i'm harold holzer and i have the privilege of serving as chairman of the lincoln forum and i want to welcome you to what we think will be a rich and stimulating discussion of the subject that is ever evolving, and sometimes fast-moving. controversial, emotional, and something we need to talk about. and from time to time when i've done this panel with friends and colleagues, i've called it on or off their pedestals. the debate over statues, , memory and meaning. and i discussed this topic maybe twice or three times with edna medford and it is evolving even between us as we proceed over a year and a half. and it's a pleasure to welcome not only edna medford, but also liz varon and gary gallagher to join the discussion. of 1728 confederate memorials in 22 states and the district of columbia, 110 have been removed in the past few years. and three new ones have been built. so it's good to have the opportunity to take a snapshot. at best, it will be a snapshot. and i think that we all have to agree that however we feel about art, iconography, memorials, icons, history, american heroes and