i think so. joe biden is a phenomenal— voters? . joe biden i is a phenomenal person i think people who get to know him like him, that's been his thing, he's really good at going out and talking to people and meeting people where they aren't talking about two genesee and i'm sure zero —— serious topics will follow, but presenting himself as an understanding person will be important and tiktok is the platform to do. fist important and tiktok is the platform to do.— important and tiktok is the platform to do. at the same time joe _ platform to do. at the same time joe biden _ platform to do. at the same time joe biden is _ platform to do. at the same time joe biden is 81 - platform to do. at the same time joe biden is 81 years i platform to do. at the same l time joe biden is 81 years old, timejoe biden is 81 years old, far outside of the typical demographic for tiktok. far outside of the typical demographic fortiktok. do far outside of the typical demographic for tiktok. do you think young people can see through that hey, hey, young k

just as joe biden should have returned the documents, he's telling his ghost writer, hey, i found the classified stuff downstairs. so, too, would trump have had to do it. and it's definitely something where joe biden had the opportunity to see what trump did. >> yeah. >> when he got that subpoena then a few months later, he's in his own situation. so i wouldn't be surprised if his lawyers said to him, hey, you just saw what trump did. let's treat this case in a way that makes a clear distinction. >> listening to your lawyers is a good characteristic, right? and one that i think mr. trump could do more of. about the case today, donald trump seemed to have a rather good day in court. >> a lot of speculation that the court's going to rule in favor for trump in the ballot ban case and tha thet they were all, a b majority of them, not just the six right leaning justices appointed by republicans, but also maybe kagan, maybe sotomayor and jackson were looking for an offering. do you agree with that? >> i do. when i was listening to the arguments, there was a point where justice kagan said wh

the joe biden i have seen is not the joe biden i knew 30 years ago, but it is a joe biden i trust tomy president today and in a year and two years and three years. >> jamal, you worked at the white house. you had the pleasure of being in the communications staff in a moment like this. they decided to put him out just hours after this went down. they decided to let him take questions. he makes that major gaffe that anna was talking about. was this a strategic mistake? >> no. they absolutely made the right call putting him out today, because the president of the united states is the last word on what happened throughout the day. he was able to forcefully push back on some of the questions in that report. he was able to then talk about his son in a very emotional way. he got a little angry. i think that energy plays well. now, i think the sisi comment. mike johnson was talking to kristen welker on ""meet the press"" on sunday and confused iran for israel. i just don't know if that's a fair critique of the president even though obviously this question is about whether or not he's got the

biden. is that joe or hunter? guest: i do not think you can write about joe without talking about hunter. the book starts in 2015. this is just a year of incredible trauma for joe biden and for the whole biden family that started reverberating in everything going on. the reason i say 2015 is because that is the year when bill biden dies, the heir apparent to joe biden. you hear joe biden still talk about how beau biden should be in this chair. that was also the year who hunter -- were hunter, who had problems before comes up breyer be -- sobriety problems, but when beau biden dies, that is one hunter loss control, his marriage fell apart, and he eventually began a relationship with his brother's widow. and the whole family was really struck in this tragedy. joe biden also wanted to run for president, if you remember, and was sort of dissuaded to do so by barack obama. which a lot of people in biden's inner circle considered a betrayal. i think a lot of what happened that year continues to reverberate throughout the presidency. host: do you think joe biden regrets not running in 2016? guest

i said to joe biden the other day, you said you were going to do this. you justify what you said? there is no justification. i said it and i will do it. if you do not do it, then you will never solve the border crisis. if there is a consequence for entering the country illegally, it is a crime and you have due process in front of a judge, if he orders you removed, you will be removed. julio: we spent a lot of time at the border and seeing it firsthand. how can we do a better job of conveying to people because there is a of numbness to it. for the media doing the work to show what is going on at the border, what is there for us to do to kind of get further reach with how big this problem is? sara: that is a great question. i will come right off of what he was saying. there is a humane way to handle the border. those illegal aliens heading this way and for our nation, the best way is to enforce the law. when i am covering the border i think people do become numb to it. we see the hundreds, thousands pouring across. we see people coming from all over the wor

