i worked with jacky thornhill on these issues. and we moved them forward. i was responsive to her report that the trash enclosure was used as storage. so -- i would not say my response providing details of the building or lease -- you know, i would not say private information of the restaurant the new restaurant owner but -- we had a dialogue throughout the whole process. >> thank you. >> thank you. we will hear from public works. mr. rivera you have 3 minutes. >> thank you i don't have much to add. just to bring up the fact again that we have no documented evidence showing use of the enclosure since 2015. after the original restaurant closed. it is not being used as a trash enclosure. and -- this point we than businesses remodel or -- remodel the interior and worth take another look at it. revoke the upon current the existing encroachment and look in a new permit. that's all we have for now. >> thank you. we have a question from president swig. >> when there is a renewal of encroachment or requirement to renew the encroachment permit, do you look at it as