the implications are for russia, what do we do now? this alternate pipeline that they're discussing into turkey is very much second best. it does not have the same geopolitical implications that nubuko did for europe. this is a big win because it has had this pressure, this very heavy pressure from russia. it was going to redouble it's dominating presence economic and political presence in europe through this pipeline. this is now lifted. >> where is the oil that these pipelines are not going to be carrying through turkey, where is that--not the oil, but the natural gas. where is that now coming from? >> this gas comes from russia. and the whole thing, these pipelines, south stream pipeline was not going to add any volumes to what was going in to europe. it was very much a political pipeline. it was all about as i said being in the united states, skirting ukraine, and now the same valu valu volumes, by pass that putin is now discussing if that goes you'll get 15 bcm. it's not a large volume. that will go half the volume going into the

what are the implications of this? congressional hearings were held. of course, this is all played out in the journals. a very controversial thing. it took something like 10 years before there was some consensus that these were probably not fossils, that they were other things, other explanations that were not biological and origin. again, the media played a big role there. even when it does not originate with the media, this is more like an event that i think will actually occur. the media will be very important in how they play that to the public, especially with social media and e-mail and all that. >> again, the second area of your research? >> the nature of discovery. it turns out discovery is not what most people think in terms of, eureka, i point my telescope and there it is. discovery is always an extended process. when you discover new classes of astronomical objects, it is never you point your telescope and know what you are looking at. when galileo pointed his telescope at saturn and saw these protuberances on the body of the planet, he had

more deeplys even implicated, even more deeply implicated. now relating again his interpretation, his memory of his first confrontation with celia in the kitchen. i told her she knew where her master was, that george and set enough to make me believe she knew where he was. what he toldxactly us just prior that george said. george said something about celia's cabin, but you can see how powell and others investigating this case begin to andern that between celia george might be a space in which they can insert some doubt, that might confusion , mightm more evidence even net them a confession. andbeginning to play celia george off one another in a perhaps, embellishing, what george has said to him. remains resolute that she had nothing to do with this. finally, jefferson jones -- you will remember he is a neighboring farmer, a large farmer in fulton. his farm is adjacent to that of the newsom family. he is one of the first people outside the family itself on the scene stop his testimony plays important role both in the indictment of celia and im

what are the implications of this? >> they are huge. this is really unprecedented. we will just have to wait to see how the story plays out. the fact that an anonymous hacker -- and we have no idea who it is. it could be anything. an anonymous hacker group can take on one of the richest, most powerful movie companies in the world and essentially bring it to its knees is phenomenal. hollywood now is just running scared. they are scared to send e-mails. they are going back to pen and paper and blackboards and so forth. essentially if someone can do this to sony, then no one is safe. >> over the past couple of weeks, details have been filtering out slowly about what exactly was stolen. what are the hackers doing and what are they threatening to do with this information? >> the threats have not been very specific. we have heard recently about the threats to theaters that are scaring off theaters who are pulling the film. what the hackers have done already is a number of things, they grabbed a number of films that were on the sony service and put them out on the internet

disputes over islands in the south and east china seas have broad economic and security implications to the united states interest in the asia pacific region. disruption in this region could cause serious problems across the globe. i strongly believe that the united states must take a leadership role in these disputes and work to support a peaceful collaboration to these issues. the resolution takes a step in the right direction. we cannot accept unilateral action by any of the countries involved in these disputes as it it further degrades security in the region. here is a clear example of congress supporting the united states role in the rebalance to the asia-pacific region. in particular, we cannot allow

and the implications of this report are profound. not only is torture wrong but it doesn't work. and for people, we hear them coming from different places, saying it was great, it was terrific what we did, it got us so much. it got us nothing except a bad name. without this report, the american people would not know what actually took place under the c.i.a.'s torture program. this critical report highlights the importance of senate oversight and the role that congress must play in overseeing the executive branch of government. the only way our country can put this episode in the past is to come to terms with what happened and commit to ensuring it will never happen again. this is how we as americans make our nation stronger. when we realize there is a problem, we seek the evidence. we study it, we learn from it, and then we set about to enact

