i agree. >> president hirsch: okay. captain? >> under the a.d.a., we would be under obligation to provide that. if there's sustained allegations that go to dishonesty, you certainly get those records. and then, with such a large issue on 1421, we talked about it last time we were here -- we talked about it last week, as a matter of fact, and we're setting it on the agenda in june so the d.p.a. can respond and search its records and sfpd. >> president hirsch: this is public comment. it's not supposed to be back and forth. i don't want to set that precedent because we won't survive it. commissioner elias. >> i am concerned as to why only two reports have been released and those have been with respect to retired officers, and i am going to ask that the police department show what -- how it is prioritizing these requests as they come in since we are asking d.p.a. to provide that information, i think it's also fair that the police department provide us that information, as well. >> commissioners, i think the discussion here has gone

. >> good evening, president hirsch, vice president tailor, commissioners and director hawkins or actingirector hawkins. this week's chiefs report will start with the crime trends for this week starting with over all part one crimes. we were down 14%. our total violent crimes are down 17%. specifically as it relates to homicides, we're at 12 for the year, actually, as i was walking in the door we just got our 13th compared to 14 this time last year. so we're still down. i don't have all the details of the one that just happened a few minutes ago. there was one homicide last week. one suspicious death two weeks ago that was also ruled a homicide. i'll go into more detail on friday's homicide in the city. looking at gun violence, which is the number people injured in a shooting incident, we're down 25% over 2018. total property crime we're down 14%. and this includes burglary, motor vehicle theft, larceny and arsons. we continue to have fewer reported incidents in all categories compared to this type last year. we are -- except for motor vehicles we're 2% higher this year to date this time

president hirsch, commissioners, acting director, chief scott, safe streets for all. nothing has changed as far as our effort and enforcement. we continue to focus on vision 0 high injury corridors, increase enforcement, educate the drivers, distracted driving operations, light r which is speed enforcement operations, pedestrian and bicycle safety enforcement, special events, sunday streets, community outreach events, and collaborate with city agencies and advocates. now, the comparison between 2018, the first quarter, and 2019, you'll see these are the focus on the five. the red light, stop sign, pedestrian right-of-way, speeding, failure to yield with turning. we really try to focus on the turning aspect of enforcement due to the fact that many of our fatalities have to do with vehicles turning and hitting pedestrians. so now the citywide versus focus on the five violations, 2019 first quarter. you'll see that the different district stations and then traffic company. the very next slide which i'll turn to in one second in comparison to 2018, traffic company is now u

let's take a look at doug hirsch co-founder learn what it means. mr. hirsch, welcome to "mad money. a user of your are product, i'm going to jump in. i didn't think it was possible i sound like a commercial. i did not think it was possible to cut a prescription cost by 4/5 but you did it. tell me how you got to this point and how you can possibly get these breaks. >> it's amazing. most americans don't realize they can shop around for health care reality is that health care is like any other industry. >> how did you find out? >> i didn't know i got sticker shock, took my prescription back and i found out there were amazing waste to save. >> there was a "new york times" article. i clicked on the link and it's a coupon system. explain why anyone has to take these coupons and how you really do beat, you beat the system >> yes so first of all insurance is not what it used to be i can remember the days of the $10 co-pay and you didn't have to worry about it. insurance is covering less and less it turns out what we call coupons are really relationships between insurance companies, we call

of allegiance. [ pledge of allegiance ] >> good evening, commissioner hirsch. i would like to take roll. >> thank you. [ roll ] >> also present is department director eric balances sar and the chief of police. you do have a quorum. >> thank you. good evening, everybody. welcome to the meeting of may 15th, 2019. we have a moderate agenda tonight. so public comment will be limited to three minutes per person. we're ready for the first calendar item. >> line number one, consent calendar, receive and file action. that's the pd dpa document first quarter 2019. request of chief of police to accept 16,6666 from the casa de las madres to go towards the domestic violence high risk program. this requires a motion. >> so moved. >> second. >> all in favor. >> we need public comment before we vote, please. is there any public comment on this one item? seeing none, comment is close the. we'vwe're ready for the vote. all in favor. >> aye. >> all opposed? it passes. >> line 2, reports of the commission discussion, a, chief's report, provide an overview of offenses in san franc

. >> i think president hirsch and commission commissioner elias, on calendar, we are not going to voteht on the ultimate policy, so i think the department will have a chance at a later date, whether it's next session to present and then we can vote at that point. but i don't see any harm, and i think it's -- i think it's disrespectful for the people who have shown up to put something on calendar, they cleared this time out of their schedule and say oh, come back another time because we just realized we wanted to have other people present as well. so, i think the proper thing to do here is to allow the people that are here to speak and address tonight. thank you. >> commissioner mazzucco. >> i learned about it for the first time, it's not properly calendared, it does not say presentation. it's discussion between the commissioners regarding version a and version b, nowhere in here does it say any presentation from anybody regarding version a or version b outside of the police commission. so, it's one, it's not properly calendared, it's not fair to the commissioners involved in this, it's

