. >> in the part the municipal code those are the two i know but john gibner, deputy city attorney may know more. >> around housing issues i know this housing ordinance is one are there others. >> we believe there are the two. >> so the residential hotel and this one. >> the exist code allows for the nonprofits to obtain monetary damages. >> yes. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney there's a pending ordinance as well that i think in the budget and finance committee tomorrow the bio legislation that is similarly lowering the housing nonprofits. >> but in terms of the universe of where the housing nonprofits can sue to what extent does it go beyond the residential hotel. >> it's just the residents hotel that is the chapter four 1 we existing 41 a also. >> okay. and okay and so right now this and typically under the current law when a housing nonprofit has a private right of action to enforce the administration active code whether in the residential hotel code there's a city administration active process first. >> actually in chapter four 1 it doesn't require the city producing process b

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney for clarification on supervisor mar's amendment those amendments were not drafted by yourself our offices but understanding there are tweaks we want to make for example, the current language on the word inclusionary the inclusionary housing program we get probably delete now, it's covered as part of our new language about all induced housing the reference to middle-income housing we'll delete ways that is not a term defined in our affordable housing program but low and moderate is appropriate. >> thank you supervisor kim. >> thank you, madam chair wow. as if we don't have enough amendments i'll be interrogating an amendment and this is specifically on the around the issue of the private right of action just to give this amendment a little bit of context it is important to state some of the statistics right now currently 12 hundred complaints filed rewarding short-term rentals in san francisco and two legal actions by the city attorney that's a state of enforcement around short-term rentals in san francisco i've also made it clear i know the public

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney stepping back to supervisor campos amendment i'm sure you're aware of there's been litigation go challenging various ordinances in the city involving the ellis act so as i mentioned supervisor campos amendment will require a revel to another k34e hearing and at or before that committee hearing provided the advice regarding the issue we suggest during the last two weeks we've looked electro the ordinances that is preponderance of the evidence and worked with supervisors office particularly supervisor chiu's office and had clean up amendments we'll ask the board to adapt may be the first amendment you'll vote on supervisor chiu has a copy of the amendment but essentially they've fixed the number one issues that came up in the past amendment they clarify that hosting platforms can be liable for violations of the notice requirement in the ordinance and in the administrative hearing and one of the amendments that supervisor farrell proposed today requiring the finally the homeowners association to my unit covered by the homeowners association including th

. >> city attorney and john gibner, deputy city attorney. >> so i believe at some point in the discussion probably makes sense for my colleagues merlin or myself to talk about the amendments to refer to planning are which which have them requires another hearing at the board the amendment you'll proposed supervisor avalos will not be referred back to planning i'll just supervisor breed has duplicate the file at some point during the hearing when the items come up for a vote i would just say you would have a voted on this amendment as you've circulated it in either of the duplicate files or both. >> thank you. >> thank you so supervisor campos. >> i make a motion for both. >> sure so just asking for a second on supervisor campos first amendment regarding the trinity taxes seconded 3wi supervisor avalos and permitting the shortfalls subject to the ellis act evictions a second supervisor breed supervisor chiu. >> thank you colleagues let me first start by asking are there any other amendment you i think i need to ask the deputy city attorney he has amendments. >> john gibner, deputy city att

experience thank you, everyone for being so involved i certainly want to thank our da merlin and john gibner, deputy city attorney for their hard work i'll say general buildingly so to speak our airbnb has revolutionized things across the city i don't think that generally in the early stages government should not get in the way of consumer demand whether uber or airbnb but there reaches a point the government rethsdz those industries and those behaviors we have reached that point with airbnb in san francisco i know other cases throughout the country i very much agree it was part of the legislation i see stationss t is core and central that's a no brainer and insurance for anyone that could be affected by behavior in my units this legislation does not peers the vail of the existing leases or the agreements already in place a huge thing from my constituents i have a lot of people that are home sharers and not around the enforcement so if there's an issue or complaint if someone is looking at this we don't leave to the nuisance laws and quite frankly people don't have their faith so permitting