bush or some of the other presidents that we've had and done good things for america, i think joe bidenld not be saying anything about him. i think joe biden wanted to turn the page, wanted to find ways to bring unity to america. but frankly, donald trump, i think, has made it impossible. he has spent the last three years talking about how joe biden stole the election, how he's an illegitimate president, and continuing to build hostility and pit americans against each other. so, i think this is joe biden accepting the reality that this is the guy that i have to run against. and this is how i feel about it. i'm going to tell america. >> i mean, it's such an important point. the breaking of the norms was not joe biden breaking norms. it was donald trump breaking norms by not accepting election. today in bizarre things or this week in bizarre things, there's the whole jon voight of it all. donald trump, out of nowhere, retweets this old jon voight video about him. just watch it. >> believe that the man that can help this nation, the one man that was ridiculed, destroyed, as jesus, trump, a

in 1993, and then i came forward in 20192020. now joe biden sealed the file in the university of delaware, and he's been unwilling to let it go. the f, b i n g o j. since joe biden went into office, started to target me and went after me. and so this lawsuit actually addresses the weapon ization and put us how the f, b i n d o, j has been politicized. so when you think about the american f, b i, d o j, d o j department of justice is sort of the overseeing umbrella, right? and the f b, i, agents are the ones that enact and on the ground and do the surveillance. so this lawsuit lays out how my constitutional rights of privacy were violated. 4th amendment rights were violated and you know, hopefully this will set a precedent to have my files opened. and um, you know, and then expunged in any case is against me dropped because i have not committed a crime. i simply have told the truth. and when you say the f b i target they do what they do. um, well, a lot of different things came to light and are still coming to light. they surveillance to me, an

bush, or some of the other presidents that we had and done good things were america, i think joe biden would not be seeing anything about it. i think joe biden wanted to return the, page he wanted to find ways to bring unity to america. frankly, donald trump has made it impossible. he has met the last three years talking about joe biden's or the elections, how is a legitimate president, and continuing to build hostility in americans against each other. so i think this is joe biden accepting the reality that this is the guy i have to run against. this is how i feel about. it i will tell -- >> decision important point, at a breaking of the norms was not joe biden breaking -- breaking norms by not accepting election. in today, in missouri, things are this week and bizarre, things there is the whole -- donald trump out of nowhere retweets this auld xian void video about him. just watch it. >> we leave that a man who can help this nation, one man that was ridiculed, trump, and said the american dream for our, i think america great of the dignity and power of who she, is he land of freedom,

anything about delaware that would make it implausible that their unity ticket would be better than joe biden? i can think of a reason -- it is joe biden's own state. they will not vote for the no labels candidate. they have been selling snake oil. the people they have been trotting around, larry hogan, joe manchin, the billionaires that have kicked in all this money, those guys are both out -- real out. now they are going down the list. i think for meltdown looks like them going to rfk jr. and saying, what do you think? we have access and you have whatever it is you are doing. the billionaires that funded this thing will not like that. they will not like some b tier, second-tier candidate. i think they can still cause trouble but in terms of them doing anything that looks like a serious effort -- they went from, no, we will have all of these delegates, we will hold a big convention and person -- no. and then it was we will hold a zoom convention. now it is a few party insiders will pick this person. i think that looks like a meltdown. jonathan: one more thing. you said this to me in passing yes

would encourage his team, let joe biden be joe biden, and i think that really is his special sauce. it is that joe biden is not ready for prime time but the team around him is not creating or alawing him to -- allowing him to participate in prime time opportunities. howie: they're responsible and the super bowl interview is a bit on the easy side and how you don't make an address even if you don't take questions when you send air strikes against 85 targets against iraq and syria. it's hard for me to understand that written statements don't get a lot of tv play. jason, turning to defense secretary, how is it that lloyd austin is just apologizing now, five weeks after he first checked into the hospital and he went back with complications of prostate cancer and managing not to tell the media, his boss, or anybody else? >> i mean, it's absolutely stunning this happened. i think the press actually did a good job of peppering him with questions saying anybody else in the military who did this would be disciplined, if not dismissed. how is that that you can do this? the answer has to come

ask about the power of 3 with ozempic®. >> i have heard joe biden say he has never discussed businessnd knowledge about this because i directly dealt with the biden family, including joe biden. on may 2nd, 2017, i was introduced to joe biden by jim biden and hunter biden. we discussed the bidens' history the biden's family business plans with the chinese, with which he was plainly familiar at least at a high level. >> laura: well that man, hunter's former business partner testified behind closed doors on capitol hill yesterday about biden's business dealings. and that means, of course, that was more bad news that followed biden's week of bad news. there was the guy, old man confused depiction in the hur report. then democrat murmurs about biden needing to step aside the fake border deal tanking and inflation popping. and then it was bobulinski. and he was telling investigators it is clear to me that joe biden was the brand being sold by the biden family. his family's foreign influence peddling operation from china to ukraine and elsewhere sold out to foreign actors who were seeking to

