>> john gibbener, today we take comment on item 10 and 11 and recommend the committee take the motions but not vote on them until after public comment and when public comment is done adopt. >> okay. fair enough. madam clerk motion to resend the previous- >> motion to resend. >> motion by sfr visor tang and second by supervisor yee without objection and entertain a motion to accept the recommendations after-public comment. thank you very much. department of the environment here yet by chance? no problem. >> my apologies for the timing error. debbie rafael department of environment and are pleased to say we are in agreement with budget analyst recommendation and accept their changes. >> thank you very much. mr. rose why don't we go to your report. >> on page 2 of the report the recommended reductions-page 18 of the report, sorry. our recommended reductions to the budget total 102, 633. 16-17. 92, 918 are on going savings and 9, 750 are 1 time. allow increase of [inaudible] or 6.9 percent in the department 16-17 budget. [inaudible] all those monies are on pm going savings and as i underst

>> john gibbener, today we take comment on item 10 and 11 and recommend the committee take the motions but not vote on them until after public comment and when public comment is done adopt. >> okay. fair enough. madam clerk motion to resend the previous- >> motion to resend. >> motion by sfr visor tang and second by supervisor yee without objection and entertain a motion to accept the recommendations after-public comment. thank you very much. department of the environment here yet by chance? no problem. >> my apologies for the timing error. debbie rafael department of environment and are pleased to say we are in agreement with budget analyst recommendation and accept their changes. >> thank you very much. mr. rose why don't we go to your report. >> on page 2 of the report the recommended reductions-page 18 of the report, sorry. our recommended reductions to the budget total 102, 633. 16-17. 92, 918 are on going savings and 9, 750 are 1 time. allow increase of [inaudible] or 6.9 percent in the department 16-17 budget. [inaudible] all those monies are on pm going savings and as i underst

>> john gibbener, today we take comment on item 10 and 11 and recommend the committee take the motions but not vote on them until after public comment and when public comment is done adopt. >> okay. fair enough. madam clerk motion to resend the previous- >> motion to resend. >> motion by sfr visor tang and se

>> john gibbener, today we take comment on item 10 and 11 and recommend the committee take the motions but not vote on them until after public comment and when public comment is done adopt. >> okay. fair enough. madam clerk motion to resend the previous- >> motion to resend. >> motion by sfr visor tang and second by supervisor yee without objection and entertain a motion to accept the recommendations after-public comment. thank you very much. department of the environment here yet by chance? no problem. >> my apologies for the timing error. debbie rafael department of environment and are pleased to say we are in agreement with budget analyst recommendation and accept their changes. >> thank you very much. mr. rose why don't we go to your report. >> on page 2 of the report the recommended reductions-page 18 of the report, sorry. our recommended reductions to the budget total 102, 633. 16-17. 92, 918 are on going savings and 9, 750 are 1 time. allow increase of [inaudible] or 6.9 percent in the department 16-17 budget. [inaudible] all those monies are on pm going savings and as i underst

>> john gibbener, today we take comment on item 10 and 11 and recommend the committee take the motions but not vote on them until after public comment and when public comment is done adopt. >> okay. fair enough. madam clerk motion to resend the previous- >> motion to resend. >> motion by sfr visor tang and second by supervisor yee without objection and entertain a motion to accept the recommendations after-public comment. thank you very much. department of the environment here yet by chance? no problem. >> my apologies for the timing error. debbie rafael department of environment and are pleased to say we are in agreement with budget analyst recommendation and accept their changes. >> thank you very much. mr. rose why don't we go to your report. >> on page 2 of the report the recommended reductions-page 18 of the report, sorry. our recommended reductions to the budget total 102, 633. 16-17. 92, 918 are on going savings and 9, 750 are 1 time. allow increase of [inaudible] or 6.9 percent in the department 16-17 budget. [inaudible] all those monies are on pm going savings and as i underst

>> john gibbener, today we take comment on item 10 and 11 and recommend the committee take the motions but not vote on them until after public comment and when public comment is done adopt. >> okay. fair enough. madam clerk motion to resend the previous- >> motion to resend. >> motion by sfr visor tang and second by supervisor yee without objection and entertain a motion to accept the recommendations after-public comment. thank you very much. department of the environment here yet by chance? no problem. >> my apologies for the timing error. debbie rafael department of environment and are pleased to say we are in agreement with budget analyst recommendation and accept their changes. >> thank you very much. mr. rose why don't we go to your report. >> on page 2 of the report the recommended reductions-page 18 of the report, sorry. our recommended reductions to the budget total 102, 633. 16-17. 92, 918 are on going savings and 9, 750 are 1 time. allow increase of [inaudible] or 6.9 percent in the department 16-17 budget. [inaudible] all those monies are on pm going savings and as i underst

>> john gibbener, today we take comment on item 10 and 11 and recommend the committee take the motionson them until after public comment and when public comment is done adopt. >> okay. fair enough. madam clerk motion to resend the previous- >> motion to resend. >> motion by sfr visor tang and second by supervisor yee without objection and entertain a motion to accept the recommendations after-public comment. thank you very much. department of the environment here yet by chance? no problem. >> my apologies for the timing error. debbie rafael department of environment and are pleased to say we are in agreement with budget analyst recommendation and accept their changes. >> thank you very much. mr. rose why don't we go to your report. >> on page 2 of the report the recommended reductions-page 18 of the report, sorry. our recommended reductions to the budget total 102, 633. 16-17. 92, 918 are on going savings and 9, 750 are 1 time. allow increase of [inaudible] or 6.9 percent in the department 16-17 budget. [inaudible] all those monies are on pm going savings and as i understand the depart