so this is -- this is the one that president hirsch referenced section 4 dpa procedure, subsection a. dpa investigations. so the dpa sends their completed investigations to ied. you should not receive the iad investigative conclusions until you've received -- until they've received your report. is that accurate? >> correct. >> i guess it was director henderson who was here last time, his feeling was, as you just expressed it -- and i don't recall what the -- does somebody have any sense of what the opposition to that is? >> yeah. i can tell you what it is. >> okay. >> the reason that the department was getting or is getting the dpa's completed investigation is ultimately it goes to the chief who makes the final decision as to how the department and how he will charge an individual officer in discipline. the reason it doesn't flow the other way is that dpa is really an independent entity. they're an independent civilian review board providing oversight and i think the public is best served, the position that was taken was that the public is best served if the dpa comes to their own con

. >> good evening, commissioners, president hirsch, members of the commission, chief-of-staff. i am here this evening to present to you both an update on c.r.i. in general and i think hillard heintze will do a presentation focusing on process and how we're working together and things like that. i do want to take a moment and introduce the executive sponsors who really do the hard work of coordinating many, many, many members of the department in implementing these really rigorous compliance measures. the executive sponsors are commander walsh, who oversees the use of force objective. commander lazar, who is coordinating the community police be recognize tiv objectid commander yee, and commander -- who do i have left -- o'sullivan who has the highering and hiriny objective. with that, thank you for having me. the overview tonight encompasses making these changes. i'll talk more details about the summarizing each of the specific areas within the categories outlined bit u.s. d.o.j. assessment. also the program-wide efforts we've been making as well. throughout the process, sfpd an

the media this morning regarding the adachi matter was on behalf of police commissioner president hirsch and vice president taylor. at this time it would be inappropriate for the commission to opine further without seeing the results of a full and fair investigation. yesterday the police chief called for resignation into who leaked the police report about the death of former public defender jeff adachi on journalist bryan carmody. mayor breed declined to comment. but on friday she released a statement which says in part, i'm glad that the chief has acknowledged the department's mistakes and apologize but i remain deeply disappointed by the actions taken in this case up to today. this is unacceptable and we have to do better. the police commissioners are appointed by the mayor and the board of supervisors. they oversee the police department. and today, statements from the commission are the latest in this controversy over the sfpd raid of bryan carmody, a journalist, which has set off a national debate about freedom of the press. back to you. >>> memorial day is usually the start of summe

i'm ken hirsch, introducer in chief. our goal here is to provide content you can't get anywhere else. we are honored today with this session to launch a wonderful insiders look at presidential retreats and a glimpse of what life looks like for a president outside of the white house. it's a fascination that some people have. we are delighted to take a deep dive into camp david, crawford, kennebunkport and the lbj ranch. tonight, we have a series of guests who can give us that special insight. to kick us off, i would like to introduce the 43rd president of the united states. [applause] mr. bush: this is a special moment for laura and me, because we have such fond memories of the presidential retreat. one of the things about a presidency that is hard to explain is, what it feels like to be in a bubble. you are kind of in a bubble, particularly in washington. the presidential retreats, for any president, are very important in the life of the presidency. i want to thank ken and holly and the team here for opening up the presi

i also want to agree with president hirsch. we talked about this at the commission and we all agreed there should be communication between d.p.a. and the city attorney's office, if only because there's information that they may have that you may not be aware of. and vice versa. because you're not aware of some critical pieces of information. so we all agree that you should be working collaboratively together, even though you are making individual decisions about what to disclose. and then the last thing is, everyone keeps saying next week, but i don't believe that the commissioner will be here next week's, so whatever this should be, we should decide what it is to make sure the community knows that everyone knows and they're expected to come back and talk about these issues. i don't thank you be next week, but whatever the date is -- >> we will make sure it is noticed with plenty of time. >> i'm really confused. you talk and talk, and i've no clue what you're talking about. let me back up for a moment. i just read 1421 as a pro

i'm ken hirsch, introducer in chief.ur goal here is to provide content you can't get anywhere else. we are honor

. >> director hirsch, that is only temporary until the train gets here and then that number will change. [laughter]. >> that is true. >> anyway, i want to thank the board, i want to thank the panel for jumping in, and i appreciate the scepticism. i think this is a very valuable approach to looking at what we are doing, and one thing that i think might be helpful is to keep the panel together a little bit to see what the sfcta comes up with. they might be a time where the peer-reviewed panels compare notes, and then sift the comments up higher for us to consider at the tjpa. i could probably spend the next hour asking questions, but i will stick to the high-level. thank you for jumping in and your expertise. on the project delivery comment or section, thank you. when i ask about project delivery and i have done all of them plus others, i always interview the organization first about capacity, culture, capabilities, a whole number of different things before i even answer the question of what is the best delivery, because it is tied to a catch 22. you have to have the right people for the