i think the question -- besides the moral and ethical implications, and clearly -- >> i think the issue is one of proportionality. i think we always have to ask ourselves at what cost does victory come? and i think, you know, clearly the use of atomic weaponry is debated in 1954 when the french are on the verge of losing, there's an argument made by some among the joint chiefs of staff we should use tactical nuclear weapons to keep the forces at bay and to save the french and

caller: you mentioned some negative implications that come from these clips. is this connected to the clip from two years ago with those debate, that it would have a massive negative economic implication and attacks occurred under bill clinton. to these clips really going create negative implications one way large corporations would have the bush tax cuts? i was referring to is the interplay incongruous with the physical play, and and all rnment shutdown of that, and the political drama that we saw fold. nobody will like that. there is a lot of frustration in the business world but for average americans outside of politics. there is a lot of frustration. the point that i was trying to is a great t question, i do not expect that any spenders were created sort of clip. on our from oklahoma line for democrats. caller: the interest rate to help seniors is very low and tax breaks for seniors. we are all on fixed income, i would like to see and hear something about what the taxes are going to be doing for seniors. is another great question, if you are a senior that

so what are the implications of that?rst one -- there are many, but i want to say two of them -- the first one is china is today developing its new, its own nuclear technology. and by building, constructing a lot of nuclear power plants, bringing the cost down, and we may well see china soon to be a serious competitor to western countries in terms of exporting the nuclear technology. today the main nuclear technology countries -- north america, europe, japan, korea -- we may well see china with a new generation and lower costs may well be serious competitor there with all of its implications. second, today in the world 80% of the nuclear plants are in oecd countries, 20% in non-oecd countries. as a result of this picture in two decades of time, it will be 50% o to ecd -- oecd, 50% non-oecd countries of the nuclear power plants worldwide, and, of course, this has lots of implications in terms of climate change, in terms of energy security and all other issues. for nuclear today we see two major challenges. one is the finan

and more on that and the implications. and oracle results.up more than 9 percent of the open and stocks overall in rally mode with the dow up more than 225 points. all that and more on "squawk alley" coming up. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 [ male announcer ] your love for trading never stops, tdd# 1-800-345-2550 even on the go. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 open a schwab account, and you could earn tdd# 1-800-345-2550 300 commission-free online trades. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 so if you get a trade idea, schwab can help you take it on. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 we're getting a lot of questions tdd# 1-800-345-2550 about organic food stocks. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 [ male announcer ] sharpen your instincts tdd# 1-800-345-2550 with in-depth analysis by schwab experts. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 and if you want to run your idea tdd# 1-800-345-2550 by a schwab trading specialist, tdd# 1-800-345-2550 our expertise is just a tap away. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 what's on your mind, lisa? tdd# 1-800-345-2550 i'd like to talk about a trade idea. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 let's hear it. tdd# 1-800-345-255

but this has very important positive implications. because he doesn't have his own power base when he became the leader. because he doesn't have to take care of his own people, and only he needs to do is he can -- he needs to dismantle the current power structure. so when he -- this has important political meaning. [ inaudible ]. maybe his own companies, and so on. p after his uncle's execution, kim jong-un endured a lot of new resources to -- that can be distributed to the new leaders. so this has very important political and economic implications. in the nuclear power, but i think kim jong can take very aggressive marketization of policies, because he has nuclear power. so he's proud in his nuclear power, and he's emphasized the nuclear power, and it's not negotiable. based on that confidence, he can push marketization farther. so we may think of that as north korea proceeds, and makes progress in marketization. he can change the system, and effect on the elections that may contribute to north korea's dismantlement of the nuclear we

that is a great story with enormous implications.ins, best known as the founder of electronic arts has his sights set on the markets for competitive mobile gaming. we will find out why with our exclusive interview, next. ♪ >> i'm cory johnson and this is breaking newst." coming out of sydney, australia. let's listen to the latest. finding ways to actually heal the wounds, to help everyone grow stronger because we all want a stronger australia. i, too, would like to commend our police. while anyone could second-guess what occurred in the last hours, they are the ones to had to make the decision. it was tough, exacting work, whether they were part of the team that had to make that entry and deal with the situation, i want to point out they have saved lives. they have saved many lives. to those men and women, all that were involved, we thank you. as the commissioner, i think you , as a community, australia thanks you. thank you you are prepared to put your life on the line to keep us safe. it's a very honorable cause and for that, our a

