. >> but that's happened fins time immemorial.thing new. >> with all respect that's just wrong. that just isn't true. >> that's nonsense. >> i'm sorry. we have run out of time, gentlemen. william benny, robert deitz, thank you so much for joining us. the third rail panel is next if the you've just heard about government surveillance impacting one person. let's broaden it to the general public's access to your information online. richard is an attorney who served as a senior advisor to president clinton and now contributes to new yorker.com. as well as hugh hewitt. hugh, let's start with you. france wants to expand european's right to be forgotten so you can basically appeal and say, hey, i would like some stuff about me when you google me and can you take it down. does that sound reasonable to you? >> no. it makes every historian in the audience say what a horrible idea. martha washington burned george washington's letters. we're poorer for it. whenever anything is lost from history's record, we are poorer for it. france can't dic

. >> but that's happened fins time immemorial. that's nothing new. >> with all respect that's just wrong. that just isn't true. >> that's nonsense. >> i'm sorry. we have run out of time, gentlemen. william benny, robert deitz, thank you so much for joining us. the third rail panel is next if the >> investigating a dark side of the law >> they don't have the money to puchace their freedom... >> for some...crime does pay... >> the bail bond industry has been good to me.... i'll make a chunk of change off the crime... >> fault lines, al jazeera america's hard hitting... >> today they will be arrested... >> ground breaking... they're firing canisters of gas at us... emmy award winning investigative series... chaising bail only on al jazeera america you've just heard about government surveillance impacting one person. let's broaden it to the general public's access to your information online. richard is an attorney who served as a senior advisor to president clinton and now contributes to new yorker.com. as well as hugh hewitt. hugh, l

. >> sea serpents have been in the conscious of people from time immemorial because whenever there'sny body of water in this world, they have encountered animals they don't know about. >> nessie, cressey, champ, owe go pogo, many bodies of water play host to a mythical creature. some imams of these critters are proven hoaxes and others are simply unexplained. >> it's imperative that we have physical evidence. until you do that, they still float around in the clouds and mists of myth. >> in 2009 this surfaces. it remains unidentified. for believer, there is only one anticipate this is caddie. oh, my gosh, you guys should see this. >> [ bleep ]. >> cad borrowsaurus, wilsey, or caddie for short, is a creech sure said to inhabit cad borrow bay in british columbia. much the story of caddie is very old, because the first nation's people here in british columbia have representations of it. >> the natives a lot of them won't even go on the lake. >> some 200-plus caddie sightings have been documented, but it wasn't until this serpent-like cash cass was found in the stomach of a sperm whale in

unlike the park which has been held since time immemorial for the benefit of the public has become license plates are -- >> you want is to say the public forum are not involve overtime according to -- people to go to parks in order to drive. >> traditional public forum can evolve over time, but the indicia of a traditional public forum so that's the one that is open to attacks is not open license plate. if other states wanted -- >> in a world in which you've approved 400 license plates and a pretty common in the state and you only disapproved every select few, it does seem as though you've basically relinquished your control over this and make it a people's license would for whatever private speech people want to say. >> justice kagan, i think would be odd to say that it's private speech when the board is taking a public vote and receiving notice and comment, a governmental function of when the government wants to act and then it is placing its name on the license plate. when the government is placing its name on the license plate it is accepting and signify that this is the government's m

since the time of the pyramids or whatever but they haven't had license plate messages since time immemorial. so maybe that's why they shouldn't be considered just like the monuments. >> mr. chief justice, don't mean to suggest they're just like the monuments but it's still a fixed medium, and a tangible message is being displayed to a captive audience, as the court recognized in leeman. and in those situations the government is entitled to select the messages it wishes to propagate and are going to be close the identified -- >> identity rather have the license plates than the pyramids. i don't know that we want to drive texas to having pyramids. >> justice scalia, we also want to retain our license plates. >> that shows what this case is about. the respondents want texas to place itself stamp of approval on the confederate battle flag through license plates and texas doesn't have to make that judgment. >> i don't want to beat a dead horse. what's the best distinction you can give me between what you do with license plates and billboards, a soap box, an official state web site where people c

we have kept these records and inkeepers have kept these records for time immemorial. we use these records for different purposes. every record of our business transaction. we use them to keep in touch with our customers. it's quite proprietary information. >> motel 6 does this? i never received anything from them. [laughter] >> my goodness. >> you may not be in their frequent guests. nobody doubts. remember, this is an ordinance that applies to the four seasons, and ritz charlton and everything else. they carve out a subsegment while we are attentive to the point we are not asserting -- the guests are not asserting 4th amendment rights here, let's not lose sight of the fact that these records can show very very personal information. not just the driver's license information, but whether you stayed at a hotel during a religious or political convention. >> complaining about the privacy interest of the guests. >> justice scalia, here's the point. they agree this is a fourth amendment search, point one. then, what you are doing you have to make an honest assessment whethe