so, ivan stupak, first he will tell us what is happening in our place military branch, i hope he will appear before us now, and we will ask him, he appeared, thank you very much, mr. ivan, for finding time for us, congratulations, always a pleasure, well, look, the question is, you know, i will be fired from my job if i don't ask you anything about zelensky zaluzhny, i will just be thrown out immediately, that's why i'm asking... apart from speculation, mr. wang, there is something rational in the events of yesterday, that is, the resignation of mr. zaluzhny, so what, what i see and what i read on the networks, when i get there, i don't often i arrive, the shore of the army is empty, and the assyrian new commander-in-chief is not guarding, there is something, but we, we, none of us are there. we know in the stake, we just think that maybe they were near and didn’t hear the words, we don’t think anything is right, it seems that zaluzhnyi really played a very important role, and indeed many operations were successful, and what role did syrsky play, maybe he also performed very important

we will also analyze in detail the column of zaluzhny together with ivan stupak'. analyst and former mr. ivan, welcome to our broadcast. thank you for joining. congratulations, congratulations, thank you for inviting me. i'll start with a political question, first of all, in your opinion, why was this zaluzhnyi column published right now? is this a farewell instruction to the successors? no, wait, this is not his first column, not the first such exit into the public sphere. yes, he appears much less often in the mass media than mr. budanov, for example, or some other political leaders, i have... in the middle of attention among the military, that is, he comes out with his thoughts, and this is normal, that is, he a living person, he shows his thoughts, his thoughts are read at the event, they are listened to. that is, this is a completely valid, normal story, and he does not show any disrespect, for example, to the political leadership or any opposition, he shares his thoughts, it is very fine. if you listen to the versions of western media, then one of the probable reasons for the pr

ivan stupak, a military man, is in touch with us now expert and employee of the service. security of ukraine from 2004 to 2015. mr. ivan, we welcome you to our project together beraber we talk about crimea and everything related to it. glory to ukraine. thank you for the invitation, glory. salam aleikum. salam aleyka. congratulations , i can’t repeat what you said, i’m sorry , we will teach you, we will teach you, that’s what we exist for, actually, ivan, well, a short remark, as if from a military expert, in particular, this loss is a defeat and not just damage, drowning precisely by five magura v5 drones, by the way, just a few days before, it was reported that these drones had been improved somewhat, and it was they that would bring... the forces, or rather, the russian military, in general, a lot of trouble in the black sea, well, no matter how they looked, they were not mistaken, in particular , our developers, the ship went to the bottom, it happened in the area of ​​the southern coast of crimea, that is, well, let's put it this way, it doesn't often happen in such a resort envi

and now we will talk with ivan stupak, a military expert, an employee of the security service of ukraine in 2004-2015. mr. ivan, we welcome you. good morning studio, thank you very much for inviting me. mr. ivan, how did the ukrainian forces have to leave avdiivka, how did this operation go in your opinion, can we say that it was timely and can we say that it was successful. yes, let's talk about such things, i am sure that the military themselves, who are there, should speak. directly at the front, they saw everything, everything that happened, how everything was organized, and they will be able to say their decisive word, and their opinion will be the most correct, because to criticize the style, oh, oh, you are late, oh, that you threw everything there, it is completely wrong, it is not professional, so once again i will leave the opportunity to our to the military to tell how it was, it is clear that we would like to see all the boys and girls leave this semi-encirclement, it is very... unpleasant to see, for me personally, and i think that for all ukrainians, when the russians seize

and the expert of the ukrainian institute of the future, ivan stupak, is in touch with us. how can a change of commander-in-chief at such a time during the war affect ukrainian defense? yes, look, what i want to see personally is that mr. syrsky has at least some plans for the future. development of the army, further optimization of the army, use of those reserves that are available, for example, there are many complaints about the fact that part of the military is in the rear, they do not fight, but receive a large salary, there is a certain injustice, i really want to believe that he will completely rework it, will maximally implement technological means, tech, equipment, novice equipment, and again it is necessary to repeat myself, i did not have time to finish, because... it was mr. zaluzhnyi who recommended mr. zaluzhnyi as his successor, that is , this information is there, and it says a lot, that is, i think that he should quickly pick up management, command and not to lose the positions that we have now, because the russians, unfortunately, we must note, are very ac

yes, well, we will now include in our marathon ivan stupak, a military expert, an employee of the security service of ukraine in 2004-15. glory to ukraine, mr. ivan. welcome to grom slava studio. well, yesterday, the president of ukraine held a meeting of the supreme commander-in-chief in an updated composition. yes, priority issues remain unchanged. fronts and protection of frontline regions, people and critical infrastructure from russian aerial terror, i quote directly. reports of the chief of the syrian army and the chief of the general staff bargelevich, representatives of intelligence, commanders of the operational-strategic groups of troops, avdiivsk, kupinsk-south, providing the army with all the necessary shells, drones. rap, reports of energy experts, viguls, military-civilian administrations. to the president of ukraine also reported that a decision was made to increase the number and capabilities of mobile fire groups. well, let's go now avdiivka, kupyansk, then pivden. why say, well, it's difficult, well, once again, you and i are getting involved, and it's difficult, difficul