>> there are several implications.irst of all, greece might lose 1.8 billion remaining under the current program, which expires at the end of december. there would be no credit line unless this review is completed. bondsy, greek government would no longer be accepted as collateral by the ecb. greece would be left without the unlessp come january 1 this was concluded, and conclusion of the review is a prerequisite for requesting an extension of the program into three months or six months of 2015. >> what are the chances of the review being completed and greece getting an extension? the review needs to be completed at staff level by next monday at the latest, because european parliaments need to approve the extension before around therecess 18th or the 19th of december. there is only really one week left in which to conclude the negotiations between the greek government and the troika. >> what are the implications politically in greece? we are waiting to see when we will have presidential elections. they could potentiall

i'm sorry that you came away from it with that as the implication.ot my intent. >> having said that, i am empathetic to a lot of your point. i am aware of harrell chased them along time ago. >> in prison right now for selling potential. >> i would have to say that i think whoever is the unified grocers label are, they left out in trader joe's blew it. i have to say they are not obligated to give that to you because there is a business confidentiality that is involved in business confidentiality when it comes to sourcing. >> i'm going to sapi for second. i would do two things. i'm going to take a question from this lady. since you don't have any natural direction projects -- >> i don't eat canned beans. i cooked my own. >> at any rate, let me take the question here. i appreciate your point of view. my job is a joy and it is a tough one oath. i have to make decisions along the way. i appreciate your criticism and your support. yes, ma'am. [inaudible] -- wholesale produce markets? >> wholesale produce market i did not visit. >> at 110 offices were being

what vermont is doing and implications nationally. what do you think? >> i think the implications are exactly pa our friend dagen said. single payer doesn't work. single payer is too expensive. single pay sir too bureaucratically unwieldly, trying to back down, first state by state. never that plan. we in the nixon days had a great plan, just pay for the health insures for private companies for poor people. that's t. adam, feel guilty? >> always. thank you for reminding me, neil. we don't know if single parent would have worked. never a political will to do single parent nationally where it had the scale. we don't know. >> guy, thank you all. dagen, charlie, as almost a pleasure. >> do i get to kill him now? >> please, stand in line. you'll have to stand in line. >>> up next, it was a great year for stocks. >> they didn't see what happened. >> i don't want them to, and an even better year for charles payne. semiconductor -- this is charles -- right? a big, since he picked it, in july. don't think he can top it? think again, after this. ♪ (holiday music

so robert asked me to talk about the fourth plan of legal reforms and their implications for u.s./china relations. i'll start off with a broad brush picture of the fourth plan reforms and talk about their possible implications for u.s./china relations, but don't hold your breath because i don't think there are a lot of implications. the big picture summary of the fourth plenary reform decision is i think that it contemplates no fundamental reform in the basic relationship between the legal system on the one hand and sort of the party/government on the other hand. so it seems pretty clear to me that institutionally speaking, the party is going to remain above the law. at the same time, though, i think the decision does contemplate some genuinely meaningful and in my opinion positive reforms, and so, you know, i don't think that it would be correct to look at the decision and say, oh, well, it is not advancing towards some ideal we have of the rule of law and it is meaningless. there is meaningful stuff going on there and much of it positive. so i guess first of all i just want to e

we're very glad to bring you this program on corruption, constitutionalism and control, implications of the fourth china and u.s./china relations. this afternoon's talk brings together two topics which are very often treated separately although i think they belong in the same program which are corruption and china's attempts to carry out further round of legal reforms. no doubt all of you have been following corruption stories from china over the past few years. and you have heard about x ping's willingness to take on both tigers and flies. probably followed the some times sorted tales -- ping's attempt to combat corruption is often in the american media characterized as a campaign but it really seems to be a state of affairs. it's part of xi's on going govern nans. combatting corruption has been one of the major factors leading to xi ping's great popularity in china. you need to look no further than the second line of the new viral song in china called -- i don't know if you've heard this or not. it's covered in today's new york times. if you haven't seen it, i rj you to give it a c

