can i ask to our john gibner, deputy city attorney. why is it that some ordinances don't have this session but the city attorney's office is certifying it is only responsible to have the section in the current ordinance before us >> well, let me just to just to be clear ultimately it is a policy decision for the board whether to center a private right of action ♪ ordinance not from my office our advise is that the board should be implicit one woorpd to keep in the clause no private right of action implicit create a private right of action in the ordinance in years past we were not including 24 clause i think we started including 3 in situation where the ordinance imposes a duty on city departments that can impact members of the public we wanted ordinances like this to be implicit about where a private right of action that's why we included this ordinance i'm sorry this clause in ordinances like this regularly but again, it is a call for the board i would suggest if you want to work on a private right of action in the break downs delete

can i ask to our john gibner, deputy city attorney. why is it that some ordinances don't have this session but the city attorney's office is certifying it is only responsible to have the section in the current ordinance before us >> well, let me just to just to be clear ultimately it is a policy decision for the board whether to center a private right of action ♪ ordinance not from my office our advise is that the board should be implicit one woorpd to keep in the clause no private right of action implicit create a private right of action in the ordinance in years past we were not including 24 clause i think we started including 3 in situation where the ordinance imposes a duty on city departments that can impact members of the public we wanted ordinances like this to be implicit about where a private right of action that's why we included this ordinance i'm sorry this clause in ordinances like this regularly but again, it is a call for the board i would suggest if you want to work on a private right of action in the break downs delete

.) >> and our john gibner, deputy city attorney. >> (clapping.) >> we make a great team i'm looking forwarddoing this work over the next two years as board president and a supervisor i'm honored to serve with each of the 10 of you whether that is chief suhr on transit quality or public safety or supervisor farrell on good solutions for the homeless challenges on supervisor peskin as he fights for good government a good government that our people here in the city deserves and being a physique convert and supervisor tang for moms and protecting the furry friends and supervisor kim so for bringing city college for those that deserve an opportunity and supervisor yee and his decades effort to improve the services and support for our children especially preschool for all and supervisor i know will bravely defend our health care and vital health care services and supervisor ron in an and commissioner coppel on orange our police department and balancing our budget during challenging times and supervisor as he fights for somebody's and workforce housing in the city all of you are talented and amazi

our city kroerl ben rosenfield and want to send a special recognized to our deputy city attorney john gibner and finally the legendary man that needs no introduction who worked on the board of supervisors as a budget and legislative analyst since it's inception the line of questioning legendary harvey rose. >> (clapping.) >> i did this in the electives thank you. >> so thank you all for being here today clearly it is not just the members of the board of the supervisors that makes the decisions that will the people that actually make the city run we appreciate many of the elected leaders and the department heads for joining us here today with that, time for raekz racks from the members of the board and so i'll go in order and starting with supervisor sandra fewer. >> thank you madam president and i would like to say thank you for the opportunity to introduce you to my family that supported me throughout the campaign but actually, the pride of actually my life and i would be honored today for everyone to get to know my family which is john fewer my husband of 35 years. >> my daughter colleen f

our city kroerl ben rosenfield and want to send a special recognized to our deputy city attorney john gibner finally the legendary man that needs no introduction who worked on the board of supervisors as a budget and legislative analyst since it's inception the line of questioning legendary harvey rose. >> (clapping.) >> i did this in the electives thank you. >> so thank you all for being here today clearly it is not just the members of the board of the supervisors that makes the decisions that will the people that actually make the city run we appreciate many of the elected leaders and the department heads for joining us here today with that, time for raekz racks from the members of the board and so i'll go in order and starting with supervisor sandra fewer. >> thank you madam president and i would like to say thank you for the opportunity to introduce you to my family that supported me throughout the campaign but actually, the pride of actually my life and i would be honored today for everyone to get to know my family which is john fewer my husband of 35 years. >> my daughter colleen fewer

