along this path do you think the rate of violence could get worse if it isn't seen as child process joe manchin us of illness is to. sampson the self. quoting buddha a prop is the stance of the food each. going to insist. upon me his sons my scripts marches ones or masses which just. as the fires continued in brazil also narrow took the stage at the u.n. general assembly in september defending his response to the crisis they are not no with stuff still there for us throughout the evening course will be the feel of full coverage is major loss i mean it's a major. and took aim at other countries saying the amazon was presumes to use violence death as philosophers mortal bodies easier judge of the embark corners me just as the media if you both told you former there is this pay towards the. goal in your earliest. version not a kill you know that my thought get out our north us a bit and here. the president why have you weakened over certain protection and the imus on we made repeated requests to present both scenarios office for an interview but were told he was unavailable there is no doubt. that

. >> joe manchin and if my memory is correct, in every county in west virginia. >> the other new englanderelizabeth warnings figuring out how to pay for medicare for all but admitted could cost millions of jobs. >> this is part of the cost issue. and should be part of a cost plan. >> reporter: that means warren as plan for healthcare could be similar to hillary clinton's plant renewable energy. >> we will put a lot of coal miners and coal companies out of business. >> clinton could still join the field but it is not clear if kamala harris will be long. they have to do better than the candidate who won 13 million primary votes and is running again. >> we are not just running against one person but against 19 others, a different dynamic. >> reporter: sanders like biden is arguing age is an asset, because it is experience. biden revealed how much ground he covered in his career telling caucus goers his amtrak rides at up to 2.3 million. in newcastle, new hampshire, peter doocy. >> the time is half past the top of the hour. a new face of terror, isis named a new leader after the death of abu b

and joe manchin. i thought doug jones will probably be in a senate fight against session.hey will talk about we tried to impeach trump in alabama. are these red state democrats, what are they going to tell their people? even the "new york times" wrote about this today saying they will have trouble.op >> it's not just the red states. it's all the swing states where people carry about their pocketbooks and like the fact that president got the economy going again. they are seeing higher wages and democrats are talking about impeaching the president over a whistleblower they are hiding from the public who heard that was not withhold. the facts are on the president's side. >> laura: doug, the 2020 field isen looking weak. we are hearing more and more of this from a familiar voice. >> are you going to run again? >> no. >> in a few days i won't open my newspaper? >> i never say never. i am under enormous pressure from many, many people to think about it. that's not in my plans. >> laura: what is your advice to your former boss? >> my advice would be go home, close the door. shut

. >> i was talking to joe manchin the other day and he was talking about it, we are nowhere close. republicans don't like the idea government needs to be involved. we are never getting to carbon sequestration at a rate that's important without government because it is moon shot level stuff, right? we would have to have plants on every corner for the next 50 years. >> and it is a misnomer to think there's no government. we are talking about limited government and the appropriate role for government. i think that's what we will start to see with more republicans engaging on the issue of solving climate change. what is the appropriate role for government? now that we have republicans wanting to come to the table, we will start to have a solid discussion that hopefully leads us to serious results. >> well, let's hope they come to the table, and if they do let us know. we would be happy to talk to them about climate change solutions. heather reams is with citizens for response solutions, the executive director of that organization. thanks for watching "velshi & ruhle." i will see you ba

if they flip the senate to democrats that a chuck schumer led democratic senate with people like joe manchine going to support this plan. warren and sanders -- ezra klein wrote this and i agree, they're saying forget this idea of compromise. forget this idea of trying to work with the insurance companies and do things in a sort of collaborative way. they want to bulldoze over the corporations and everyone else and get this through. >> bret: jonah, beto o'rourke steps down. it's hard to believe that andrew yang, john delany are still in the race but beto o'rourke with all his vaunted p.r. at the beginning of the campaign is out. >> it would take a heart of stone not to laugh. the basic problem with beto is that he more than anybody else believed his press coverage whechs running -- when he was running against ted cruz. when the national press wanted cruz to lose. he believed he was this robert f. kennedy messianic figure and every time it was proven that he wasn't he tripled and quadrupled on his rapid onset woke dementia and went even crazier to the left and got no traction because he wasn't

joe manchin says he's not voting to get rid of the president, three republicans vote to say they are, this is going nowhere. and ultimately who is going to hurt? it's going to help democrats who voted against impeachment in the house and you already see it with congressman jeff andrew who already has a primary opponent. this will have as much electoral disruption on the democratic side. >> jessica: i'm not sure about that for house democrats, it's interesting that censure is creeping up. that's one person, there are hundreds of them on the record saying they want to go forward with the inquiry and take the boat. we will see if nancy calls the vote. mark penn also went to the white house it hard to president trump about how bob mueller and the whole investigation was a deep state coup. this is not representative of democrats. mark penn and andy stein have nothing to do with the base of our party or where we are ideologically. >> melissa: i'm just wondering, do you think it's good advice? >> jessica: it's captain obvious advice. listen to lindsey graham, you see that video of him crying

