in a small flat in west byfleet from 2017 until april 2023, and then in a three bedroom house in horsell, woking. both homes were too small for a family of this size, especially given the twins challenging behaviour. you, earth and sharif worked long hours as a taxi driver. you spent your time at home looking after the children. the only credible evidence of events from 2019 until the period immediately before saras death comes from three sources. first, there are recovered whatsapp messages that were sent by ben batool to her sisters. second, there is evidence from the family's neighbours and from teachers, staff and parents at saras primary school. third, there is the evidence that you, irfan sharif, gave after he had abandoned the lie that you had never assaulted sara. your evidence must, however, be regarded with a great degree of scepticism because even after you had made admissions, you continued to conceal the true extent of your cruelty towards sara, and you were not truthful about the involvement and knowledge of the others. irfan shanf knowledge of the others. irfan sharif, it