. >> deputy city attorney john gibner. the committee recommended to move to the full board. >> colleagues, can i have a motion to not disclose. >> so moved. >> anymore business? >> that concludes our items for this session. >> then meeting is adjourned. [ meeting is adjourned ] >> >> (music) >> herb theatre,open rehearsal. listen to the rehearsal. i think it is fun for them, they see our work process, our discussions, the decisions we make. it is good for us. we kind of behavior little bit when we have people in the audience. msk (music) >> we are rehearsing for our most expensive tour; plus two concerts here. we are proud that the growth of the orchestra, and how it is expanded and it is being accepted. my ambition when i came on as music director here -- it was evident we needed absolutely excellent work. also evident to me that i thought everyone should know that. this was my purpose. and after we opened, which was a spectacular opening concert about five weeks after that the economy completely crashed. my plan -- and i

. >> deputy city attorney john gibner. the committee recommended to move to the full board. >> colleagues, can i have a motion to not disclose. >> so moved. >> anymore business? >> that concludes our items for this session. >> then meeting is adjourned. [ meeting is adjourned ] >> >> >> there are kids and families ever were. it is really an extraordinary playground. it has got a little something for everyone. it is aesthetically billion. it is completely accessible. you can see how excited people are for this playground. it is very special. >> on opening day in the brand- new helen diller playground at north park, children can be seen swinging, gliding, swinging, exploring, digging, hanging, jumping, and even making drumming sounds. this major renovation was possible with the generous donation of more than $1.5 million from the mercer fund in honor of san francisco bay area philanthropist helen diller. together with the clean and safe neighborhood parks fund and the city's general fund. >> 4. 3. 2. 1. [applause] >> the pla

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney i think the appropriated motion is to continue to the to the call of the chair and we'll afford it to the full board. >> so the duplicateded version of item 3 to the call of the chair. >> 70. >> we'll take that without objection. align to the original version of item 3 as amended by supervisor mar and me it a motion. >> some of the task force on the subsidies we'll work with the planning folks to make sure that the stakeholders are included and i think also the process to look at the small business priority progressing pilot program as a potential method of streamlining for the smaller chains and smaller soup companies and those kinds of smaller chains will be looked at this is another process and lastly i know a number of people brought up the jobs and quality and the conditions in jobs and retail i think this is really was on effort with the small businesses and neighborhood leaders and jobs for justice to look at more comprehensive issues of the working conditions and the whole economy of small and bigger businesses in the city i think another ke

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney that's adequate i've got the gist. >> to the presentation of d t what they said thanks and yes or had another objection in terms of the moving forward. >> we'll draft that after the meeting. >> i'm sorry one other thing in terms of the 9 hundred feet i think so that if you have a small project you might not want to also do this but there's a cost involved i get that i i'm wondering why the 9 hundred feet as opposed to why another measure of feet and in terms of the department works the range of projects what percentage of road projects are going to come in under 9 hundred and what's the possibility to piecemeal that by bringing up the 2 thousand foot and defining it not having to accept any conduit sir, do you want to - >> thank you very much for that. >> thank you, supervisors jerry department of public works streets and mapping thank you, supervisors a valid question actually what i can tell you with use and as supervisor chiu and my colleague mentioned the eye of the gi s based you know as the tool we would like to forecast those jobs out for

