motion. >> cooper. >> no. >> hernandez gil. >> aye. >> member ho. >> no. >> member chasel lee. >> no. >> jeremy. >> aye. >> townsend. >> no. >> there's fouries and five nos with member castillon, member cooper, member ho, member chasel lee and townsend in descend. >> now, that motion fails, mr. chair. you want to bang the gavel. there were questions that came in while i was stating -- while i was taking the roll on that one, do you need for me to restate the motion you took the vote on? >> i think we understood. >> it's okay. we're fine. >> okay. >> now the next motion offered was to undo a portion of what was on the motion that just happened a second agency. is that motion still offered by the mover? >> yes. >> so, this is to accept the map as it is on the screen right now which has had the addition of the western addition and the panhandle to district 5 removed from it. is everyone clear on that? >> did you stay moved. >> moved by chasel and seconded by yourself. >> i wanted to hear you right? >> yes. >> so i understand, this is the map that is moved for consideration at tomorrow's line drawi

jeremy lee. >> so many things to comment on. first of all, i want to say to member chaseel lee and councilmember ho for advocating. i understand your position and my aunt lives on university street. i have family that lives out there. and i get what it feels like to have a community, to be a part of a community that is so isolated so and so -- so neglected for the city so thank you for your advocacy. in terms of the map before us, you know, i want to thank chasel lee for working out the percentages and listening to district 5 we heard from that were heartbroken that their being moved out of their community. but you know, to member hernandez gil and the area around the tenderloin, you know, i just truly feel that the tenderloin needs to be in district 6. i appreciate what member chasel, what you did with putting together philippine that and the (indiscernible) district and trans cultural district. like yourself, i was admonished of it for not speaking up about the other minorities that i hold. i'm a queer man and it's something i'

member cooper and jeremy lee. 'd like to note only have the four people criticized the process but member lee said we have lost the publics trust and townsend said earlier in the meeting he failed as a lead ir. leader. i appreciate that. that's six out of the nine of you. two-thirds of you recognize something was done wrong. take more time to produce a map that takes the community input. it's better to be late than have a terrible sham map. >> thank you for your comments. next speaker please. >> good evening, i live-in district two. i was sadden by the vote by this committee to adopt this map. i understand why they call this a warfare map. the communities most impacted have had representation here time and time again to make comments in defense of their communities. time is a justice issue. we know black and brown community members have to constantly advocate for their basic mu man rights. you have to fight to be seen. they are not seen because the map would like different. to me, the map is inmu inhumane. it's con

it looks really weird. >> yeah. >> let's adopt it. >> member jeremy lee? >> can we see the demographic data for one b.? >> we would need to adopt this change or pause it for now. >> are we agreeing to adopt that? >> for the purpose of the demographics, i am fine like that. >> are you able to compare the current district one and the population changes? >> i believe so. >> thank you. >> can you please clarify what demographic you would like to look at? there's race and ethnicity for total population. >> all three

member jeremy lee. >> lee: since last night i have had conversations with district 5 office, chinatowneaders as well as members of s.f. rising. >> thank you. member cooper. >> cooper: thank you. yes, since last night, i had conversations with residents of d5 and the d6 office. thanks. >> thank you. mr. -- once again, are there any callers in the queue, mr. clerk >> clerk: first, let's see if there's anyone in the room to give public comment on the member reports. not seeing any. we did have access instructions just a few moments ago. if there's anyone who is connected remotely who has comment for the task force member reports, can we be connected to any of them. >> mr. clerk -- we have one caller in the queue. >> clerk: can we please be connected. >> caller: hello. >> clerk: hello. >> caller: hi. yes, can you hear me? >> clerk: yes, we can. >> caller: yes, i am brenda bales and i wanted to just say that i was a little bit disappointed in the report that not more of the commissioners have been speaking or communicating with residents of d10. that's my only comment right now. >> clerk: t

. >> jeremy lee >> present. >> gill. >> present. >> pierce. >> present. >> towns towns absent. >> member ho. >> present. >> member cooper. >> present. >> member lee. >> present. >> vice chair reiner. >> madam there is a quorum. >> thank you, mr. clerk. call item 2. >> agenda item 2 is mapping. members of task force discussion maps developed and committed lie data and research at the task force direction and give further instructions by agreement may move to line drawing if they decide this is a discussion and action item will be taking public comment as part of this discussion. >> thank you. mr. clerk. mr. chasel lee. >> thank you. thank you. mad am chair >> can you bring up the presentation, please. >> thank you. i like to thank the public for participating in this process and look forward to continued participation this this process. before we get in mapping and public comment -- i will like to start with a small presentation. will basicings san francisco has 11 districts and redistricting is the process of adjusting the bound easier to be compliant with redistricts every 10 years afte

