commerce clause for the occupancy tax it is unlawful to say that an out of state company or resident hydrahas to pay occupancy tax in san francisco basically that was dismissed and i didn't think about that a week i was watching alumni beggar west and someone on the program basically agreed he didn't disagree when the host of the program said this rule basically says it is not a platform that is completely not the cased so i thought i would bring it to everything everyone's attention adapted by the board of supervisors to a allow for enforcement and provide a better snapshot of where listing are in san francisco so i thought i would highlight that no action necessarily this is a court decision and legislation stands as well so we'll see how things play out in the future i thought that was an interesting take the homeowners of bloomberg would take away that decision. >> commissioner richards. >> i have 4 things here excuse me. i'm fighting a cold last week in the examiner talking about stopping things i read he talks tongue in check brings up palo alto providing office space and san francisco