hogarth is an extraordinary storyteller. he's too wordy either directly or simply all of the following the story line of all those modern morality towns but he made the point which was wonderfully taken and it may have been made before, i don't know where. that the actual formal design of hogarthian prince in particular, graphic art to some extent in some of the paintings with its we would now say pretentiously in intellectual circles, a kind of formation that eats itself, collapsing, things collapse constantly in hogarth. men fall off their sedan chair. a drunken mother loses her baby down a cellar horrifying. things are constantly falling apart and it was said well, if you look at design, it actually disobeys all the instructions of classical art education. it is above all serpentine and it was to design itself in its great wheeling bounding somersaulting motions inside the work of art to contain a story line to contain a kind of twist and turn, a moment of the unexpected. and whether or not hogarth's closeness to which he

you know, collapsing, things collapse, constantly in hogarth. men, high born men fall off of the chair, drunken mother losing her baby down a cellar. things sort of constantly falling apart. he said if you look at the design, it actually disobeys all of the instructions of classical art education. it is above all certain tine line. it was simply to design itself to contain the story line and twist in the moment of what is accepted. whether hogarth was responsible or what everyone doesn't know. the irresistible which english art had makes england and by extension britain, but it was english thing overall. but it's certainly an english thing. that the purest of abstract expressionism out of the nature of storytelling is extremely almost biologically alien to english painting, i think. think about that aggressively modern painters. like francis bacon, for example, they are the same. the serpentine lines forms and dissolves and reforms themselves. that seems not a point made. so it was. excuse me with the digression, schama digressed, heaven forbid.

hogarth, and mr. mcdonnell. i think that they would be very fair. we do not have any lgbt task force members as well. and think it is important that that community is represented in this task force as well. the individuals i would consider in terms of supporting -- not because we do not have many other great applicants that would serve our task force well -- but given who has been appointed thus far and fun to come up with a balance. there are a number of folks here i would love to work with in the future to my office to get acquainted and through a variety of other commissions. i know this is decommissioned that you all wanted to apply for, for many of you, the only commission you apply for. i know that folks have talked about ms. morales, and i know she has been active are around mental health and residency issues. i would love to work with her in district 6. supervisor farrell: we need to get three names out of here. let me bring a little experience to this. i was not on the committee 10 years ago, but i served a member of the board to was on the

next, we have paul hogarth. >> the morning cause supervisors. i have lived in san francisco since 2004, having lived in districts 5 and 6. i have actually worked in san francisco for 11 years and i have been politically involved for the last 15 years. i was a political science major at uc-berkeley. i actually enjoyed studying maps and political demographics and a always had a passion for how folks get represented in these communities and the importance of redistricting and having fair minded folks who can take into account community feedback. my interest specifically in this position, why this redistricting commission and why this year, is that in my time in san francisco, i've worked almost exclusively at the tenderloin housing clinic, working as a community organizer color and managing editor of the on-line web site. district 6 more than any other district will be changed more by this map. district 6 has to lose over 20,000 people. you need someone at the table of this commission is intimately familiar with that community and who can make sure

hogarth, but when community interest, the works for both parties. it works for both sides. then we get different kinds of supervisors, and while it is kind of dis-uniting, we actually let the board of supervisors decide things at the board of supervisors and work and out there. supervisor kim: thank you. any other public comment? >> good morning, supervisors. i am a resident of district 11. i applaud everybody for being up here because it takes a lot of guts to get up here in front of you all, in front of supervisors, and just put it out there and at times get grilled. i am speaking on behalf of -- i am really supportive of maria and lupe. this task force is the right place where we could have new blood, new insight, a new generation of community activists that really want to contribute to our city. me, myself, personally, i can understand and feel a lot of their inspiration and vision and their roles on this task force coming from immigrant families. families that are not politically engaged because the countries that our families come from, you get disappeared. we get kil

for example, paul hogarth sits on the business district board, among other things. i can't believe that given the amount of surgery that's going to have to be done on district 6 that you're not putting someone from that district on that commission. if you sell this neighborhood down the river, what do you think you're going to get? supervisor campos: is there any other member of the public who would like to speak? >> good afternoon, thomas piccarello, last monday i was elected to the board of directors but today i speak as a resident of the c.b.d., and not reflect the views of the c.b.d. first let me say i appreciate the oversight. i think the c.b.d. does a lot of good things for the tenderloin, no question about it. but there needs to be greater transparency and there needs to be greater accountability. at the present time, the c.b.d. spends approximately 80% of their budget to one vendor who cleans the streets. this is on a noncompetitive basis. if -- i was given a packet of documents after my election. i was speaking about the noncompetitive contract. again, orga