along making billions and billions of dollars in dirty energy according to pay our man and author jim hogan the success of this echo chamber has nothing to do with science and everything to do with spin it was a media campaign they wanted to create doubt in the minds of journalists they wanted to create doubt in the minds of the public and your average person will never know they just see some articulate guy needn't be a scientist basically being shills for industry people like fred singer he was a guy who worked for tobacco now works on climate change but because they're wearing a lab coat and they have a ph d. people believe them. i tracked down singer in washington where he was briefing senate staffers on the scientific reasons why they support the cap and trade bill it's just that. through the want that's not correct that's been cooling since not everyone has the function of his to. use to disseminate the quasi science of people like dr singh or. the science is not finished the debate is not over as he left to support this legislation would tell you i think global warming is a complete