and i read it as hugh congratulating president biden on whooping you, but i think people read it as using a joeike to say that? >> welcome to twitter world. who got worked last night, i did. my rear end is sore, and of course, i'm congratulated president. i predicted he would get 95%, he got 96%. i don't know how you can misread that tweet, by the way. if you look at the numbers, one person, actually spot with pretty good. i hope i created up. >> reporter: so how do you -- when you look at that whooping, how do you look at your campaign? and how should voters look at your campaign going into the next series and states. what is being served here? because you've got an incumbent president, who's pulling 96% of the vote in a very important state like south carolina, we'll pull a significant number of votes in subsequent states. so what is your path and what does it look like at this point? and why the full measure of what you're doing? >> i appreciate, it michael. it's a mission of principle. i know tradition dictates that you always predict the incumbent. but i democrat who wants to win. and yes,

joe biden. the biden family business was joe biden and joe biden is a lying crook. think about the progression from debate stage in 2020 when joe biden lied and said i't talk to my son about business dealings, i'm not involved, i don't financially benefit. those were lies all along. it is clear from bobulinski's testimony that the biden crime family to put it bluntly prioritize love of money over love of country. doing business with communist chinese, existential threat to this country. the doj and fbi are proven to be protection racket for the biden family. to my knowledge, bobulinski never been interviewed by the doj or fbi, they refuse to interview him while the doj tries to imprison biden's chief political opponent. it is staggering to watch in realtime. >> laura: let's watch. >> we don't have it, sorry. ned, the point here, this is biden family operation. you have valerie biden, jim biden, hunter biden, kind of mofris of roles. democrats keep insists that tony bobulinski is lying. his attorney said it is catagorically false to assert mr. bobulinski failed to provide evidence that biden was involved in business dealings, bobulinski's motivation

how do you feel about joe biden, tell me about it. >> i think that joe biden is doing a great job, withthe things that he is doing, whether the economy or international relationships, i think he's done a lot for us, and i want to show my support for him. >> that is the one thing that you hear from folks actually pumped into the issues and aware of what the administration has done. there seems to be a disconnect between the positive message that resonates with him and other folks who are clearly unaware of that progress. again, that voter is the kind to show up today, those who are informed and mission-driven, ayman. >> across over to steve kornacki at the big board with more numbers,? steve >> what do you do when it's 97 to 2 to 1 in terms of that second the vote? look, one thing that we can tell you that is interesting to add to the conversation here is that it's what has been reported so far in south carolina. the thing that is most noteworthy to me is, actually, the three counties with the lowest share of black population in the state are theory that we have got reports from. you've

so what does joe biden have to fear from michigan congresswoman so first of, all i don't think joe biden has to fear anything. i think joe biden is listening. i think we are a purple state you know, i can do him file takes for a long time. i'm not all but i'm season. >> this >> state is always and i go back to 2000 and al gore and the weekend before the election he was down, he ended up winning the state and george bush went to florida. and what would've happened if it had been another way, we're going to be perfectly fitting november but unlike to 15 to 16, when i warn people that donald trump could win michigan and everybody thought it was crazy. >> people are listening to me. >> we know what we have to do. we have to turn out our vote. so we're going to turn out our votes. and there are communities that are hurting joe biden understands that they're hurting and he's going to have to spend time with them and listen to them. but this is a purple state. we know we've got to do, we're going to roll up our sleeves and we're going to deliver. >> do you think the efforts by by congresswoman

i know what worked. when joe biden puts in executive orders he is rumored to do he will defy his own words that said nothing i can do to control this. has to be done through congress. you have a bunch of bad options, mr. president. and you are coming to the border two times in three years is not great. >> harris: let's add this to the mix. critics are railing against bob costas who said this about former president trump and his supporters on cnn this weekend. >> he is by far the most disgraceful figure in modern presidential history. only become more disgraceful since 2016 and since 2020. he is a bubbling caldron of loath some traits. you have to be in the throes of a toxic delusion and toxic cult to believe donald trump has ever been in any sense emotionally, psychologically or ethically fit to be president. >> harris: brian. >> i know bob costas. i know how bright he is. by the time he was 34 best sportscaster in the country. that's exactly how he feels. but i think it's so shallow of him to think that you can have y

