jody harding fourteen years for the minister for education has said his department is considering today's ruling marie quinn said the judgment by the european court of human rights watch significant indications that he was consulting with the attorney general and other campaign as tough as campaigners have called on the department's to live up to its morrow responsibility for easter by france. when things go wrong in either sleuth who was responsible even though it comes to muslims pays teaches the states has long argued that the buck stops with the school patron usually the milk of catholic bishops the kiwis o'keefe was convinced the state was responsible for fifteen years he puts the state through the irish courts risking even the loss of her home she announced as every turn. it's straight to fight it. two young children and effect that if anything happens. i took up stones. and for taking stakes in her role as the head in my case tonight's any response that is sick. no binding reloading the european court of human rights has said she was right for her and her family and had this to you

jody harding fourteen years for muscle muscle this even more of course the mind but to one two a time when a day full of team. mcguinty the ch ch the hour. err err. marvel each of my duties will pull you to suffer from. the young adults affected. in a country that has to take attendance in conflict with little or no credit to me because this is only a small number that would be paid up to the basket. according to cable. i couldn't have picked the development of the gospel in kochi. more than two my second born and raised in mogadishu police holidays to the uk has returned to his country to perform a life changing. i executed. so what's inside the international medical organization that stands on twenty eight or any sense of duty said the man and his team in the form content of the haitian student in the future. the unit unnoticed by mrs. and that includes. then two hundred it is this. i decided on this is this going soon. and oh i sneeze. this is. this piece. for me so my life is a daily struggle. if you're blind the couple becomes even more you cannot go to school oh what a time and

jodi hernandez is live where the family is pleading for some help. >> reporter: jessica, what happened to this 82 year old is really hard to believe. police here in oakland say someone beat up this senior nearly to death. tonight his family is making an emotional plea for help. >> he's a hard-workingman. and he's a, you know, really responsible father. and now he's in the hospital. >> reporter: she's heartsick at what her father's had to endure, the 82 year old has been in critical condition since christmas eve when he was brutally beaten just two blocks from his oakland home. >> we know that he was walking in his neighborhood, around 11:00, 11:30 at night when he was assaulted. he has multiple facial fractures and broken ribs. >> reporter: he is a father of seven and grandfather of 13, can't eat or talk. tonight his family is pleading with the public to help them identify who's done this to the head of their family. >> it's important to let us know and why an 82 year old man. >> we want to find out who's responsible for this, and we want to remove them from our veets. >> reporter: police say whoever's responsible for this is clear

jodi? >> reporter: those at state's financial picture has changed dramatically. the governor says that is not the green light to open the checkbook. while some agree some are lobbying hard to spread the wealth. >> california has a strong budget. it is a balanced budget, but it is by no means a budget free from liabilities. >> reporter: governor jerry brown says california's getting back on track, but despite this state's surplus in revenue, he says it's not time to go on a spending frenzy. >> for this year, there's very good news. good news in the fiscal stability and resources available for the state of california, but also cautionary warnings that by no means are we out of the wilderness. >> reporter: the governor outlined what he called a prudent budget, one that calls for stashing away money in the state's rainy day fund and tackling california's wall of debt but also earmarked $10 billion for education. >> after years of drought and cut backs and pink slips for the teachers, we're finally able to provide a substantial amount of new money for all the schools in california. >> it's a great conversation to be able to have. how do i spend my new money as opposed to wha

. >> how hard was it to get mr. french from buffy, jody and sissy? >> i actually used lurch for awhile. >> lurch was a butler? >> lurch was a butler. thank you very much. >> houp cousin it? how about cousin it? >> came to make a lot of squeaky noises. we've got to talk about former secretary of defense's book. it is explosive. >> we've been talking a lot about the cold weather and snow. that resulted in a deadly avalanche in the state of colorado taking a tragic twist this morning. we're learning the 24-year-old killed outside the resort is the grandson of the resort founder. tony seebert and three others were skiing the back country when the avalanche occurred. his death is the fifth in the rocky mountain region in the past two weeks. and that can be so dangerous. >>> we are learning new information this morning about a horrific crime. the former miss venezuela and her ex-husband were shot dead in front of their five-year-old daughter. police are saying a sharp object was placed in the road in venezuela and this caused her car to get a flat tire. tw