hyek, once again, economists knew that we need a basic safety net. anybody that says gets rit of all government programs is crazy. they are not paying attention to what we need. it goes beyond help for the vulnerable. i want to help the vulnerable, too, but i don't want middle welfare. i don't want forced sharing. morality comes when people voluntarily above basic poverty, when people help each other voluntarily. voluntary charity doesn't happen when government redistributes too much income. we know that from the europe and soviets. a lost it has to do with the fact we believe that individuals need to make these choices. we have to get away from this idea if you believe in limited government. if you believe the moral thing is rewarding merit and entrepreneurship and unfair to force people to pay that the state needs to function that somehow you hate the poor. no, i want to help the poor with a minimum basic standing of living and where everyone can rise. your ancestors came from that, not for forced income distribution. >> john: thank you mr. brooks.