. >> good evening, >> you can move it down >> thank you >> my name is jennifer chung, i am speaking on behalf of my parents who are in the podium for this appeal. because they don't really speak english. we have an appealed a number of permits on this construction as the contractor has not acted in good faith regarding the planning process and the neighbors. in our early appeal, we documented we did not pay attention to the work until we realized that the work encroached to my parents' property and so we started to look into their work and then we found out that the contractor conducted work well beyond his original permits and notification, such as extended the full rear supporting wall further back to gain more space. and extended the back and relocate the rear stair and do a deck on the third floor, above the kitchen extension and also on the third floor, a change one window into two windows, and added an outside door. to access the newly built deck. they are doing the massive change and they built the new foundation which we have questioned what are the permits that are on file, it