robin, one of the things we saw yesterday was jo joe manchin wan with neil cavuto and if he said if bernied trump, he would not vote for bernie sanders. that hurts. >> that does hurt. i've said similar things. bernie pledged he would not go back to being an independent after 2016 and he did. and he broke his promise. we haven't forgotten. my party is stubborn. if there's one thing i can say in all honesty, it's that we're yostubborn. so i understand. cheryl: i have to bring this up. a democrat out of california, congresswoman porter, came to the vote yesterday dressed as batwoman. when asked about it, she said i'm dressed up as bat girl. republicans jumped all over her, saying it shows the democrats don't take the impeachment inquiry seriously. your response. >> the impeachment inquiry is an embarrassment and the congresswoman is an embarrassment to the american people and they should be ashamed of what's going on and so should she. that's why you're seeing the american people supporting the president. cheryl: ted, robin, david, great discussion as always l. thank you for getting you early

pass medicare for all and there are real realtis, because you are dealing with amy klobuchar and joe manchiners to sign for medicare for all, and so our colleague asked would you be willing to primary democrats who are opposed to medicare for all, and she said no, and then i followed up the senator from massachusetts and i said, how then do you make medicare for all a reality if you are dealing with the senators such as potentially hickenlooper who is opposed and she said in november of 2020 president warren would turn around to her democratic members in congress and say, look, we just passed and we got a mandate from voters to pass medicare for all and she would work with democrats to take that over the finish line. this is my own editorial note. we saw one president, and perhaps the one sitting in office right now, able to take his party and move it in his direction, but the question is if elizabeth warren could change her own party in the presidency? >> it is about the size of the mandate. vaughn hilliard, thank you. and now, coming in we are joined on the other side of a quick break who

i take senator joe manchin to someone who talked to the president all the time and they worked together to-- he served a bit of that in between with the democrats and the republicans and trying to solve problems. and so the more we can have of those types of relationships, the i think the healthier our political process can be. you know, it's become a challenge with social media, a challenge with 24-hour news cycles because the politician wants to get out in front of the media and give the response and attack their opponent and move on. and i think that that becomes challengeling, but i think at the end of the day, look, we're all getting close to thanksgiving, you're going to maybe have your liberal cousin or your conservative uncle and you want to make sure that you talk about the issues that matter and to donna's point find solutions you can come together and agree on. there are things we do agree on when it comes to, for example, usmca, the ipo crisis, criminal justice reform, which was a big win for both republicans and democrats. and so, i think the more we can find those common g

the affordable care act, and all at the time 48 fighting democrats stood together from bernie to joe manchin and we said no, because we stood together we were joined by three republicans including senator mccain who said no, and we won that effort. they did not take people off of their health insurance. we did that. [applause] you go into that following summer when they first glimmers of hope since donald trump's election and into the fall when these legislative races were up, my personal favorite was the guy from new jersey who would it se date of the women's march, i hope it will be home in time to make dinner. that guy got defeated by an african-american woman. that happened. [applause] and then you go to parkland and the young people, and what happened there where they just said no, we are not going to take it, and he started marching and kept that march going into the last congressional election where literally we took the house of representatives and turned it into the people's house again. we had what happened is last few weeks. i mean, it is an exciting thing to be a part of because

different from elizabeth warren, he can pay for it but everyone likes what i am coming up with, joe manchindemocratic senator that he would support. i got to talk to manchin about it and he did not agree. >> the bernie sanders thing. would you support his agenda? >> absolutely not. bernie brings a lot to the table and makes you think a little bit. it is not practical where i come from. bernie keeps saying medicare for all, we can't even pay for medicare for some. neil: he went on to say the choice, donald trump and bernie sanders, a tough time deciding but seemed it would not the bernie sanders. >> elizabeth warren's plan, the first healthcare plan on the democratic and republican side that lays out exactly how she intends to pay for it. bernie sanders asked are you going to lay out a plan how you intend to pay for medicare for all? he said i don't think i have to do that right now. >> the middle-class wouldn't pay and i give you an example how it could. she was exacting that. >> she has been forthright to the extent more so than any republican or democrat in the race and at the end of the

