victoria nuland hero of azovstalia svyatoslav kalina palamar deputy secretary general of nato more joanariters and historians timothy snyder and apple bound e-e well-known military diplomats world and ukrainian figures and today we continue our dialogues so we start new series of our online discussions i am proud and i am pleased to present to you our speakers today, thank you, gentlemen , why are you with us today? first, let me introduce general david petraeus, a four-star general of the united states army, former director of the central intelligence agency , ambassador john gerps, director of the eurasian center of the council for atlantic studies and former us ambassador to ukraine, mr. arseniy yatsenyuk, chairman of the kyiv security forum and former prime minister of ukraine. thank you all for participating in this interesting online discussion called the struggle for ukraine, russia's aggressive war in ukraine has been going on for 8 months. putin did not achieve what he wanted to achieve. he did not achieve any of his goals, but he increased the progress of ukraine in the territo