privacy concerns far beyond those implicated by the search of other objects. david, you wrote in the nation the title of your paper is the one supreme court decision we can celebrate it in ruling policemen that search cell phones without award the court brought the fourth amendment into the 21st century. i'm assuming you agreed with the courts opinion and riley to can you say a bit more about that and how far that went in satisfying your consent have expressed the computer severely weakened the fourth amendment, so much so you side and other times in the modern digital age the fourth amendment means very, very little. >> the first thing i want is it is really unfair to ask michael to talk about three cases that he lost. [laughter] but i think it's interesting. michael doesn't lose many cases in the supreme court. not a one, because he's one of the best advocates that this nation has. number two, because he's representing the government against bad guys, pretty consistently. and yet we made him talk about the three cases he's lost. i think maybe michael does as

george has somehow, if not implicated celia, certainly implicated her cabin as the site of newsome'smise. this will lead to the area around her cabin and scrutinize celia herself. this precedes the confrontation with celia are. we have a transcription of his oral testimony. on cross-examination which is to say as he's being examined by the attorneys for celia he again speaks of george. i went into the cook house where celia was. i told her she knew where her master was. that george had said enough to make me believe she knew where he was. she denied it. now, george svenis more deeply implicated. powell is relating the first confrontation with celia in the kitchen. she knew where her master was. we can see the ways in which powell and others who were investigating this case begin to discern that between celia and george might be a space in which they can insert some doubt. insert some confusion that might net them more evidence. maybe a confession. they are off one another in a sense. embellishing perhaps even what george has said to him. celia, as we know at this juncture remains res

one of the implications of this film, this mediocre comedy.he interview" has really only increased the friction between north korea and japan. north korea has called the film an act of war. cnn's will ripley joins us live from tokyo. and will, you have learned new information about how this film was approved in the first place. >> yeah, well, there was certainly, according to these e-mails and what we're learning there was increasing discomfort among top-level sony executives about the content of this film. and you can bet there are going to be serious questions raised here on out about how much of a role sony here will play when it comes to sony pictures entertainment. seth rogen with all due respect may not be familiar with the geopolitical issues, the tension between japan and north korea. we know that the sony entertainment ceo consulted a probably concern, a think tank, rand corporation. he's on the board of that corporation and he asked one of the korean experts to take a look at the film and write up his thoughts. the expert said it's p

what are the implication of that? >> i think that it's a lot of fun to make fun of hollywood. this was very embarrassing for a lot of people in hollywood. that was the initial reaction. but i think that this is a very serious thing that the u.s. government and the broader private sector in the u.s. should have come to sony's defense and been much more aggressive in its response. now the white house is waking up. but this should have happened days ago because this is a fundamental attack on first amendment rights in this country. if we don't -- if we can't defend against this we're victims of terrorism. >> what should we do about it, mary? >> if it is north korea, we don't know for sure. but let's say it's north korea, put them back on the list of sponsors of terror. >> that were taken off by george bush. >> absolutely. japan for example is now conducting its own negotiations with north korea, so we are not presenting united front against the regime. >> china we believe is looking to least turning a blind eye. >> isn't that award for the obama administration that just stood up

the details. >> yeah, you are right, but let me just ask you again, what we think the long term implications of this information that's. released and everything you have been outlining for us? well, president obama has ruled out prosecuting anyone involved and he just put out a statement, to you if i could. he said rather than another reason to refight old arguments i hope today's report can can help us leave these techniques in the past. today is a reminder that upholding the values we profess doesn't make us weaker it makes us stronger. and hook to prosecute any of the people involved even though that is exactly what some inside the united nations are calling for. congress i should point out does have the ability to hold people accountability for highing to congress, because this report says basically the c.i.a. lied to everyone, the president, the white house, the national security council, members of congress, the public, highing to congress is illegal, they could prosecute, but that's unlikely to happen. let's not forget they didn't want this released in the first place. reporting from