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney. so the as you said supervisor yee the ordinance in its current as the scheme is conceived the board adopt the tdm requirement and planning adopt the tdm standards the board could adopt the tdm standard itself that's not how this has been conceived and not how it is drafts the board can require that planning approves the standard and bring them to the board the board will adopt by ordinance a future ordinance if you want to make that amendment i would like to discuss it with planning how exactly that fits and how does that work and ask that we at least the board continue the item to later in the meeting and maybe continue it a week entirety. >> i know for any district probable other district supervisors in their computes that care about this our balboa reservoir and when not in discussion the laguna honda boulevard and forest hill project and the 5 hundred more units, 4 hundred more units the issue of how do you deal with transportation demands have come up over and over and over and o

john gibner. >>deputy city attorney john gibner. the sheriff this will need to be approved i guess i need to ask the sheriff whether if this is accepted whether or not any work will be done on this at this point or not . >>i am looking forward to working with you and the community on strategy so that we can decrease our general population but i just wanted to put on the record that that is not an option that i am open to entertaining if and when this, you know, project comes before us again, through acceptance. >>we are talking 2019th we have to plan for this at a time if this were to occur and then, you know, the strategies that we envision through this project we will have available to us. >>thank you supervisor. supervisor kim. >>thank you. this is not necessarily a question for staff but i do want to express my concern of what the city will incur regarding debt. what i'm concerned with is if this is something that the city can pay out without increasing their debt and i also am concerned and less they can match the funds if-- i

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney. the ordinance on 16 desolates the zero there's license fee for second-hand dealers at the police department supervisor yee is requesting we add that back in so the document i believe that supervisor yee has provided to the clerk adds the new line 17 that adds the delegated line back in. >> got it. >> okay so - >> supervisor yee. >> i'm sorry the the president deputy city attorney gibner is that subsequent we wait until next week or pass is this week. >> not substantive amendment under the charter anytime it needs a second reading after you make the amendment have a first reading and technique. >> thank you supervisor yee supervisor peskin second. >> so supervisor yee was made a motion to amend and seconded by supervisor peskin colleagues without objection the amendment passes unanimously on the item as amended colleagues, can we take that same house, same call? this pass first reading. >> madam clerk next item 9 an ordinance to have the development agreement with a ground lease with a

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney. the ordinance on 16 desolates the zero there's license fee for second-hand dealers at the police department supervisor yee is requesting we add that back in so the document i believe that supervisor yee has provided to the clerk adds the new line 17 that adds the delegated line back in. >> got it. >> okay so - >> supervisor yee. >> i'm sorry the the president deputy city attorney gibner is that subsequent we wait until next week or pass is this week. >> not substantive amendment under the charter anytime it needs a second reading after you make the amendment have a first reading and technique. >> thank you supervisor yee supervisor peskin second. >> so supervisor yee was made a motion to amend and seconded by supervisor peskin colleagues without objection the amendment passes unanimously on the item as amended colleagues, can we take that same house, same call? this pass first reading. >> madam clerk next item 9 an ordinance to have the development agreement with a ground lease with a

our city kroerl ben rosenfield and want to send a special recognized to our deputy city attorney john gibnerinally the legendary man that needs no introduction who worked on the board of supervisors as a budget and legislative analyst since it's inception the line of questioning legendary harvey rose. >> (clapping.) >> i did this in the electives thank

our city kroerl ben rosenfield and want to send a special recognized to our deputy city attorney john gibner finally the legendary man that needs no introduction who worked on the board of supervisors as a budget and legislative analyst since it's inception the line of questioning legendary harvey rose. >> (clapping.) >> i did this in the electives thank you. >> so thank you all for being here today clearly it is not just the members of the board of the supervisors that makes the decisions that will the people that actually make the city run we appreciate many of the elected leaders and the department heads for joining us here today with that, time for raekz racks from the members of the board and so i'll go in order and starting with supervisor sandra fewer. >> thank you madam president and i would like to say thank you for the opportunity to introduce you to my family that supported me throughout the campaign but actually, the pride of actually my life and i would be honored today for everyone to get to know my family which is john fewer my husband of 35 years. >> my daughter colleen fewer