i think the numbers will remain to be seen. obviously joe biden was the decisive winner and the democratic primary tonight. we are swearing off again for a trump biden rematch. and i think when voters are presented with that stark contrast of joe biden's record and trump's record, joe biden's vision for america, and trump's vision for america, that contrast will send voters rushing to the polls again for joe biden, as they did in 2022. because we have seen the devastating consequences of a trump presidency. and we know that a second term could be even worse. >> congresswoman hillary scholten, thank you very much for joining us tonight. >> thank you so much for having me, lawrence. >> coming up, we'll have more of the numbers, but as of now joe biden is headed to a much bigger victory in michigan among democrats than donald trump is headed for among republicans in michigan. we heard republican voters in michigan's primary today explain their vote for donald trump by repeating donald trump 's 2020 election lie. michigan's barbara mcquade's new book

i think the numbers will remain to be seen. obviously joe bidenisive winner and the democratic primary tonight. we are swearing off again for a trump biden rematch. and i think when voters are presented with that stark contrast of joe biden's record and trump's record, joe biden's vision for america, and trump's vision for america, that contrast will send voters rushing to the polls again for joe biden, as they did in 2022. because we have seen the devastating consequences of a trump presidency. and we know that a second term could be even worse. >> congresswoman hillary scholten, thank you very much for joining us tonight. >> thank you so much for having me, lawrence. >> coming up, we'll have more of the numbers, but as of now joe biden is headed to a much bigger victory in michigan among democrats than donald trump is headed for among republicans in michigan. we heard republican voters in michigan's primary today explain their vote for donald trump by repeating donald trump's 2020 election lie. michigan's barbara mcquade's new book explains how

think, robert hur had to find something justify that calling him elderly man with poor memory i am sure joe bidenentire true with robert hur said he couldn't remember anything that is about what people do when they have done something long they say "i can't remember that was too long ago" joe biden himself a to blame for that i do think you see the press conferences, for gets things not the full as they say not very sharp but sharp enough, i mean, he is even back in 2020 he has sharp in the debates, still does very few press conferences when he does he is, obviously, doctors who he every has got him into a mental state where he can cope with that so not completely gone is what i am saying i think you he ought to be accountable for actions held accountable for stashed classified documents everywhere wilfully doing so and sharing them, as a donald trump has been but that is why they had to have headline grabbing moments, basically saying the president's too senile i think tony bobulinski had a front row seat on the entire china, with bidens explain that how joe biden lied about development of. >> s

i have a feeling that joe biden did not use the same criteria when choosing kamala harris, that's justell, i do not believe that was joe biden's criteria. i'll say this with nikki haley. at this point, she's like a suicide bomber on the entire republican party. okay. in addition to repeating every single dem talking point about donald trump, she's only in the race to waste donald trump's resources and to slow him down from focusing on the general and in addition to that, what she's doing and why she has support is she's using the democrat get out the vote operations so she's getting independents that are actually democrats and democrats to switch party af affiliation o vote in the republican primary. that will dirty up the data for the next two or three election cycles, they'll send door knockers, mailers, text messages, phone calls to democrats that will never vote republican, all for the sole reason of trying to slow down trump's run to the white house. this is damage that's going to continue on for possibly a decade that she's doing right now. so it is a disaster. she has no chance,

biden this election, as it in 2020. so, i think that's what he needs to doing and then stylistically, joe biden just needs to be joe biden. he had some great moments this week where he smade jokes abou his age, he showed people that he knows how to take selfies on cell phones. frankly, i think sometimes joe biden's team is playing three- dimensional chess but their fate is going to make a gaffe am or that his age will become an issue. when the right run right into un things or republicans are trying to igmake his vulnerabilities, that's really when joe biden is at his best and i hope that we can continue to hosee more and more of that version of joe biden, as he ramps n up the campaign trail. >> danielle moody, lucy caldwell, thank you so much for getting us started today. we appreciate it. and msnbc is going to have special coverage of the south carolina coprimary starting tod at 4:00 eastern, with my colleagues, jen psaki and jonathan capehart. and at 6:30, rachel maddow and the team will pick up analysis with steve kornacki at the big board. but still to come on the katie phang show, creeping christian nationalism. ho

i think joe biden is going to come out victorious. >> i don't think there's anybody who doubts joe bidenry. the question is how big is that uncommitted vote. your colleague rashida tlaib posted a video two hours ago. i want to play that for you. >> when 74% of democrats in michigan support a cease-fire, yet president biden is not hearing us, this is the way we can use or democracy to say, listen, listen to michigan. >> our nbc poll found that only 29% of voters approve of biden's handling of the war. so does she have a point and between now and november what might he have to do to win over those skeptical, uncommitted voters? >> well, it's very traditional before any election to have lots of speculation, lots of concern. there's certainly -- there isn't polling. we know 1 million have voted early in the absentee. i was at my poling location today and saw people coming in. i saw polling locations across my county and people are voting. we'll find out tonight. i will say i have been with large groups of democrats from troy, michigan, into bloomfield hills and pontiac, michigan, and they're