caller: you mentioned some negative implications that come from these clips. is this connected to the clip from two years ago with those debate, that it would have a massive negative economic implication and attacks occurred under bill clinton. to these clips really going create negative implications one way large corporations would have the bush tax cuts? i was referring to is the interplay incongruous with the physical play, and and all rnment shutdown of that, and the political drama that we saw fold. nobody will like that. there is a lot of frustration in the business world but for average americans outside of politics. there is a lot of frustration. the point that i was trying to is a great t question, i do not expect that any spenders were created sort of clip. on our from oklahoma line for democrats. caller: the interest rate to help seniors is very low and tax breaks for seniors. we are all on fixed income, i would like to see and hear something about what the taxes are going to be doing for seniors. is another great question, if you are a senior that

that could have implications for whole of europe. prime minister andonis samaras be is standing for reelection. the rks syriza party is stand to gain. a human implication for the situation in greece which in turn has an impact on greece's creditors and the euro zone. >> yes presumably so barbara. the first few months at least of the new year are going to be pretty turbulent with greece very firmly back in the international spotlight as it tries to work its way towards a sustainable government out of a snap election, bearing in mind that that may well be a coalition of parties that have never been in power before. and all of that creates uncertainty that the financial markets don't like and all of this happening at a time when greetionthatgreece is only beginning to emerge from six years of recession. take a look at the wide are picture, greece's position in the euro zone and how that may be affected. joining me is a journalist who writes widely on financial policy yergos scopopolis, let's talk about this, how difficult is it going to

>> so there are huge implications. he is going to freeze up a lot of these establishment donors.t basically means there's not much space at all for mitt romney. he's basically the same kind of figure as jeb bush in this potential primary. it causes a lot of complications for chris christie, the governor of new jersey who was counting on support from a lot of the same donors who appear to be migrated toward jeb bush, also senator marco rubio, also from florida, there is a lot of overlap in his donor network. bush is just a very attractive candidate to these donors for the reasons susan identified. >> woodruff: susan, there are so many names out there, in fact, brand-new names. south carolina's lindsey graham, former new york governor george pataki both saying today they're looking at running for president. but how do you see the bush announcement affecting some other names we've been hearing about? i mean, rand paul, the governor of texas, former governor of texas, rick perry. >> i think it makes it hard for marco rubio to run and maybe harder for chris christie to run mitt romney

even as it ended, implications are being felt around the world today.e do not know of a direct connection between the gunman and isis or any radical islamic group or whether this, in fact, is a lone wolf attack. this is exactly the terror and chaos isis has repeatedly had people spread around the globe. now it's asking nations to re-examine their terrorism security merchandise. joining us for what this means, we're joined on the set with retired lieutenant colonel michael kay and joining us is david rothkopf. and joining us from virginia is former fbi profiler and msnbc contributor clint van zandt. thank you for being with us. david, i wanted to start with you on what exactly isis is doing. we don't know of a direct connection but what is isis doing to encourage this sort of lone wolf attack around the globe? >> well, isis by its nature dross misfits and people who are seeking this kind of trouble. don't know that we're ever going to draw a direct connection between isis and this guy. the more we hear about this guy, the more it seems like he was not on

with increasing demand and enormous economic implications and competitive implications for our nation. as you know, the the faa modernization act was established for technology. the act directed faa to take stamps to advance integration with the goal of safely integrating technology by 2,015. in june we reported on faa efforts in these 11 recommendations specifically aimed at helping faa more effectively meet the goals. my testimony today will focus on the progress in implementing the act provisions and the challenges that the agency faces and safely integrating technology. today they lead in more than half of the requirements. this includes selecting the test site as well as publishing a roadmap outlining agency plans. in addition using the authority granted in the act faa recently authorized 11 companies to operate. however find schedule on the ax remaining requirements, many of which are key. for example, faa missed the august deadline for issuing a final rule. these are systems weighing less than 55 pounds. expect to issue a proposed rule soon, it will likely generate a significan

e implicated in and ask themselves, is this the kind of reputation i want for my bank? i hope they take a serious look at what's going on. >> i'm curious as well when you said this whole idea of them not giving an inch. what we hear is all about how there's just been too much forced upon them already to the detriment of healthy capital markets. and to the concerns about liq d liquidity in parts about whether it's the fixed income market, commodity currencies, et cetera. is that just rhetoric, or has there been damage done here? or are there economic factors underlying all this? >> i think there's been incremental progress. i don't want to take away from that. it has forced them to change their business model a bit. i think in a way that makes them for stable and long term is in their best interest, whether they want to admit it or not. i would agree with them there's been far too much bureaucracy and complexity as part of this implementation. we need simpler rules, easier to understand, easier to enforce. the horrific complexity of this has created a lot of compliance c