. >> i want to start off by tilly chang john gibner, deputy city attorney. and all the attorneys in his office sue donald trump the city of san francisco san francisco sued our president sued him seek on injunction against the executive order that attacks our city against a squanderers i couldn't be happier we're takeing on if executive order we have one of the best exclusive 0 law it gives me calm to know the city attorney's office taking the lead and he just wanted to express pride i'm introducing a resolution today in support of a bill sponsored by pro tem a call to the california sb 54 it does 3 things number one requires that no state and local resources are used to help immigration and customs carry out deportation and regardless of resources that are implemented a judicial warrant for the detention if local custody to ice custody and protects californian that seek services or engage with services to insure that private information didn't end up in easing hands and creates safe zones around comes out and other public places i'm happy to have learned th

john gibner. >>deputy city attorney john gibner. the sheriff this will need to be approved i guess i need to ask the sheriff whether if this is accepted whether or not any work will be done on this at this point or not . >>i am looking forward to working with you and the community on strategy so that we can decrease our general population but i just wanted to put on the record that that is not an option that i am open to entertaining if and when this, you know, project comes before us again, through acceptance. >>we are talking 2019th we have to plan for this at a time if this were to occur and then, you know, the strategies that we envision through this project we will have available to us. >>thank you supervisor. supervisor kim. >>thank you. this is not necessarily a question for staff but i do want to express my concern of what the city will incur regarding debt. what i'm concerned with is if this is something that the city can pay out without increasing their debt and i also am concerned and less they can match the funds if-- i

. >> john gibner and there were sections not amended in the first ordinance and removed from this version all together some changes to zoning coal tables that no longer need to be changed because the ordinance is scaled back. >> okay. colleagues any questions, comments for the sponsor and team in. >> less is more. i am fine with these changes. >> okay. we will open up public comment then. thank you. [calling speaker names] if there is anybody else wish to speak please line up and do this for the next items as well. everyone has two minutes to speak if line up on the far wall. that would be great. >> good afternoon supervisors. i am president of the south of market business association. i remember as a kid i still loved to go to the local cafe in my town and play pin ball and not just games but meet people there and a fun time to have a friday evening or saturdays and so forth so it was a great time to spend with friends and so we feel it's the same thing now. we don't have the pin ball machines anymore. it's sort of more electronic and techy stuffs and i don't blame myself but it's great

john gibner. >>deputy city attorney john gibner. the sheriff this will need to be approved i guess i need to ask the sheriff whether if this is accepted whether or not any work will be done on this at this point or not . >>i am looking forward to working with you and the community on strategy so that we can decrease our general population but i just wanted to put on the record that that is not an option that i am open to entertaining if and when this, you know, project comes before us again, through acceptance. >>we are talking 2019th we have to plan for this at a time if this were to occur and then, you know, the strategies that we envision through this project we will have available to us. >>thank you supervisor. supervisor kim. >>thank you. this is not necessarily a question for staff but i do want to express my concern of what the city will incur regarding debt. what i'm concerned with is if this is something that the city can pay out without increasing their debt and i also am concerned and less they can match the funds if-- i

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney.ee the ordinance in its current as the scheme is conceived the board adopt the tdm requirement and planning adopt the tdm standards the board could adopt the tdm standard itself that's not how this has been conceived and not how it is drafts the board can require that planning approves the standard and bring them to the board the board will adopt by ordinance a future ordinance if you want to make that amendment i would like to discuss it with planning how exactly that fits and how does that work and ask that we at least the board continue the item to later in the meeting and maybe continue it a week entirety. >> i know for any district probable other district supervisors in their computes that care about this our balboa reservoir and when not in discussion the laguna honda boulevard and forest hill project and the 5 hundred more units, 4 hundred more units the issue of how do you deal with transportation demands have come up over and over and over and over one of the major topics we t

determine, aside from what he mentioned regarding the threat risk analysis and the >> city attorney, john, gibnerfiscal agent we play a limited role or dem played an limited role with the agreement in the other counties, that we will apply for the funds from the federal government and administer them, but dem does not play a policy making role in determining whether as a policy matter that the funds are appropriate or in appropriate and so the board can't conditionally apply for a grant for giving them to the county for certain purpose and not other purpose and our role is limited under our agreement with the other counties. >> so the question here would be can the different locations including san francisco, accomplish what they want to accomplish without utilizing or subcontracting with urban shields? >> well, we did contract with urban shield. it is an exercise that alameda county conducts. we in san francisco there are members of our law enforcement and our first responder community that participate in urban shield because it is an opportunity to enhance our ability to respond to emergencies