i did what my ph.d. is not in campaign my ph.d. is in joe biden so that i could go where he was and talk about joe biden and character and why he was the right person. and listen to you and come back and say, joe, you know, i've just met somebody today and this is what and translate and knew i don't want to ruin your reputation but it's well ruined as just wonderful and in wordsmithing and believing that commitment so we ran but i mean once we said yes i was in full bore but and this next one i mean that that's going to look like mary poppins and you know we're going to go through. but you you just can't back that i mean i'm preaching the choir i mean we're we're i'm the what you talk to. no i mean look at what you're going to hang in quarter and imprison the people who who are against you and you're going to be a dictator. and you make fun of people. i mean it. he is the biggest junkyard bully that ever existed. i will i can't even say both their names in the same sentence because it's degrading to say joe biden's name in the same sentence with h

i think people should be speaking up for joe biden. i think people need to be speaking up for the good he's done for the country. the labor unions are stronger than ever because of joe biden. you've got a bunch of people creating jobs in red states and clean energy because of joe biden. joe biden may not be able to speak for himself the way he used to, but we should be speaking up for what he's done. if you don't see people speaking up for him, that's going to be the problem. >> he said something last night i thought really interesting and her take was the way people are consuming information now particularly younger people it's all in little bites and, you know, sound bites on social media and stuff. and there's a split screen of reporters, you know, trying to yap over each other to get their most important question in. with the split screen of that and president biden just looking at them, the reporters, frankly, didn't -- it wasn't a pretty picture from what -- from what the reporters were doing. they -- i mean i aappreciate what my

and if joe biden were going to back america's great police forces, he would have already backed america's great police forces. so i can -- conclude, safe america retire joe biden. -- save america, retire joe biden, that is my riff, for more we bring back our great friend texas senator ted cruz, we appreciate you. i know your position on this senate legislation, but, i just say, i don't want triggers, i just want successful campaign, as you do, remain in mexico, build the wall, catch and deport, the story here, what to we need more legislation for? it is not any good. you know. you know that joe biden and alejandro mayorkas will not close the border, i don't care if it is 5,000 or 8500 or whatever. you know this. that is why this is such an exercise in few till tie, -- few till tie, i am sorry you are the guest. >> look, listen, you are right. every word of your opening remarks were right, one of these days, you will say something this i disagree yet, but not yet. you focused on how this crisis happened. joe biden inherited incredible success, the lo lowest rate of illegal immigration from 45 years and joe biden de

joe biden and should rfk make the ballot. and he's only on the ballot in you too far. it could hurt joe biden's reelection chances. and ink for former president donald trump, he has a feeling a lot of their tactic is to take away voters that would otherwise support joe biden. >> i want to turn, since we have our china expert here, to joe biden and tiktok. he joined tiktok. let's listen to and watch what he said in his first post. >> game or halftime show?>> game. >> i would get in trouble if i told you. >> first of all, that is funny that he's leaning in to the whole conspiracy that is the deep state pushing for taylor swift's boyfriend to win the super bowl. but what about the notion of him being on tiktok, which is, of course, his government said is a national security risk because china? >> for years, folks i know in the intelligence world say do not go on tiktok. it is a massive chinese information gathering operation. and you've heard public pronouncements of the connections and how it could work. it is not insignificant that the president is basically making a political calculation that this is a great way to get

and in terms of what caroline said, i would disagree with that. look, joe bidenhe fact that he is old. when voters are asked do you think joe biden is old, they say, yes. he is old. that is worrisome. that doesn't mean that they are not going to come home for joe biden. and the voters that we're talking about are what we call the double haters who ultimately did come home for him in 2020 and i think may very well. so i think that savvy democratic strategists are looking at this on balance and saying we're actually probably in pretty good shape. howard: well, both candidates obviously have their weak points. but meanwhile, let me get to this, a star witness in the biden impeachment inquiry, the now-indicted informant alexander smirnoff getting lots of coverage as jim comer soft pedaled his own probe in one interview but downplayed smirnoff's importance with sean hannity. >> as to whether or not we impeach joe biden over here or we just focus on holding him accountable, my goal is to get the truth out there and hold people accountable for wrong doing. that may enco