hirsch why mounted on talk of realize it should also and a lot of lawyers really of as. a whole they'll. also line. here. with the office to model reality. in the election mccain. lecithin what are the flip positivity if you would feel if somebody. could be danish her thought of a highly m. and i was with her and macand with our feet. a year. or so we have had the map would have been the s.s. and we commend and the s.s. mystery then we have a question how you met him i can hardly hear. you and i. looked and i've been out of the bus benignly. from. going left alone sort of the way your hair you managed to might always let the furrow lemanis in the top a year. or 2 for. luck they're far and a lot of months for cheever even if she is a hawk it's scorching babo love under she should look into but the bluff is all a shitty years. imho because they knew what a lovely. passage persico are and your dad did not work because she was stuck here on the bus and she seemed so numb as in a loco i was in awe is there a lot below you or didn't belong to. militia in general in 70. ad for

they call themselves sober curious. 33-year-old josh hirsch, a former wine buyer, is one of them.he difference between sober curious and sobriety is what? >> the big difference is that people who are in recovery need to be in recovery. sober curious is you've noticed in your own life how drinking has impacted you and you've come to a point where i need to think about this. >> pervasive part of modern life, josh began questioning the troubling side effects that come with being part of a drinking culture. it seems to be a neverending bender. >> last october i decided, i was like let me do november and december just no alcohol. and if i can do it during the holidays then i can do it anytime. so i did it as an experiment and i just was like oh, wow. it made such a difference. >> reporter: he heard about the sober curious movement through lifestyle journalist ruby warrington, who wrote a book by the same name after going through a similar journey. >> i came to drinking age with very much "sex and the city" as my backdrop. it was seen as part of being a fabulous modern emancipated woman

hirsch why mounted on talk of realize it should also and the law that allows the reality of a. dog and also a line. here . was so obvious to me the reality. in the election became. what are the flow positive if you would feel if somebody. could be danish he's heard what the but he had and that was a time. and macand mcafee. said he so we had the map would have been in the s.s. and we commend it and the s.s. mystery plan we had for question how you met him i can hardly hear. you and i. looked out of the glass benignly. for. mr where you left hello t. alone or sort of the way your hair do you ma'am which termite always let the 1st holy man nurse in the top a year. or 2 for. their father and a lot of mothers for cheever is a hawk it's scorching babo love. should look all into but the blood has all shittiest tortuga and hawkers there and you regularly. pass it are sick or are and your dad did not work because she was stuck here on the bus and she seemed so numb as on a local i was in awe is there a lot below you or didn't belong to. militia general in 70. ad for questioning about t

i would say that president hirsch have been part of this these collaborative discussions and calls. lot of things are hardening to me. one of those things, we all felt strongly that d.p.a. should be part of the conversation. it's really helpful. cal d.o.j. is anything but rubber stamp. there are no rubber stamps on the policy. it really is a process of kind of rigorous discussion and testing of ideas. there's lot of work to do. from what we have seen, we have a lot of people from various kind of points of view having discussions about these policies. >> one last thing. can you tell us in couple of sentences, the report that's coming out in couple of weeks, what do you expect us to see from that? >> i think what you're going to see is that the city and this department and the cal d.o.j. have really established a foundation that i think provides structure for reform for the department going forward. just as the vice president identified, coming into this, we weren't quite sure how all the new stakeholders were going to work out in this. what i can say, it's been your work. that is the

the media this morning regarding the adachi matter was on behalf of police commissioner president hirschident taylor. at this time it would be inappropriate for the commission to opine further without seeing the results of a

hirsch why mounted on talk of real as a sort of also. a new law that allows the reality of a. whole. notion of i'm. here. was too obvious to meet our reality. in the election mccain. lecithin but on the flip i should tell it if you were full of something. he could be danish he's heard whatever he highly am and that was a time and macand mcduffie. a year. or so we have had the map would have been the s.s. if we command and the s.s. mystery then we have a question how you met them i can have 3 of. you and i. looked and i've been out of the class benignly. for the. left alone sort of the way. to my top way let the 1st holy man miss in the top a year. or 2 for. they are far and a lot of months for cheever even if she is a hawk it's scorching babo lump under she should look into but the bluff was all a shitty years. imho because they knew what a lovely. passage persico are and your dad didn't know why because she was stuck here on the bus and she seemed so numb as in a local i was in awe is there a lot below you or didn't belong to. militia general in 70. ad for questioning about t

hirsch why mounted on talk of real as a sort of also. a new law that allows the reality of a.whole they'll. also line. here. with the obvious to me the reality. in the election mccain. let me borrow the flip i should read it if you would feel if something. he could be danish he's heard whatever he had am and that was with her and macand mcduffie. a year. or so we have had the map would have been the s.s. and we commend and the s.s. mystery then we have to question how you met them i can have. you and i. looked and i've been out of the us benignly. mr going. to wear your hair do you ma'am wish to might always let the furrow lemanis in the top a year. or 2 for. yes they're far and a lot of months for cheever even if she is a hawk it's scorching babo lump under she should look into but the bluff was all a shittiest tortuga imho because they knew what a lovely. passage persico are and your dad did not work as she is stuck here and the budget machines are now mass and i loco i was a loss there a lot below or didn't belong to. militia general in 70. ad for questioning about the happ