. >> john gibner and there were sections not amended in the first ordinance and removed from this version all together some changes to zoning coal tables that no longer need to be changed because the ordinance is scaled back. >> okay. colleagues any questions, comments for the sponsor and team in. >> less is more. i am fine with these changes. >> okay. we will open up public comment then. thank you. [calling speaker names] if there is anybody else wish to speak please line up and do this for the next items as well. everyone has two minutes to speak if line up on the far wall. that would be great. >> good afternoon supervisors. i am president of the south of market business association. i remember as a kid i still loved to go to the local cafe in my town and play pin ball and not just games but meet people there and a fun time to have a friday evening or saturdays and so forth so it was a great time to spend with friends and so we feel it's the same thing now. we don't have the pin ball machines anymore. it's sort of more electronic and techy stuffs and i don't blame myself but it's great

. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney. the ordinance on 16 desolates the zero there's license fee for second-hand dealers at the police department supervisor yee is requesting we add that back in so the document i believe that supervisor yee has provided to the clerk adds the new line 17 that adds the delegated line back in. >> got it. >> okay so - >> supervisor yee. >> i'm sorry the the president deputy city attorney gibner is that subsequent we wait until next week or pass is this week. >> not substantive amendment under the charter anytime it needs a second reading after you make the amendment have a first reading and technique. >> thank you supervisor yee supervisor peskin second. >> so supervisor yee was made a motion to amend and seconded by supervisor peskin colleagues without objection the amendment passes unanimously on the item as amended colleagues, can we take that same house, same call? this pass first reading. >> madam clerk next item 9 an ordinance to have the development agreement with a ground lease with a

. >> john gibner and there were sections not amended in the first ordinance and removed from this versionogether some changes to zoning coal tables that no longer need to be changed because the ordinance is scaled back. >> okay. colleagues any questions, comments for the sponsor and team in. >> less is more. i am fine with these changes. >> okay. we will open up public comment then. thank you. [calling speaker names] if there is anybody else wish to speak please line up and do this for the next items as well. everyone has two minutes to speak if line up on the far wall. that would be great. >> good afternoon supervisors. i am president of the south of market business association. i remember as a kid i still loved to go to the local cafe in my town and play pin ball and not just games but meet people there and a fun time to have a friday evening or saturdays and so forth so it was a great time to spend with friends and so we feel it's the same thing now. we don't have the pin ball machines anymore. it's sort of more electronic and techy stuffs and i don't blame myself but it's great for th

. >> john gibner and there were sections not amended in the first ordinance and removed from this version all together some changes to zoning coal tables that no longer need to be changed because the ordinance is scaled back. >> okay. colleagues any questions, comments for the sponsor and team in. >> less is more. i am fine with these changes. >> okay. we will open up public comment then. thank you. [calling speaker names] if there is anybody else wish to speak please line up and do this for the next items as well. everyone has two minutes to speak if line up on the far wall. that would be great. >> good afternoon supervisors. i am president of the south of market business association. i remember as a kid i still loved to go to the local cafe in my town and play pin ball and not just games but meet people there and a fun time to have a friday evening or saturdays and so forth so it was a great time to spend with friends and so we feel it's the same thing now. we don't have the pin ball machines anymore. it's sort of more electronic and techy stuffs and i don't blame myself but it's great

. >> john gibner and there were sections not amended in the first ordinance and removed from this version all together some changes to zoning coal tables that no longer need to be changed because the ordinance is scaled back. >> okay. colleagues any questions, comments for the sponsor and team in. >> less is more. i am fine with these changes. >> okay. we will open up public comment then. thank you. [calling speaker names] if there is anybody else wish to speak please line up and do this for the next items as well. everyone has two minutes to speak if line up on the far wall. that would be great. >> good afternoon supervisors. i am president of the south of market business association. i remember as a kid i still loved to go to the local cafe in my town and play pin ball and not just games but meet people there and a fun time to have a friday evening or saturdays and so forth so it was a great time to spend with friends and so we feel it's the same thing now. we don't have the pin ball machines anymore. it's sort of more electronic and techy stuffs and i don't blame myself but it's great