what i think is that joe biden needs to be allowed to be joe biden. a couple of weeks ago for eight hours and he was the joe biden that i know. when he is talking to people, he is energized and cares about issues and he is joe biden. joe biden, there is nobody better than joe biden. i think the campaign needs to let him get out there and be who he is and i also am sick and tired of everybody talking about his age. when you look at the age of donald trump, which is only a couple of years younger, who has 91 felony counts against him and goes on rants that make no sense. the one he did a week ago saturday night. >> dana: would you knowledge that president trump presents as somebody fully with it, with the energy despite the age. people age at a different rate. >> look, i've been with him. yes, i can tell you when i spent eight hours with him, you know me, dana, i had very direct, blunt conversation about every issue there was to discuss in michigan. he was engaged fully on it and we had very intense conversations. when he was with people in the uaw hall

would like to see out of this is i guess they have five hours of videotape of joe biden'ssel, i think republicans in the house need to subpoena that and i think that the american people need to see that. let them decide. is that doable? >> it's absolutely doable. if you are going to have the spokesperson, ian sams come out and say that it was totally a misrepresentation of what happens, there is one way to clear it up. and that is to release the tapes. and that's what they should do. chairman jordan should call special counsel hur to testify so the democrats can relive exactly what happened so they can ask him into their own questions and they really should release the tape. joe biden can unilaterally do that. he should absolutely do that. and by the way, to lisa's point which was spot on. there is no fact pattern where united states senator takes classified information home. you are not to be in possession of it ever. there's no scenario in which that is legal, lawful, or anything else. for it to be willful, he should of been prosecuted. >> sean: i think he needs to be co

i was stunned by the tweet that joe biden put out. the supreme court blocked me. >> i saw that. >> i found another way. if donald trump had said or tweeted something like that, you would be hanging off of the chan chandeliers. this democracy question that you brought up, it's split even in the nbc poll. joe biden has a 37% approval rating. worse going into his election than the last four presidents by a huge number. he often says donald trump is a danger to democracy. if he really believed that, would he be running for re-election? right now, he looks like he's the one democrat that might lose to donald trump. and if you're an average voter and you hear the comment about, he's a danger to democracy, why is he pursuing this re-election campaign that seems like on the brink of -- >> he's the only one. >> voters are not enthusiastic about this campaign or either nominee. this is the resistible force against the movable object. >> we lived through this in the 2022 midterm elections. everyone felt very confident about the republicans' postu

it doesn't seem as if that is the feeling, i would say, most democrats -- they don't feel like they are lining up charge, ready to vote for joe bidene their voices aren't being heard. how are their voices being heard and seen through a vessel like joe biden? >> when it comes to the actual rank and file of left-leaning voters, especially younger voters, there is a lot of disatisfaction with biden. maybe that is because of his age, he is kind of old, he looks like grandpa. maybe it is because -- >> jordan: kind of old? >> really old -- >> jordan: looks like grandpa, sure, yes. >> so does trump. >> jordan: they are both quite old, sure. >> but the challenge for biden will be, how can he bring those younger people back into his coalition? i think one hope is my characters will be effective surrogates. it is either that or he is going to have to count on going on tiktok and trying to attract them in other unorthodox ways that maybe the biden campaign isn't going to be so good at. >> jordan: you talk a lot about economic populism and what people across america really want. i was recently in south carolina, and biden has pretty good numbe

to hunter biden, over $6 million in loans to hunterd tw biden. >> you mentioned two loans to joe biden i jimn when you wee introducing me. >> that's $1,000,000 to joe biden. we hope we haven't found any loan documentation. it appearscumentat that the bidy have been laundering throughterl the the the term loan. and, you know, when you get a loan, you don't have to reporten you g'to on your taxee >> but a loan is something you're supposed to pay back if you geosed tt loan and you do ny it back, then that's income that's income in the form of either a gift of the donor of also income from the person that received the money. re and by the way, if that's an extended period of time that you'r>> seae back, the loan that you buy as a matter of law, i haven? to interest. otherwise, it's considered a gift. you do. >> you do. and the answer is no. they are just another another tool in the toolbox, but they have notnother produced any loan documentation who would loan p people millions of dollars and not have a document. i meana, this is classic import selling. this is the way they tried to deceivng