is very important for us, and above all it is very important for our armed forces. we are adding ivan stupak a military expert and sbu employee from 2004 to 2015, to yeter. mr. ivan, i am glad to see you, i traditionally welcome you to our air. this is very, very nice, thank you invited let's maybe start with what's happening on the front lines right now. well, the institute for the study of war made such a rather pessimistic forecast, as far as i'm concerned, they note that russia has regained the strategic initiative on the battlefield. and the institute for the study of war believes that russian troops have regained the initiative in the entire theater of operations and will be able to conduct offensive operations whenever and wherever they want, as long as they receive the initiative, this is what the institute for the study of war actually said, and it was parallel to this macron's statement that maybe one day such a moment will come when ukraine will have to help not only with weapons, but also with troops, and this moustache. putin's spokesman piskov has already said that this will be

ask putin what we should pay attention to in that interview, we will also talk about this with ivan stupaktary an expert, an employee of the security service of ukraine. mr. ivan, we are glad to see you. yes, welcome to the studio, thank you very much for the invitation. mr. ivan, as a matter of fact, yesterday's dismissal and immediate appointment. what should we expect, what was your reaction, what do you expect from mr. syrsky? let's wait a month, give the person the opportunity to show himself, let him show his team, let him appoint those people whom he will be allowed to appoint, who will be his personal people, who will be appointed by respectable people, and let's see for the first steps, and let's do it , i think that on at the beginning of march , we can already understand the full picture from our military, the style of management, what kind of management it is, how promising it is... our military will be the first to experience it and we will see, perhaps, some first results, both in the positive direction and in negative, well, everything can be predicted, but i saw the reactio

yes, and let's remind you that ivan stupak, a military expert, ex-employee of the security service ofne, was on the call from the studio. we will now take a short break, after which we will remind you that the russian federation, and this is not a joke, will sue ukraine in international courts for the blockade, the energy blockade of crimea in 2015, and ayder muzhdabayev. along with our next guest like no other knows what it is about, let's talk, there is such a thing. there are discounts on ururolysan of 15% in pharmacies psyllanyk, pam and oskad. there are discounts on helpex - 20% in travel, fam and savings pharmacies. according to the results of january, the espresso tv channel continues to hold the first position among information broadcasting channels. for the 10th month in a row, we are the first. greetings, it's news time on the tv channel. this november we turned 10 years old. we. new design, sound, we continue the saturday political club khrystyna yatskiv and vitaly portnikov. our values ​​and ukrainian point of view remain unchanged. watch out for espresso update and thank

well, today we have ivan, our guest is ivan stupak, a military expert, an employee of the sbu. 2004-2015congratulate you, mr. ivan, i congratulate you, judge , thank you for inviting me, ah, thank you for joining us, and you know, well , it seems to me that we have already talked a lot about how what happened, what happened, but simply, in your opinion, what are the possible one or two main reasons that led to the loss of avdiivka, the lack of provision of our eyelashes. shells and the presence of russian aviation, that is, these two factors, which , in my opinion, they did not provoke, but led to the fact that i had to leave this city, i think that if the supply of shells was at a much better level, plus the absence of russian aviation, well, of course with the help of our military, then of course the situation was much better and it was possible to keep the widow, well, it seems to me that, well, i won't say there for years, but well, on a certain horizon. events so precisely, they could not agree in the united states on aid to ukraine, the shells did not arrive in the amount that was

olyarnyk and antin borkovskyi of espresso live studios and are ready to add our first speaker, ivan stupak a military expert and sbu employee from 2004 to 2015. mr. ivan, we traditionally welcome you to espresso. congratulations, traditionally you are a studio, thank you very much for inviting me. so, mr. ivan, we have successful attacks by our drones or other means that work very successfully not only on the territory of the russian federation, but also on the territory of the temporarily occupied crimea. and we received information that yesterday and at the airfield something was exploding in belbek, something was happening, and there is also information that gur conducted a successful operation in the crimea and sank a missile boat and... novitz. and in fact, we have the previous days, very successful, hits and hits in st. petersburg. i would like your assessment of whether this leaky russian air defense system can no longer cope with the means that our brave boys and girls already have. yes, let's start from the end, let's start with ivanovets, it's just such a christian story, i have