. >> deputy city attorney john gibner. the committee recommended to move to the full board. >> colleagues, can i have a motion to not disclose. >> so moved. >> anymore business? >> that concludes our items for this session. >> then meeting is adjourned. [ meeting is adjourned ] >> >> >> hi. i am cory with san francisco and we're doing stay safe and we're going to talk about what shelter in place or safe enough to stay in your home means. we're here at the urban center on mission street in san francisco and joined by carla, the deputy director of spur and one of the persons who pushed this shelter in place and safe enough to stay concept and we want to talk about what it means and why it's important to san francisco. >> as you know the bay area as 63% chance of having a major earthquake and it's serious and going to impact a lot of people and particularly people in san francisco because we live on a major fault so what does this mean for us? part of what it means is that potentially 25% of san francisco's building stock wil

voters that's a question for the city attorney whether we can set aside tax for the city improvement john gibner, deputy city attorney is saying no, but we have to fund and have a discussion on how we will be able to fined this the legislation only works if we enforce the policy we need to know where the dollars are coming from i want to figure out that in advance i want to make sure the planning department can have a robust team like the quadrants, please plus someone to oversee the budget sequoa the final issue i'll bring up there's a number of other issues but the concept is standing sequoa in terms of who can complain ii not to know who they would go to and who can file the complaint and that kind of questions the beginning of some of the questions i have i want to say i think we've made headway in the legislation before us a couple months ago i couldn't see how to regulate this but has negative consequences the top one being people if the unit that take the rooms off the market with the housing is expensive in california i've met residents that have been ellis act evicted and they rented ou

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney earmarking the hotel review it requires voter approval you can't do it in this ordinance the boards could do this in the future. >> i'll say supervisor cohen if we get $100 million a year from this activity i'll support you to make sure that money goes to affordable housing. >> we've got something coming to the voters next year. >> or the board can allocate it. >> more to come on that topic. >> supervisor kim. >> thank you i just want to appreciate some of the amendments that came in and i have copies of scott wiener's amendments and could get copies of supervisor cohen's amendments as well arrest i want to reiterate i want to pass legislation i agree that what's happening is not working for the city and not working for our host as well they don't want to be conducting illegal activity we need to pass something we're moving in the right direction by actually legal listing the activity but under a set of regulations i think the perjury will be helpful if we're going to investigate against an individual that has signed an agreement that investigation

experience thank you, everyone for being so involved i certainly want to thank our da merlin and john gibner, deputy city attorney for their hard work i'll say general buildingly so to speak our airbnb has revolutionized things across the city i don't think that generally in the early stages government should not get in the way of consumer demand whether uber or airbnb but there reaches a point the government rethsdz those industries and those behaviors we have reached that point with airbnb in san francisco i know other cases throughout the country i very much agree it was part of the legislation i see

. >> sure john gibner, deputy city attorney to our question supervisor avalos i do recall the due process for all ordinances and that process i can't remember steak which amendments need a continuance but we've drafted with the state law we wanted to feel comfortable with before the board adapted it on first responder generally, if an ordinance if the board all the times open ordinance we call substantive outside of the general issues that were noticed at the committee he meeting we'll recommend that the board send the item back to committee but from my understanding there were 14 amendments that are floating out here right now not including the two technical amendment we've will suggested earlier many of those meantime can be adapted and the board can pass it on first responder some of the amendments need a further meeting in committee and some a further committee hearing at the planning commission that doesn't have the opportunity to consider the items supervisor tang said we can republic through the ordinances and see which ones that will require a continuance. >> i see a real differen

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney i agree with ms. burn that's hard to predict what's going to happen the cases are going to turn on the fact the court will have reasonable attorney's fees if the nonprofit prevailed so there's a number of factors that is reasonable as you know, from seeing the settlements before the board there's a low moderny dangle award and attorney's fees are high in terms of the injunction relieve under the the amendment you've proposed the party that's going to be sued would have 45 days to cure before a lawsuit is filed once it's filed if there's a claim for injunctive relief and the folks change their practices it's possible under a type of litigation that the plaintiff the nonprofit in this case would be considered a prevailing party because the lawsuit forced the change and then petition the court for attorney's fees he again hard to exactly predict. >> i think historically is that courts don't give fees for a minor violation i want to make sure that folks said the amendment that i have been offering and why

experience thank you, everyone for being so involved i certainly want to thank our da merlin and john gibner, deputy city attorney for their hard work i'll say general buildingly so to speak our airbnb has