my name is jeremy lee, and i'm calling on behalf of the rose pak democratic club. i urge you to support the petition to revoke the petition for the portsmouth square club. chinatown is the most dense neighborhood in the u.s. west of manhattan. many live in tiny s.r.o.s, and portsmouth square is the only respite they have from their cramped living spaces. they have no where else to go. the hilton hotel controls access to the bridge to make a profit by holding events on it. let our community have control over its public spaces. let us determine what our community needs and how our community should look like. our immigrants, our s.r.o. families, our monolingual seniors like the v.p.s. members sitting before you need more open space, they need to protect every square foot their community has. please support the petition to revoke the permit for the portsmouth square bridge. thank you. >> clerk: can we have the next caller, please. >> hi, all. i'm the [indiscernible] [speaking cantonese language] >> let me translate his speech. i'm [indiscernible] to ask for your suppor

my name is jeremy lee, and i'm calling on behalf of the rose pak democratic club. i urge you to support the petition to revoke the petition for the portsmouth square club. chinatown is the most dense neighborhood in the u.s. west of manhattan. many live in tiny s.r.o.s, and portsmouth square is the only respite they have from their cramped living spaces. they have no where else to go. the hilton hotel controls access to the bridge to make a profit by holding events on it. let our community have control over its public spaces. let us determine what our community needs and how our community should look like. our immigrants, our s.r.o. families, our monolingual seniors like the v.p.s. members sitting before you need more open space, they need to protect every square foot their community has. please support the petition to revoke the permit for the portsmouth square bridge. thank you. >> clerk: can we have the next caller, please. >> hi, all. i'm the [indiscernible] [speaking cantonese language] >> let me translate his speech. i'm [indiscernible] to ask for your suppor

the motion was offered by chasel lee and seconded by member cooper on that motion member jeremy lee >> aye. >> member pierce. >> aye. >> vice chair reiner. >> aye. >> member castillon y. aye. why member cooper >> aye. >> member hernandez-gil. >> aye. >> member ho. >> aye >> member chasel lee. >> aye >> chair townsend. >> aye. mr. chair there are 9 aye's. >> thank you. >> on adopting. >> matters adopted. mr. clerk. mr. chair. i believe. >> mr. chair. why mr. lee >> question for clarification. i believe q2 has to submit the final maps to fix stuff for inclusion in the final report is this correct? >> i believe the motion adopted did include that? >> yes, i do believe had -- you know what i will check but i'm sure that whatever process was followed left time will be followed this time in the final maps. >> okay. >> >> if it helpful and past practice dictates futures results we receive the maps sooner than may fifth. >> thank you. i like to add i had conversations with q2 and they have been full y prepared to do that all along. i was surprised not to see that in there. i want to make sure

jeremy lee. why good morning and to the members of the public. this is it. our final meeting.we started redistricting in mid-september 2021. 7 months we set out a process to listen to the public and needs of redrawing district lines. in the beginning i know that we all set nought good faith to conduct a press that was fair, consistent and transparent. but -- by today it is my belief this body fell short. if i could chose one word to summarize our process i would describe it as crew. crew not because we had to make tough choice we agenda 've understood that from the beginning it was crew we made hard decisions reversed them and reversed them again did so on multiple occasions. we will time we reversed we did not offer an explanation to the public. did not guide them through our rational. as if we expected the public to accept this giving them when they wanted and then taking it away was just part of the process. for example. on march 25 the tl and western edition in one district a move no one advocated for. on april second the community responded. heard if 182 speak and ares 2

when you hear your name indicate you are penitentiary member jeremy lee. >> present. >> >> member piercends. >> present. >> cooper. >> present. >> chasel lee. >> we have all 9 members present. i believe you may have mr. announce ams.

when you hear your name indicate you are penitentiary member jeremy lee. >> present. >> >> member pierce >> present. >> >> chair towns ends. >> present. >> cooper. >> present. >> chasel lee. >> we have all 9 members present. i believe you may have mr. announce ams. mr. chair we the redistricting task force allowing in person attendance and public comment while promoting public comment via phone. recognized that public access is essential and will take public comment first public comment on each item. those in personal be allowed to speak first then those waiting on the 27 line or web ex. the call number is 655-0001. you will be prompted enter a meeting erickson d, today is 24820649460. after you entered the meeting id press pound 2 times to connect. when you are connected you hear the meeting discussion your line will be muted and in listening mode. when your item come up in public comment is called. those in person in room 408 will lineup on this side of the room i'm pointing out with my left hand. those who are on the phone or connected through callers can raise hands by dialing star 3

jeremy lee. >> just a very brief -- i checked that lot and it has 13 people. it's a pretty easy add. [laughter] >> it's between venice and polk. >> okay. >> the greatest problem i have is that when comes to district 6, the people have been excellent at telling us what they want and from every neighborhood, we've heard they don't want anything to change. every neighborhood wants to stay in 6 and which all of our implies that that's impossible. it hasn't made a difference and we've got to cut something and the residents of 6 have not been great at telling us what they think even if it meant the ones who want to say, they have to say you've got to go. we have heard very little, so we're left on our own to make the decisions we have to make. that something absolutely has to change and as difficult as it may be and dealt because of the passion we have heard about people and their district, we have to be about the business of cutting something, so i will leave it to all of you surgents that i work with because we're not going to get to any other district until we do