i have given it to biden. i had sleepy joe biden, i have crooked joe biden. crooked joe is more accurate. you know? although sleepy is pretty good. nikki haley is not in this race to fight for you. she's in the bidding for big donors or maybe she wants to get a contract on cnn. did you see their ratings? there goes the cnn cameras off. why did i do that? [booing]. i shouldn't have done that. the light just went off. they knew what was coming. right? tim? they knew what was coming. they have the worst ratings they've ever had. it's dying. they're not truthful. they're not truthful. by the way, did tim scott make a great speech? [cheers & applause] i don't know if he likes it when i say this, but it's a compliment. because he's such a fine man. he ran and he ran okay. he was okay. he was okay. he's a respected guy. but he ran and he did fine. and then when he got out, he endorsed me and he's a surrogate. he's the greatest surrogate i've ever seen. he went from modest, high quality man, introducing his mother who is incredible, by the way. i said, tim, tim, i sai

has to make the case that he's the one that can help provide the better future for american, i think joe biden's got the receipts on this i mean, all of you have covered joe biden's presidency. joe biden, creative 15 million jobs. we have the lowest unemployment rate. we now have 46,000 infrastructure projects going on across the country. we have $650 billion of private sector investment and we've got the receipts. you got a guy. otherwise, it just talks about things that is now talking about oppression, revenge, and actually looking backward. and i think when americans look at that choice really clearly and the fairy dust leaves the eyes of all the and that's about how it's not going to be biden or it's not going to be trump, it is going to be them. but then, then then we're going to really kind of get down to breath. what did the accounts though for the fact that biden is underperforming his coalition with people who brought him to the presidency in 2020 matches muslim vote, american voters, young voters, pulls to these struggling with hispanic voters black voters also, why is the president ha

joe biden. now we know joe biden is a crook. he mishandled classified information since 1970s. so i think the muddy -- waters have become muddied. joe biden no long every has any argument to make heading into 2024. >> sean: charlie, i don't think the republicans, slim as their majority is in the house, they are not supposed to be potted plants, right? i think for them to insist on secure borders and budget in balance 34 trillion in debt. no new york city more giveaways. maybe loans. maybe help in another way. that seems to be the right political formula. look at previous primaries, all show american people are tired of nearly 10 million illegal, unvetted, joe biden's immigrants crossing our border. there is no vetting. countries, china, russia, afghanistan, syria, iran. not vetted. we'll get into more detail later in the program. that is 80/20. 85/15. maybe 90/10 issue in terms of what the american people want. i want them to fight for that. >> absolutely. biggest mistake republicans on capitol hill made they didn't agree to die on the hill of protecting our border closing the borde

i know joe biden. i was in michigan with him last week, and we were talking about issues. all kinds of issues. issues that matter. and i'll tell you, we were talking about the mideast and arab-americans, and we had some of the blood test, and i mean blunt conversations. this is a man that's on his game. >> let's talk about that, because i remember talking to you during the hillary clinton campaign when i was covering hillary clinton, and you were sounding the alarm for her campaign about michigan, where she lost in the primary, unexpectedly, to bernie sanders. i'd say less surprising to you. and then she lost in the general election to donald trump there. you are sounding the alarm, clearly, to president biden. what is your worry as we look at administration officials going there to michigan, talking to the arab-american population that is so concerned about how the u.s. and biden is supporting israel in its prosecution of its war? >> look, it's taken too long, i'm going to tell you that, but i will say you saw him come this week after he came to michigan last weekend, and

biden? >> he won the south carolina primary here -- i would not vote for donald trump. i don't think i can stomach a vote for joeg for some third party or write-in candidate. will: if say no labels picked nikki haley and trump and biden were on ticket along with nikki haley your vote would still go to nikki haley? >> the presidential candidate i would strongly consider voting for her in a general election. if it was -- someone like joe manchin i would consider voting for somebody like him. >> all right. hayden andrej thank you so much for being with us this morning interesting perspective on both philosophical and strategic level of the vote thank you both. all right. hey by the way, coming up on the will cain show this week streams live at 12:00 every day at fox news.com and on the fox news youtube channel we've got jeffrey turker economist, byron donalds with us on tuesday kennedy will hang out with addition of will and pete off the wall you have off the grid you've got will and pete here streaming at the will cain show hang out around lunchtime we would love to have you. a wild competition from the mechanical

joe biden miscues me. they voted for joe biden because they want it done. right. so here's here's my question. i mean, ashley makes the observation she thinks maybe we're getting close to a time where joe biden needs to endorse a ceasefire would that be enough for arab muslim voters in michigan based on your reporting? >> i mean, not a singularly, and i think that's partially because the political damage, as we see tonight, has been laid over a set of months. these are folks who are been consistently calling for the president to be more vocal on this issue it's due to lead or to even acknowledge the consistency of the criticism. and they have chosen not to do those things. i think that if even if there were to be a ceasefire, you still see lingering kind of a holdover feelings. i think feed into a larger perception of biden as out of touch with the base. now that is expressed here among there, but muslim community that's expressed among young people among the different way doesn't surprise among black voters in a different way, but it's a larger feeling of a disconnect between but between admini

