after three years on death row, joe would receive a new trial. the martinez family asked peter to lead joe's defense. >> i was very fortunate that it was a different state attorney. he gave me access to his files, and i learned that some of the people who had been interviewed had not disclosed everything that they knew and had done. >> among the state's files, peter came upon a tip from barbara mccoy, the mother of victim, sherrie. >> there was a tampa tribune article about a motorcycle outfit that was busted, and i kind of asked around and they said when that article appeared in the tampa tribune, barbara mccoy called detective conigliaro and said, "those are the guys that came to my house looking for doug about a motorcycle, and they were scary." >> at the crime scene, detectives had located a motorcycle that peter now believed was connected to the group, led by the suggs brothers. >> i asked barbara mccoy, "so, in your mind, they were potential suspects?" "yes, they were." detective conigliaro probably abandoned that investigation when sloane brought joe t