu no commissioner president fong so moved that will move forward with 4 to 3 moore rishgd and

commissioner wu >> move to approve draft minutes. >> second. >> on that motion to adapt the minutes commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 9 commissioner questions or comments. >> commissioner moore. >> i'd like to report open the 3rd of subcommittee meeting of this commission we are in the process of prior sigg's items for presentation or for final agreement on the last meeting april 23rd and will be coming back to the mission shortly is thereafter other thing i'd like to ask we put up another action item meeting and this is called enforcement i'd like to have a discussion on permits, coincidence, complaint based enforcement the 3 enacting with each other and the illegal projects that are popping up current or past and where we stand with defining workable items of enforcement that would be an action item for timing. >> commissioner antonini. >> thank you a couple weeks ago i mentioned i want to talk about some of the things they've done in the town

. >> commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes that recommendations will go forward unanimously unanimously. >> so recommendation go number 4 is to allow private right of action for nonprofits as outlined in the kim ordinance that will allow a nonprofit it is chart to protect housing in san francisco to sorry to initiate private right of action against unit with a ellis act violation or 3 or more registering or rent control united if there's a violation thirty days but basically after a period of 90 days they can initiate the private right of action. >> commissioner antonini. >> well, i'm not supportive of this i think it is encourages litigation and the city should be the litigationer why do we give nonprofits a special privilege above and beyond anyone else i mean you know we should stick with a firm controls of the city has and we should be the endorseer some groups get different motivates and you're not sure you've got all those lawsuits going on that

. >> no commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes that item will be recommended 6 to one with commissioner antonini voting against. >> commissioner johnson. >> thank you for your recommendations. >> scott recommendation number 3 to allow the city to have civil procedures against the platform as defined at any time in the kim and supervisor campos ordinance. >> commissioner johnson tucson i forgot to press the bottom this is one where commissioner hillis my vote depended on the explanation of a later recommendation to mr. star explain the current enforcement the erupted enforcement practice given that a later recommendation voiced a clank to the administration hearing and how those are invoked and used at what point is the city snuft. >> to clarify the latter recommendation right now it requires a hamburger and the change is to make that hearing something they can request but otherwise that is a minor technical change not changing the process but maybe the adoptin

. >> no commissioner hillis san francisco commissioner johnson by commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and commissioner fong so that recommendation theoretically will get added to the represents to the board of supervisors by a vote of 5 to 2 with commissioner antonini and commissioner hillis voting against recommendation two is to rehabilitate unit that have been subject to an ellis act from registering on the short-term rental registry the department buildings this will add another disincentive it allows someone to do a short-term rental after the period of 5 years it didn't cut them out of the market. >> commissioner johnson i'm supportive of this supervisor kim and supervisor breed decided to eliminate this amendment. >> mined was that supervisor breed want to take out her private right of action provision for units that have been subject to the ellis act violation. >> if i can jump in if those are were added by the board of supervisors to the full board you can't take it out she can't take it out herself it has to be forming because it goes back to the full board the full board ha

. >> no commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes with a vote of 6 to one. >> number 5. >> 5. >> don't take away progress. >> (laughter) the next department recommendation to add permanent owner residing within one hundred hundred photo to the interested in the supervisor campos and mayoral ordinance that depends on how you take the private right of action if you don't expand the private right of action to any interested party someone living within one hundred photo of the unit to take action after the city finds a violation so bringing those that are directly effected to the short-term rental the impact on their neighborhoods into the definition of an interested party. >> the clarify the difference between this one and the last one. >> we're amending the definition for what on interested party is and expand the private right of action to the interested parties then everyone within one hundred feet. >> there's mud. >> deputy city attorney again if i could offer a

. >> commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes commissioner richards you are hereby recused. >> good afternoon, commissioners andy deceased power with supervisor wiener thank you for this opportunity this legislation i'll speak briefly included projects along the octavia boulevard the castro street and 18 nc d and noah valley nc d and the owners is geared towards our retail corridors remain actively 86 it tweaks the information for the corridor on market street from octavia boulevard west it makes legislation interim controls that were put in place last year to insure that new ground floor retails that's been put in along market street doesn't turnover to you know don't you'll turn offer 0 real estate and insurance brokers that's the trend the controls along market street we envision require a cu for the ground floor but we're not requiring a cu if they were to go into ground floor or second-story and the goal to sensitive vices the floors other than the groun

understand or the than commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wuommissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero zoning administrator what say you >> on the variance closed the public hearing and grant the exemption. >> thank you. >>break. >> commissioner >> commissioner regular meeting for april 2, 2015, remind the members of the audience that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind. please silence any devices that may sound off during the proceedings. and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. commissioner we least off in our regular calendar for case no. at 5 61 through 73 valencia street a conditional use authorization. >> good afternoon planning department staff have you a conditional use authorization to legalize the expansion avenue restaurant.org to approximately converting an reinforcing space at 563 valencia to a restaurant use specifically the expansion requires a conditional use authorization both to exposed a floor area of 3 th

. >> commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner wu and commissioner chair wu. >> so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 5 to zero. >> commissioners i'll say we're trying to keep a 3:00 p.m. for the short-term rental discussion we have two items remaining items 12 and 13 and collectively about 18 speaker cards pointing out as advise to the commissioners commissioners telephone ab for the cases at 4022 on fourth street conditional use authorization and variance please note on march 26 commissioners you held a public hearing and closed public comment you continued this matter to today by a vote of 6 to zero commissioner antonini you left earlier have viewed the video if you could acknowledge. >> i viewed the entire hearing i think i'm have famous with the remaining issues and hopefully can add to the process. >> thank you. appreciate that. >> and you had a recommendation on timeing of presentation is that right. >> oh thank you because this has been heard the practice to reduce the sponsor and i believe some organized opposition to

i'd like to take roll at this time commissioner president fong commissioner wu commissioner antonini commissioner hillismissioner moore and commissioner johnson and commissioner richards are present commissioners first on your agenda is consideration for items proposed for continuance item number one conditional use authorization is property until that april that 23rd 2015 and the next item the castro street

that staff recommended commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. >> commissioners, that places you under your 13 abc for case numbers at 150 van ness after a downtown conditional use authorization and zoning administrator will consider request for variance. >> commissioners before, before we start i want to introduce you to a new planner gonzales with with 15 years of experience a planner and lead professional with speciality in neighborhoods led and his masters with the city planning from the university of arizona joined the 2k789 in june of last year and his passions include karaoke and a die-hard of mildred soccer in spain. >> 82 welcome, welcome. >> good afternoon commissioner president fong and commissioners i'm gonzales the request before you is two actions regarding the project on 150 van ness avenue and the prioritization and the conditional use authorizations the project will demolish one office building at the southeast corner of hates and the p

. >> no commissioner hillis san francisco commissioner johnson by commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and commissioner fong so that recommendation theoretically will get added to the represents to the board of supervisors by a vote of 5 to 2 with commissioner antonini and commissioner hillis voting against recommendation two is to rehabilitate unit that have been subject to an ellis act from registering on the short-term rental registry the department buildings this will add another