of the book from time immemorial the origins of the arab jewish arab conflict over palestine by joan peters that came out in the i think in the mid eighty's and it's been completely debunked by scholars ok and even people in israel will say it's just fiction but when we look at the presidential contenders that's what they have joan peters just in the twenty first century i mean newt gingrich is a very good example i mean how is that happened was so much. research and studies and effort into studying this conflict you get this cartoonish view in media and by people who are supposed to be you know going to be running the free world i mean i guess going back to what i said earlier i mean this is just outrageous or is it just done purposely it's just to pander to the lobby. well i think it is done purposefully and but i would definitely quibble with the idea that it's pandering to a lobby i think that she will was on to something with the idea that the lobby is the american population it i think the problem here is that the republicans are sort of trying to split the democratic party i mean of