evs are getting a boost and clean energy names like first solar are also green on the knows but jay timmons says the final bill will stifle manufacturing investment in this country he joins us in a first on cnbc interview. you guys have been among the most vocal, you and private equity looks like they got their way, you did not, jay is it because of this 15% minimum tax on booked profits? >> yeah, so, sara, that obviously is going to be a drag on the economy i will say this, though. we were very successful in getting immediate expensing, if you will, accelerated depreciation protected from this minimum tax. senator kyrsten sinema from arizona was incredibly important in that effort and she helped us get that done. but the overall bill is going to cost the economy it is very and aptly named i know you're going to be talking to somebody else about that right after this. unfortunately, it's just going to suck money out of the economy that could be used by manufacturers for investment, job creation and most importantly right now wage growth >> so you mentioned it did -- you got that very key de