and he would seek weizmann, give a direct order i will only see and talk to ian weizmann. do not let sulfur and those people in the white house again. >> what else has changed? >> there was a famous incident when silver was in the office and apparently shook his fingers in truman's face, and truman was upset and person he saw after that i never want that and so be in my office again and that is when he kind of shut down and said i don't want to see any more extreme zionist leaders which is a category he had developed. >> one thing neither of you touch on in your remarks and i wonder if you get into it in the book is the position of the defense department, because my understanding is it wasn't simply marshall for the leading cabinet secretaries opposed but james also took a strong view. can you talk about that? >> he was the cia as well hammes cia long memo was declassified and is one of the intelligence magazines too late to include in the book and it wouldn't have mattered if we put it in the book. it was almost verbatim, the same argument as the state department. it coul