but implicated only to say that smith was drinking with them. something that smith denied vehemently today. he did admit he was briefly with mcdonald and the alleged victim on the evening in question, though. as he was speaking with the media earlier today. >> as far as it's concerned i was over at ray's house for close to an hour. i didn't drink one thing as far as it goes relating to that i have nothing else to say that's not my issue or my problem. >> what did you do later that -- >> i spent time with my son. >> there you go. and we get to talk about some real sports now. and what a night it is for the stanford cardinal basketball team. a game just complete as they beat one of the nation's best. number nine texas. stanford going at it with jonathan jones in the final moments. in fact, last 25 seconds he hits that clutch jumper against texas to help send the game into overtime. johnny dawkins and company will take a one point lead into the final moments and jason randall has really been lights out for that clutch jumper giving them a three poi

what are the implications of that?>> i think that it's very -- it's a lot of fun to make fun of hollywood and this was very embarrassing for a lot of people in hollywood. that was the initial reaction but i think that this is a very serious thing that the u.s. -- both the u.s. government and the brooder private sector and u.s. should have come to sony's defense and really been much more aggressive in its response. now the white house is waking up but this should have happened days ago because this is a fundamental attack on first amendment rights in this country. if we don't -- if we can't defend against this, we're basically victims of terrorism. >> what can we do about it? >> if it is indeed north korea, put them back on the list of state sponsors of terror. >> taken off by george w. bush. >> absolutely. >> let's go out to asia and get our allies on board. japan is conducting its own negotiations with north korea. we are not presenting a united front -- >> china has we believe is looking turning a blind eye -- it isn

happen until 1995, but it did happen, and now as we're beginning to do church together, it has implicationsety, for mass incarceration, it has itch indications for the racialization of communities and neighborhoods and how racial fear affects policing. i thank god for our police and their protection of us. i pray that they will function in less racial fear and as that happens, we will see less of the kind of injustices and fractures like we've seen with eric garner, i think it's sad, with trayvon martin, i know that wasn't the police, but because we live with so much racial fear, there is a problem on our hands and our nation, and i think the church uniting cross-racially as church like heaven on earth will help make a big difference in racial fear in our country. >> we'll have to see. >> not only black lives matter but all lives matter. pastors, thank you both. >> all lives matter. >> love you brother chris, have a great day. >> bless you, pastor mike. >> have a great day. we'll be right back. turn the trips you have to take, into one you'll never forget. earn triple points when you book w

. >> caller: you mentioned a series of clips and negative implications that would come from these. are those cliffs similar to the ones encountered two years ago where there was so much debate about it that there would be a massive net negative economic implication. are these clips really going to create concrete negative implications or is this one way i think large corporations who are benefiting from extensions of the bush tax cuts are just tripling their ability for profits? >> guest: what i was referring to of course was the interplay in congress with the fiscal cliff and all of that and the government shutdown in all of that political drama that we saw unfold. no one likes that right, and there was a lot of frustration not only in the business world but also i think for just average americans outside of politics. i think there is a lot of frustration. the point that i was trying to make and it's a great question is simply that i don't expect the extenders would create any sort of coalesced over the next few weeks and i don't expect there to be a government shutdown. >> host:

charles: you brought this set before people that i knew but what are the implications for the economy ? >> as you highlight the junk-bond market and has the energy space also though lower market which is a lot of product kept on the balance sheet but the fact is they are getting hurt in there on marginal companies. but to say it is not as big of a concern is i was thinking because the maturity is not near term. they owe money they will borrow more expensive the but the maturity is extended they will not be as hurt as they thought. >> baines have a lot of loans on the books it is almost like.com because they bet on u.s. shale netanyahu in the economy withstand the energy sector? even with that one major sector is in trouble? >> how long can we withstand that kind? the oil and gas extraction it contributes half a percent in the a dual composition of the past four years. if we remove that it is the direct impact will get back to trickle-down effect for every 10 percent reduction production and hiring and investment that is 40 percent of the benefit directly to the consumer. charles: you