be it bill clinton or barack obama and now joe biden. ion't think any american president in history has been so supportive of israel and gave such strong backing to israel than joe biden. but still, for political expediency, it's good for netanyahu to campaign as if he is standing up against the pressure to build a palestinian state in gaza. or to bring the palestinian authority there. it is good for him politically. and it's good for biden politically, vis-a-vis the situation in israel. >> and do you think it's the coalition that is holding netanyahu together? what is the state of the israeli government? >> no coalition in israel is ever stable. this coalition has been more stable than others because ied . they joined the covenant without aspirational portfolios or executive jobs, only to be part of the handling of the war. so, netanyahu can play. he has one cabinet with the ministers and a different cabinet with the centrist ministers and his own party. he is playing between both. his main risk is from the far right, ditching the coaliti

>> i think joe biden needs to get ahead of this issue. needs to run into the age issue rather than fear from it, shy away from it. and you actually see this a lot, i think that the biden team is so concerned that he's going to go out and make a gaffe, which i would note joe biden has done all of his career. it's kind of his thing. they're so afraid that he's going to come off as old, that they wind up doing something that reinforces a right wing narrative that they are hiding him. and actually, you can even see this tension reflected in how joe biden sometimes talks when he's making remarks off the cuff. he'll say things like i'm going to get in trouble for saying this. i should be careful about how i say this as if to reflect the fact that behind the scenes his team is holding tight control to make sure the optics are good. i would say joe biden is at his best when joe biden is being joe biden. let him out there, let him make more jokes like the yolk he made at a rally a couple of months ago where someone fell and stumbled, and he said l

president, nor when his own son died. >> this is the beginning of the end of joe biden's reelections campaign. democrats, that ipoken to are at a full blown panic. the problem is alternative is kamala harris who polls lower than joe biden and gavin newsom who has a horrific record in california. that's where we're at, guys. yesterday was the biggest moment of this primary season so far no doubt because of the report and damning things he said about joe biden's mental state. >> carley: everybody is making predictions on this she and beginning of the end is your prediction about president biden's future media obviously reacting to this report. a portion of what some in the media had to say. watch. this you want to get the age thing. call it what it is. this is ageism snuck into a report clearing the person of any wrongdoing. >> man is 80 years old. >> he rides a bike. >> he is the age. >> i think some people covering biden you realize he does have a temper. his whole staff, his allies. >> mexico? mexico? where did that come from? i mean, that's the only thing anyone is going to remember from this. >> well-meaning

i pointed out the cognitive decline. he is defending joe's cognitive state. that was not joe biden's flobeck of the week but he made a major his slip up in vegas on sunday. let's refresh your memory on that one. >> president biden: after i was elected i would to a g-7 meeting with all of the nato leaders. i was in south england. and i sat down and i said america. >> and [indistinct] iran from france looked at me and said, yw long are you back for? >> ask a question. have you ever gone to walmart, target, and a lot of times they have great respect they tend to be older people, retired that for whatever reason they are bored and want a little extra cash. they greet you. welcome to walmart. and that you say, how are you? can i help you with anything? in the nicest, most helpful people you will ever meet in your life and pleasant and smart. i don't think job could be a walmart greeter. -- joe could be a walmart greeter. i don't think he could remember where all of the different departments are. i don't think he could do that job. the president, joe biden, president mitterrand died in 199

i am told there was a phone that joe biden used. t have that yet is my understanding. >> no doubt he had a phone. i called it wants thinking i was calling hunter and got joe. there is a phone. no doubt about it. i think at the end of the day most of the key elements are there. one thing republicans need is a clear story. i just still hard to do because there so many parts coming together. the clearer the story becomes the easier it is for the public to get behind impeachment. the president lied to get into office. he facilitated shakedowns with some people who are not desirable individuals. joe biden thought burisma was corrupt. joe met with one of the executives in 2014. why shouldn't that be a matter of concern? there is one thing they will be going towards in the next couple weeks. there are three ukrainian documents that were found in joe biden's possession that were classified. all are in the timeframe around when he was pressuring the ukrainian government to fire the prosecutor who was looking at joe biden's sons company burism