we are back with dan heninger, jason riley and kyle peterson. let's look at the data first. how much support is harris losing among black voters out there that you see? >> typically democrats went around 85%, 95% under obama, over 90%. paris in the mid-70, this is dangerous territory for democrats. not just nationally a problem. in georgia blacks cast 30%, around 20%. around 12% and 13%, pennsylvania% and 13%, pennsylvania around 10%. those are close states. just losing a little bit of this black vote could cost the democrats. paul: to what do you describe this shift? >> quite simply blacks were doing better economically under trump than they have been doing under biden. the facts, whether you are talking about employment, whether you are talking about wages, they had more money in their pockets, more employment opportunities and they remembers that. it wasn't that long ago. biden's record cannot compete with trump's record when it comes to these matters. offering giveaways like subsidies, i will let kamala harris on a secret. we are doing well on the cannabis industry witho

paul: let's bring in dan heninger and jason riley and editorial board member kyle peterson. what do you make of the vice president's answer on what she would do differently than joe biden? >> don't hear an answer which is part of the problem that she has. you would think that is a question she would anticipate and have an answer to. she was asked multiple times in these interviews and keeps dodging. her problem is joe biden was going to lose this election. he is unpopular and she has not done enough to distinguish herself from the record. 2 thirds of the country thinks we are heading in the wrong direction. the other problem she has is retrospectively donald trump's presidential approval rating is higher than it ever was when he was president and she's dealing with is that. it is clear, people know they were doing better under donald trump than they were doing under biden and she can't explain why they would continue with the biden, with her, continuing for biden. she can't justify that. paul: this is a real puzzle, she says i'm different, but there's not a single issue of a

this is from jason riley, lincoln's falter i think it's being used politically to get those votes. it makes me angry. i feel like they're using my daughter's name and she was much better than that as she should be raised up for the person that she is. she was an angel. why couldn't kamala harris say something like that that human eyes, her concern but the loss and then called out those who would exploit it isn't interesting point and there. i think first of all, she gets this question every single time that anybody comes to her with a microphone and the default to while trump killed the immigration bill that honestly does doesn't seem to be working for the folks who immigration is their number one issue and fox has certainly been a part of that message machine and that's their number one issue right now. that's not a movable voter at this moment, people have made up their mind already. it's 20 days before an election her going on fox's is not about changing people's minds about how they feel about voting based on immigration. it's about showing people that she can be tough. she is

this is from jason riley, lincoln's father i think it's being used politically to get those votes. it makes me angry. i feel like they're using my daughter's name and she was much better than that as she should be raised up for the person that she is. she was an angel. why couldn't kamala harris say something like that that human eyes her concern for the loss and then called out those who would exploit it is an interesting point. there. i think first of all, she gets this question every single time that anybody comes to her with microphone and the default to while trump killed the immigration bell that honestly doesn't seem to be working for the folks who immigration is their number one issue. and fox has certainly been a part of that message machine and that's their number one issue right now that's not a movable voter at this moment, people have made up their mind already. it's 20 days before an election. her go on fox's is not about changing people's minds about how they feel about voting based on immigration. it's about showing people that she can be tough. she is a leader and