but i think that the affects of the case had long range implications. the creation of the naacp litigation strategy to fight for civil right in the rest of the 20th century and more importantly the modern criminal procedure revolution where the supreme court expanded their power in criminal law and redefined what constituted a fair trial. i believe it is important to understand the structure and expertise of the naacp that played the role during the brown civil rights was determined by an earlier set of events that set it down that path. brown didn't just happen. we don't just get civil rights or the modern criminal procedure. we understand miranda versus arizona but we need to understand how the political and constitutional change happened. it was the battle around the racial violence that started the shift of the naacp and their supporters about how to success fullly fight racial injustice in the federal government. the naacp wasted no time using brown for funding their legal department. from 1923-1924 the legal defense fund drew from $120 to $1,058 w

now that we have known the anyict for a few hours now, more information on the implications of this longer term for apple? >> it's a win for apple. were participating in this antitrust sort of thing. it's also in a window into how operating. the new operating of the company, more open and transparent, that sort of thing. jobs made an appearance through video deposition. he died six months after it was taken. it was controversial, apple tried to keep it out. it was a historic look at the company. >> what is your reaction to this decision? how much of a victory is it for apple? important it was an victory for apple. whether or not they used commercial practices to exclude competitors so it could corner a market and maintain a monopoly position. the jury apparently found quickly and resoundingly that apple had not done so. i think it's a big day for apple. >> what other legal challenges is apple facing down the line? what else is coming apple's way? caseere was the e-book that apple lost. it was brought by the united states department of justice after a bench trial. a judge in the federal dis

what implications does it mean for the economy?

how bad is this economic decline and what are the implications of it? >> well, i mean to make the transition i should first say it is sort of interesting to me the russians get to go to crimea and the russians get to go to cuba, so i think we won on that trade. that would be my perspective. and. >> rose: crimea is a perfectly nice play. >> it used to be, getting harder. and the fact that the americans have made a better trade on so many things vis-a-vis russia is very apparent over the course of the last couple of decades, this has been a tough year economically for russia. it would have been a tough year even if putin was the nicest guy we could invite around this table because oil prices have gone down almost 50 percent. >> rose: and that is 70 percent of their economy. >> a little less than that but significant, the majority, and they have not been able to diversify their economy very much since putin has come in place, putin became president, oil is in the teens, shoots up over 100 and going to look like a genius no matter what, goes down to 50 some

from melting glaciers to widespread deforestation and all its implications. with that backdrop, the lima conference was all about charts a road map for a global treaty in paris in a year's time. given the optimism there was before the conference, lima has been a disappointment. it's been saved from failure by some last-minute hustling. there is a lot of work to do in paris 2015 to be successful. nick clark, al jazeera, lima, peru. >>> there's much more ahead here on al jazeera. haiti's prime minister resigns as anti-government protests spread across the country. >>> and a mouse and a mystery. the story of a long-last paints that reappeared in the movies. >> my name is elenor and for the last 25 years i was bernie madoff's secretary. >> an unimaginable story of betrayal. >> they lived this incredible life. it just never occurred to me that they were living on the dime of the clients. >> greed... >> bernie was stealing every nickel but he wasn't trading anything. >> ... and entitlement. >> you took my grandchildren's future away from them. >>> with the come bac

to denounce the nonaligned status could have serious political implications for an already destabilizedn and the vote of 303-8 effectively opens the way to nato membership for ukraine. russia will see as a threat to security and ukraine leaders were determined to scrap its mutual status whatever the reaction from the kremlin. >> translator: today we should all vote for key bill in the current situation. a bill about peace. a bill about reform strategy. a bill about our place in western civilization. this is a bill denouncing ukraine from unaligned status. >> reporter: earlier this year senior ukrainian military officers met with nato commanders on a training exercise in bulgaria and could take years to complete membership to alliance and not all nato countries are in favor but with the fighting between ukraine and separatist rebels east of the country showing no sign of ending 4700 soldiers and civilians have died since an aborted ceasefire was signed in minsk in september and it won't make it easier when russia and rebels sit down with ukraine to try to reinstate another ceasefire and