and a democratic strategist and former chief of staff for senator joe manchin. welcome to you both. the 2020 democrats specifically. who would bloomberg's candidacy potentially hurt? >> well -- let's put aside the logic of his candidacy a second and assume he can get in and bypasses the first four states and basically waiting for super tuesday to use your monies, have some kind of air campaign to mobilize and move voters. putting all of that aside whether that's possible and we can talk about that how unlikely that is. who does he hurt? well, i want to pin it a little differently. who does he help? clearly helps warren and sanders. he becomes a living foil to the idea that if you have enough money you can influence and shape democracy the way that you want. and so in that sense, i think christmas came early for both sanders and warren. he arguably, depending how much resources he puts into this. if he actually runs a series campaign, actually can connect with voters, he may hurt someone like buttigieg. i don't think he's going to hurt biden at all. i think what he's counting on basi

i mean, the democratic party, i had joe manchin of west virginia on who bernie sanders says is for thedicare for all sounds great but we can't even afford medicare for some right now. so there's a divide in the party, isn't there? >> yeah. not surprising. first of all, you know, we talked about the economy being a major issue for trump but health care is right there as well. that's why this is such a key issue. you know, when the economy is doing okay, i think it becomes less important in terms of maybe motivating voters. that kind of shifts the focus to health care and you look at the midterms. but you're right, medicare for all, we can't afford it and i guess the question from a market standpoint is when do these massive deficits matter? and the amount of spending that is being thrown out there to fund medicare for all, $52 trillion? $20 trillion additional spending? it is the concept of trillion, it's just unbelievable. neil: that might be an "snl" skit. it's meaningless. at some point, those are real numbers. >> i think so. neil: we will take a quick break here. did the air just ge

candidate and former auburn head coach tommy and democrat senator doug jones tailgating with senator joe manchinit can be to defend his seat. trump's endorsement isn't everything. last time roy moore losing in the general election. and luther strange losing in the primary. so turning of course from alabama to louisiana, also featured in that game, the president will actually be heading down there for a rally later this week. and it's his third appearance in the state in the last couple of weeks. that's because there is a gubernatorial election coming up next weekend. and the trump campaign is hoping that the president's presence there will help the republican candidate against john bel edwards there. the president hopeful because in the last few weeks when he was there, he helped to kind of force a runoff there and all signs are pointing to that being a big factor heading into that election. so here in the south lots to watch for, lots of story lines, ayman. >> thank you so much, monica. >>> desiree, let's talk a little bit about senator doug jones here for a moment. because, quite frankly, and

one or two democrats, joe manchin and doug jones, west virginia and alabama might vote against the democratsrepublicans hold a month-long trial they'll get accused of shackling democrats to their desk. if they hold a three-day trial they'll get accused of pushing it through. it doesn't matter what they decide nobody will like the outcome or remove the president and we'll waste time. >> bill: waiting to hear on public hearings. maybe they get underway next week or maybe they don't. last night's election the fallout in virginia, down in mississippi and also in kentucky. here is the president's tweet on kentucky. election night won five out of six elections in kentucky including five great candidates i spoke for introduced last night. matt bevin picked up 15 points in the last days. perhaps not enough. fake news will still blame trump. winning in mississippi governor's race. what do the results tell you? >> first i don't know how the president knows it's a 15-point pickup in the last today. i think that's an exaggeration but what it does tell you the press has gone gaga trying to blame it on do

you and i know folks like joe manchin and others are not going to support that plan., everybody having it, but the steps getting there is going to be what can you cobble snogt htogether? chow you get things done in the only bipartisan bill that's gotten past this president was the criminal justice reform bill that i led from the democratic side if the didn't do everyth g side. it moved the ball down the field. >> joe biden says he has the experience, the contacts across the globe, decades of service to back up the argument that he can restore order to the presidency, that he can bring things back to normal and move america forward. what makes you have more experience or more ability than joe biden? >> well, first of all, i've been everything from a chief executive in new jersey's largest city in the middle of a crisis all the way to a senator getting things done. think my favorite new author, i said a little earlier, we're not going to win -- people have to understand. we've got one shot to make donald trump a one-term president. we need a movement in this election. s

joe manchin, nothing right about this. dead wrong.make a decision about impeachment. bottom line, for anyone to condone this and say this is normal behavior and how we should act as a country, superpower, world is wrong. ask the republicans start attacking the witnesses in question and patriotism and character of these people you see some of the democrats who you might expect to be quiet and safe be more outspoken. the elastic works both ways. >> just re-elected and counting on nobody remembering or talking about this in six years. stick around. more to talk about. testifying in the impeachment inquiry hearings, and how lieutenant colonel vindman responded when asked if he's getting blowback at work. wow! that's ensure max protein, with high protein and 1 gram sugar. it's a sit-up, banana! bend at the waist! i'm tryin'! keep it up. you'll get there. whoa-hoa-hoa! 30 grams of protein, and one gram of sugar. ensure max protein. wwithout it, i cannot write myl tremors wouldname.xtreme. i was diagnosed with parkinson's. i had to retire fr