where prisoners, and we will not show them to you, what is the difference, of course, thank you, ivan stupakemployee of the sbu from 2004 to 2015 was in touch with us, now we will take a short break and after it we will return to our studios, professional anti-fix cream is... extra-strong fixation for all types of dentures, applied to wet dentures, protefix, german quality at an affordable price, there are discounts on bronchialik 10% in pharmacies, plantain, bam and savings. attention, total sale on unpack tv, dutyk and pannochka only from 699 hryvnias. if you are looking for a comfortable and high-quality pair of shoes for the winter, rather dial the number on the screen. dutyk and panochka are a new level of real comfort, put on and forget. the increased width and increased fullness will suit even special legs. dutyki panchka is not just a fashionable pair of shoes, it is comfort in every detail. the increased height provides protection from the cold, even in severe weather. ekofur insulation and non-freezing sole perfectly keep heat down to -20°, and the top is made of water-repellent ra

in particular, captain of the first rank of the reserve of the navy of ukraine andriy ryzhenko, ivan stupaklitary man, is in touch with us now. an employee of the security service of ukraine from 2004 to 15. mr. ivan, we welcome you to our project together beraber we talk about crimea and everything related to it. glory ukraine. thank you for inviting me. salam alaikum. cheers, can't repeat what you said. we will teach you. we will teach, that's why we exist. ivan, well, a short remark, as from a military expert, in particular, this is a loss, this is a defeat and... not just a defeat, the sinking of five magura v5 drones. by the way, just a few days before , it was reported that these drones had been improved somewhat, and it was they that would bring the forces, or rather the russian military, a lot of trouble in the black sea in general. developers, the ship went down, it happened in the district. the southern coast of crimea, that is, well, let's put it this way, it doesn't often happen precisely in such a resort environment, rather it always concerns the western, northwestern part, the

of the armed forces of ukraine, will be questioned further, in the meantime, we will talk with ivan stupakmilitary expert, an employee of the security service of ukraine in the past, already with us, mr. ivan, we welcome you, yes, good studio, congratulations, thank you for inviting me, mr. ivan, i started one of your knowledge and activities, look, but not... recently, the sbu detained and showed us a snitch who rented an apartment near the airport, and in the report you handed everything over to the russian-fascist occupiers and special services information, now we look at it fresh, the security service just captured the uncle, and this uncle is not easy, he is a design engineer in mykolaiv, and this is the ukroboronprom enterprise, and he. he was caught in the act when he was just transferring, copying and transferring technical documentation, which is secret military developments of ukraine, and in this case the key word is the engineer of ukroboronprom, we knew that at the beginning of the invasion there were a lot of moles and agents, it turns out that two years have passed, they are

well, today we have ivan as our guest, ivan stupak, a military expert, an employee of the sbu in 2004 i congratulate you , mr. ivan, congratulations, judge, thank you for inviting me, and thank you for joining us, and you know , well, it seems to me that we have already talked a lot on the air about how it happened, what happened, but just in your opinion, which on here are perhaps one or two main reasons that... nevertheless led to the loss of avdiyivka, the lack of provision of our troops with shells and the presence of russian aviation, that is , these two factors, which, in my opinion, they did not provoke, but led to the fact that well , i had to leave this city. i think that if the provision of shells was at a much better level, plus the absence of russian aviation, well, of course with the help of our military, then of course the situation would be much better and it is possible... to hold povdiivka, well, it seems to me that i will not say there for years, but, well, on a certain horizon of events, for sure, they could not agree in the united states on aid to ukraine, the shel

ivan, thank you to you, ivan stupak, a military expert, an employee of the security service of ukraine, an employee of the security service of ukraine was in touch with us in 2004-2015, we are going for a short break, andriy said he would show one caricature, but he forgot. so we will show you this caricature later a caricature based on the interview of putin to tucker carlson to the odious american journalist, stay with us, tired of heavy and bulky saws, then the strong saw from rozpakuy tv is just for you, with it you can cut trees and bushes with ease , its so comfortable can also be used for carpentry, it is the perfect tool for your home. garden, and the price is only from uah 1,499. a reliable battery is also included. just call now and order. free delivery is available. check with the consultants: you can cut heaters, cut a beam, chop firewood, all this in one movement, with a strong saw. just look how quickly she copes, even with thick branches. once it is ready, and unlike standard saws, it is so convenient to use it in hard-to-reach places. in power sets. a wrench and a screw

and let us remind you that ivan stupak, a military expert, ex-employee of the security service of ukrainell now take a short break , after which we will remind you that the russian federation, and this is not a joke, will be sued, sued against ukraine in international courts for the blockade, the energy blockade of crimea in 2015 and ayder muzhdabaev, together with our next guest, as no one knows what it is about, let's talk, there is such a thing. laughter, physical activity, sneeze. even during such a small load, urinary incontinence can make itself felt. feminost uro helped me. thanks to its natural ingredients, feminost uro helps restore control over urination both during the day and at night. feminism. uuro: urination under control. ask at pharmacies. there are discounts on pairs of villages of 20% in podorozhnyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. there are discounts on icelandika lozenges, 15% in the pharmacies of plantain bam and oskad. there are discounts on mukaltin of 15% in psyllanyk, pam and oskad pharmacies. according to the results of january , the espresso tv channel continues. thi